Had a question for those out there for a possible HP/ Ben 10 crossover. Mainly, the idea is the setup.
First idea, Myaxx is on Earth, using a data storage facility for Plumbers on Earth, to gather some alien DNA samples, but trying to leave, her ship fails and she crashes in Britain. Waiting for extraction, she sees the events of Harry’s drop-off at the Dursleys. She knocks to get the baby inside.
You can guess how the Dursleys will react to seeing a Chimera Sui Generis, holding Petunia’s nephew.
Cursing the one time she was brave enough to try and help out, she knows she’s stuck with the kid, as well as some weird information to give Azmuth about a hidden society on Earth, she lies to the Plumbers and says Harry is a Anodite hybrid she was babysitting.
The result, Harry spends the next decade either with Azmuth, or returning to Azmuth after Myaxx sells the cloaking technology to the pirates and ends up in Incarcecon. After the event that lets Ben access Way Big, Azmuth asks Max to watch Harry for a bit, so Harry can spend some time with humans.
“On the bright side, he’s smart even by Galvan standards, at least way above Blukic and Driba.”
This gets Harry back to Earth before the Hogwarts letter arrives.
Second idea, before the Plumbers disband and Max semi-retires, they are called to Britain by the Prime Minister, who was hoping to use them to deal with the magical war. They did not trust the Minister of Magic to do their job, with the propaganda they gave them, and the reality they saw.
The Plumbers race into a battle between Death Eaters and the Order. A few Death Eaters get taken in, as well as Sirius and James. During questioning, a Death Eater tries to Apparate and ends up splattered along a wall, because the Plumbers had some technology to stop aliens that could teleport.
Before further questioning, Max calls his partner, Verdona, to deal with them. As she shows her powers, James and Sirius talk. In the end—and despite Dumbledore’s insistence, they help out. Verdona insists the Plumbers are allowed to help, because she believes magical humans are from a Anodite ship that may have crashed on Earth thousands of years ago, and bred with the people, allowing magic to blossom on Earth.
Comes the fateful night where Voldemort attacks the Potters, they send a call for help. But by the time Max gets there, the Potters are dead, Snape and Peter have left. He gets Harry and orders a cleanup team.
Sirius and Hagrid arrive, causing some more issues. Max insists Sirius takes care of Harry, as he was the godfather. Sirius wants to hunt down Peter. Hagrid wants Harry, because Dumbledore sent him to fetch him.
The results: Sirius runs off for revenge after saying he will get Harry from Max later, Hagrid tries to take Harry and follow Dumbledore’s orders to move him to the Dursley home, but Max stuns him, and takes Harry with him. As usual, Sirius gets captured, and since Max’s only two connections to the British Magical World that he trusted were Sirius and James, he loses contact with them. After Hagrid’s attempt, Max doesn’t trust any of Dumbledore’s allies, and decides to raise Harry on his own, with Verdona coming to help Harry to learn magic, in the hopes he might ascend to an Anodite form.
So, my questions are: which has more plot holes that would need filled, which is more likely, and what issues do you see with each idea?
First idea, Myaxx is on Earth, using a data storage facility for Plumbers on Earth, to gather some alien DNA samples, but trying to leave, her ship fails and she crashes in Britain. Waiting for extraction, she sees the events of Harry’s drop-off at the Dursleys. She knocks to get the baby inside.
You can guess how the Dursleys will react to seeing a Chimera Sui Generis, holding Petunia’s nephew.
Cursing the one time she was brave enough to try and help out, she knows she’s stuck with the kid, as well as some weird information to give Azmuth about a hidden society on Earth, she lies to the Plumbers and says Harry is a Anodite hybrid she was babysitting.
The result, Harry spends the next decade either with Azmuth, or returning to Azmuth after Myaxx sells the cloaking technology to the pirates and ends up in Incarcecon. After the event that lets Ben access Way Big, Azmuth asks Max to watch Harry for a bit, so Harry can spend some time with humans.
“On the bright side, he’s smart even by Galvan standards, at least way above Blukic and Driba.”
This gets Harry back to Earth before the Hogwarts letter arrives.
Second idea, before the Plumbers disband and Max semi-retires, they are called to Britain by the Prime Minister, who was hoping to use them to deal with the magical war. They did not trust the Minister of Magic to do their job, with the propaganda they gave them, and the reality they saw.
The Plumbers race into a battle between Death Eaters and the Order. A few Death Eaters get taken in, as well as Sirius and James. During questioning, a Death Eater tries to Apparate and ends up splattered along a wall, because the Plumbers had some technology to stop aliens that could teleport.
Before further questioning, Max calls his partner, Verdona, to deal with them. As she shows her powers, James and Sirius talk. In the end—and despite Dumbledore’s insistence, they help out. Verdona insists the Plumbers are allowed to help, because she believes magical humans are from a Anodite ship that may have crashed on Earth thousands of years ago, and bred with the people, allowing magic to blossom on Earth.
Comes the fateful night where Voldemort attacks the Potters, they send a call for help. But by the time Max gets there, the Potters are dead, Snape and Peter have left. He gets Harry and orders a cleanup team.
Sirius and Hagrid arrive, causing some more issues. Max insists Sirius takes care of Harry, as he was the godfather. Sirius wants to hunt down Peter. Hagrid wants Harry, because Dumbledore sent him to fetch him.
The results: Sirius runs off for revenge after saying he will get Harry from Max later, Hagrid tries to take Harry and follow Dumbledore’s orders to move him to the Dursley home, but Max stuns him, and takes Harry with him. As usual, Sirius gets captured, and since Max’s only two connections to the British Magical World that he trusted were Sirius and James, he loses contact with them. After Hagrid’s attempt, Max doesn’t trust any of Dumbledore’s allies, and decides to raise Harry on his own, with Verdona coming to help Harry to learn magic, in the hopes he might ascend to an Anodite form.
So, my questions are: which has more plot holes that would need filled, which is more likely, and what issues do you see with each idea?