Sailor Moon Alternate candidates for Sailor Moon

seitora

Well-Known Member
ragnarok1337 said:
Dark Knight Gafgar said:


Bonus points if, say, Ami knows who she actually is and no one else does.
Nyaruko-chan, the anthromorphic personification of Nyarlathotep, one of the only truly evil Great Old Ones?

I really need to watch that anime, if only for the WTF-factor.
but what's the point of a Nyarlathotep-moe fighting Chaos? Breaking it with cuteness?
 

seitora

Well-Known Member
So obviously I just read Hayate the Combat Butler, but Nagi Sanzen'in seems to fit the bill.

She literally has blonde hair and twintails (no odango though), is an otaku with an obsession with manga and video games, lazy, but usually tends to come out doing the 'right' thing. Also, it's implied heavily on multiple occasions that her mother is heavenly favoured, so that's kind of a parallel there with Queen Serenity.
 

bissek

Well-Known Member
"Minnie" May Hopkins.

What will the other Senshi find more disturbing, her career (At the age the Senshi were awakening, she was one of the most successful call girls in Chicago) or her love of explosives?
 
bissek said:
"Minnie" May Hopkins.

What will the other Senshi find more disturbing, her career (At the age the Senshi were awakening, she was one of the most successful call girls in Chicago) or her love of explosives?
Career, definitely. No contest there.
 

ragnarok1337

Well-Known Member
Obviously we need someone FROM the moon to be Sailor Moon. Thus I suggest Kaguya Houraisan, from classical Japanese mythology, or if you want her Touhou incarnation. Of course, this requires her to be born several hundred to thousand years before everybody else. She kind of doesn't age, and is completely immortal in her Touhou incarnation.
 

Ordieth117

Well-Known Member
Dark Knight Gafgar said:
bissek said:
"Minnie" May Hopkins.

What will the other Senshi find more disturbing, her career (At the age the Senshi were awakening, she was one of the most successful call girls in Chicago) or her love of explosives?
Career, definitely. No contest there.
They might be disturbed, but I bet they'd also come crawling for advice on how to get a man.
 
Ordieth117 said:
Dark Knight Gafgar said:
bissek said:
"Minnie" May Hopkins.

What will the other Senshi find more disturbing, her career (At the age the Senshi were awakening, she was one of the most successful call girls in Chicago) or her love of explosives?
Career, definitely. No contest there.
They might be disturbed, but I bet they'd also come crawling for advice on how to get a man.
Cue a <a href='http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PdaeapZHf3Q' target='_blank' rel='nofollow'>Lesson With Candy</a> from Minnie?
 
Now now, killkenny, that's already been done. We're talking about Sailor Moon, not Phantasmoon.
 

TmDagger

Well-Known Member
Dark Knight Gafgar said:
Now now, killkenny, that's already been done. We're talking about Sailor Moon, not Phantasmoon.
Phantasmoon is fusion. Me wants Zelretch induced crossover.
 

bissek

Well-Known Member
Yuuki Asuna.

Unfortunately, shortly after awakening the other Senshi, she decides to try out this brand new VRMMORPG...
 

PCHeintz72

The Sentient Fanfic Search Engine mk II
Hmmm... how about a dark character for a bright series,

Balilaika from Black Lagoon

or

Ayane Isuzu from Gatekeepers 21

or

Suke, from Sukeban Deka

or

Kumiko "Yankumi" Yamaguchi from Gokusen

or

Tsuruka from The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya... a mob heiress like Kumiko

And I know I've mentioned it somewhere before, but Falis from Murder Princess. Man I would actually pity the youma / Generals / Metalia in that version...
 
The big issue is that the 'darker' character the less likely they will be able to use the Ginzuishou, which means bad end for the Earth.
 

seitora

Well-Known Member
ragnarok1337 said:
To be a Sailor Moon replacement candidate...blonde...powerful...believes in the power of Love...AHA!

Marisa Kirisame Then again, unlike most other humans, she has worked hard for her powers, not just given to her by chance.
I went to see if somebody's already done a Marisa as Sailor Moon pic. Needless to say, there was one on DA, but only one.



If this was in modern Tokyo, right after Marisa defeats the youma in the first chapter, she'd help herself to some jewelry before running away before the police appear :D

(and then we could put Reimu in as the black-haired, feisty miko...and what the hey, let's shoehorn Alice in as Sailor Venus, since they're both blondes, both friends of the protag, and I guess strings could be equivalent to the chain. Of course, Marisa and love might make her more qualified as Venus?)
 

Tennie

Well-Known Member
I've been having this idea of a Full Metal Panic! crossover, in which Kaname Chidori is Sailor Moon, many of the other major female characters are the other Guardians, and Sosuke Sagara is Tuxedo Mask.

The bad guys would be in over their heads with this one...and that's before someone decides to try to hook up the Silver Crystal to a Lambda Driver...
 
Kaname might be more of a replacement for Mercury/Ami given her smarts, but given that Ami's a does well in school type and Kaname might be more of a wench wrench it could work. But why would the other FMP girls be the other Senshi?
 

Tennie

Well-Known Member
gemmaethanwhitaker said:
Kaname might be more of a replacement for Mercury/Ami given her smarts, but given that Ami's a does well in school type and Kaname might be more of a wench wrench it could work. But why would the other FMP girls be the other Senshi?
Well, I'm imagining that Teletha "Tessa" Testarossa could be a candidate for Sailor Mercury, considering her own considerable intellectual talent (she's the commander of the most advanced submarine on Earth, and she's of high school age!).
 

bissek

Well-Known Member
More importantly, she designed and built that submarine herself.
 
Lets try something interesting: Safeholdian Senshi.

Sharleyan Alahnah Zhenyfyr Ahlyssa Tayt Ahrmahk as Sailor Moon
So of course this makes her daughter, Alahnah Zhanayt Naimu Ahrmahk, Chibi-Moon
And Irys Zhorzhet Mhara Aplyn-Ahrmahk Sailor Venus, Irys is Sharleyan's daughter-in-law and is described as a younger version of her, which fits with the meta-relationship Venus and Moon have, plus Irys's love life matches Venus', observe what happen after her wedding:

She had absolutely no warning, but suddenly Hektor had his arms wrapped around her, twisting her off her feet, throwing her toward the ground. She stiffened, shock whiplashing through her, and there was a crack of thunder like the end of the world, a brilliant flash half-screened by Hektor’s body, a sound like a thousand hissing serpents, another sound like a baseball hitting a catcher’s mitt, and his sudden, convulsive gasp. There were the beginnings of screams, the sudden realization of terror, and then his weight was coming down upon her, horribly and horrifyingly limp. Something hot and wet sprayed across her wedding gown, her head struck the Cathedral step, and her own frantic cry of denial spiraled into the darkness with her
Maikel Staynair would make a good Tuxedo Mask
Nimue Alban ETL make a good candidate for Pluto, got the mystery down pat and the whole connection to the dead.
Nynian Rychtair might be good for Saturn, but it's probably just me reaching.
Like wise if you want to fill out the whole roster Pei Shan-wei could be Mercury.

What could be very interesting is if these people somehow re-incarnated into the Silver Millennium and then when the magic triggered them to remember their past lives these older ones, the Diet could be in BIG trouble

I'll try and work up a Honorverse Senshi post tomorrow
 

bissek

Well-Known Member
Instead of a girl named Rabbit as Princess of the Moon, Luna finds a burned-out ex-superheroine in a bunnygirl outfit who could bring the moon to life if you fitted it with a big enough pair of googly-eye glasses first (she can animate and command any inanimate object with a face. Normally she sticks to plushies and action figures - which gain functional claws, teeth and accessory appropriate weaponry when activated, but nobody knows her upper limit - she once brought the dinosaur exhibit at the Museum of Natural History to life).

Velma "Velveteen" Martinez.

And her first reaction upon learning that the talking cat is looking for a Princess is likely to grab a phone and dial up the Crystal Glitter Unicorn Cloud Castle and forward the message on to her good friend The Princess, a superheroine with all the powers of a Disney Princess (don't laugh or she'll send a team of SWAT trained raccoons after you).
 
Top