Alternate Guardians for Sailor Scouts

al103

Well-Known Member
#27
My choice:

1. Moon - Better stay as it is. There ARE powers in having pure heart in SMverse. She will be spiritual leader of the team and spiritual only, but anyway...
2. Mercury - when Amy heard that her mother family is whole line of doctors up to before Meiji era she choose to look for her ancestry... and found amulet which summoned spirits of her ancestors - Sagara Sanosuke and Takani Megumi. Then she somehow summons spirit of Sakamoto Ryoma. That Amy will certainly will have a goal to be doctor... just she will have "some" other skills. (Kenshin cross + one underused and not as well known as should be real world Meiji era character)
3. Mars - still lives with grandfather... just he is not only old priest but also mage from Kansai magic association and shinmey swordman. (Negima manga cross)
4. Jupiter - adopted by Hiko Seijuro. Yes, he still lives to that time. (Kenshin cross)
5. Venus - There are some ideas, but better stay as canon - or diversification would be long ago in Sailor V period which could be bad.

Other are better stay as it is for plot reasons. Not a big changes may be... but significant. Senshi would be powerful, but not overpowered and would be in character, though somewhat different. And i really fear changes in Amy...
 

Dumbledork

Well-Known Member
#28
How about having Balalaika or Revy (both from Black Lagoon) as the girls' guardians?

They'd kick some serious ass and Beryl wouldn't last long.
 

PCHeintz72

The Sentient Fanfic Search Engine mk II
#29
Dumbledork said:
How about having Balalaika or Revy (both from Black Lagoon) as the girls' guardians?

They'd kick some serious ass and Beryl wouldn't last long.
...

Bwahahahahaha...

I can just picture it now:


Sailor moon about to dust a Youma.
Venus: Wait Sailor Moon, don't do it.
Moon: Why Venus... It needs to be punished, because we are good and it is evil.
Venus: But Moon... my auntie Revy and auntie Balalika always said, never kill vermin that know more than you do, one must always takes any means nessecary to 'extract' the info. Auntie Revy also said to always have fun when doing it.

Moon and Youma begin to back away in fear at Venus having a sadistic grin on her face while fonling a conjured rope and pulling a gun from stuff space.

Moon: Waaahhh... Venus has gone to the dark side.
Venus: (turning slowly toward Youma cowering in fear) This is going to be 'fun'.
 

bissek

Well-Known Member
#30
al103, it would make more sense to make Jupiter adopted by a Hiko Seijuro, rather than the Hiko Seijuro, as there technically is no such person. Every grandmaster of Hiten Mitsurugi other than Kenshin (who is technically Hiko Seijro XIV) has taken that name as part of the tradition of the school. By making all grandmasters have the same name, there is no temptation to make a name for yourself using the school.

And there is no canon basis for Sano/Megumi. She thinks he's an idiot, he never got over the opium thing, and at the end of the story, she leaves Tokyo to practice medicine in Aizu, while Sano fled the country to avoid arrest on assault charges.
 

SotF

Well-Known Member
#32
Imagine Hotaru being raised by Sousuke Sagara...
 

Luthorne

Well-Known Member
#33
There isn't any canon evidence they didn't wind up together, either, so you can do it however you like. Sanosuke said he would eventually return, he and Megumi are at least friends, it's not impossible to imagine them eventually getting together. Of course, it's not impossible to imagine them getting together with completely different people, Sanosuke returning with a foreign bride, or finding a nice Japanese girl, and Megumi going after a rich man, or a doctor she meets, or someone she just happens to meet and fall in love with. Or, for that matter, neither might wind up with anyone on a permanent basis. Who knows?

Etna from the Disgaea series raising Hotaru. My thoughts for this...from what I understand, Professor Tomoe created an unusual space/time with his experiments, which had the result of attracting Master Pharaoh 90's attention from elsewhere in the galaxy. What if he managed to get in touch with a netherworld, instead, accidentally sucking in Etna, or possibly some other demons along with her...or Flonne to guilt-trip her into actually being helpful. If the accident still kills Hotaru, well, healers, presuming there's one along (anyone bring a base panel?) can bring people back from the dead in town...so, it might be possible. Alternatively, if she could get in touch with the Dark Assembly, they could reincarnate Hotaru, possibly as a demon...but she should still have the soul that was sent forward, so, she could probably still transform with the aid of her sailor crystal. Plus, imagine Flonne and Etna loose in the world...and without a Gatekeeper, they couldn't get back, though Laharl would probably eventually track them down.

...Ami being raised by Jenny from the Disgaea series would be interesting, too, or at least acting as a mentor. Though, Makoto would probably like her as well, since she's a kung fu expert, a genius, and an orphan, though one that got adopted...
 

GenocideHeart

Well-Known Member
#34
Luthorne said:
There isn't any canon evidence they didn't wind up together, either, so you can do it however you like. Sousuke said he would eventually return, he and Megumi are at least friends, it's not impossible to imagine them eventually getting together.
Megumi also outright said she'd be at the window in case Kaoru dumped Kenshin, so her affections are at the very least divided, and she never said anything of the sort about Sanosuke.

Plus, saying he'd return and actually returning are two very different things. Especially with him being wanted by the government more than ever.
 

Luthorne

Well-Known Member
#35
GenocideHeart said:
Luthorne said:
There isn't any canon evidence they didn't wind up together, either, so you can do it however you like. Sousuke said he would eventually return, he and Megumi are at least friends, it's not impossible to imagine them eventually getting together.
Megumi also outright said she'd be at the window in case Kaoru dumped Kenshin, so her affections are at the very least divided, and she never said anything of the sort about Sanosuke.

Plus, saying he'd return and actually returning are two very different things. Especially with him being wanted by the government more than ever.
...yeah, and? I didn't say, "Well, they're definitely getting together, there's no way they couldn't ever wind up being together you fool!" There's plenty of possibility they didn't get together as well, which I think I already said in the rest of my post. Sure, maybe Sanosuke never came back, or came back and got executed by the govenment, maybe Megumi spent the rest of her life pining over Kenshin, though I'd like to think she'd be stronger than that, possibly she snapped and poisoned Kaoru to try and take her place at Kenshin's side, or possibly Kaoru got killed and Megiumi eventually wound up snagging Kenshin. Who knows? Point is, it's up in the air...and thus, as long as it doesn't actively rape anyone's characterization, it remains a valid possibility, since we don't really know what happened afterwards.

And, on a side note...oh, my, a girl/guy who is obviously not the one destined to wind up with the main character/main character's-blatantly-obvious-destined-love eventually getting over said main character at a later point in their life and winding up with another guy/girl? That's never happened in anime or manga at all! <_<
 

GoatMan

Well-Known Member
#36
Rather than Usagi being raised by Peggy Hill, I'd like to see Amy raised by the Hill family (preferably as a study abroad program, she ends up in Arlen, Texas).

And what would she bring to the Sailor Soldiers in their next engagement?

Clean burning, efficient propane!

Well, that and Dale's paranoia, along with a little bit of Boomhauer's accent.

"OhdangitItellyawhat," Amy started as she began entering data on the latest monstrosity sent their way. "TheseNegaverseguys'llneverleaveusalone. It'slikethatdangol'bloodfeud, man."

"Mercury, do you have any plans to stop it?" Usagi asked.

Her face lighting up in happiness, Mercury retrieved a sealed steel tank with a safety relief valve, and began selling the business that was propane, and propane accessories.
 

Typhonis

Well-Known Member
#37
"Rei chan you will need to stay at your grandfathers shrine this summer. The OTHER shrine, in Okayama. I'm sure your cousin Tenchi will be glad to see you"
 

PCHeintz72

The Sentient Fanfic Search Engine mk II
#38
Typhonis said:
"Rei chan you will need to stay at your grandfathers shrine this summer. The OTHER shrine, in Okayama. I'm sure your cousin Tenchi will be glad to see you"
I've only seen one other like that.
 

bissek

Well-Known Member
#39
NECRO!

Ami raised by Fran Madaraki.

She still wants to be a doctor like her mother, but...
 

BF110C4

Well-Known Member
#40
If that happened I wouldn't blame Luna if she believed again Ami was part of the enemy forces, some of Fran's creations are far weirder adn far more dangerous than any Youma, Daimon or whatever other monster you can imagine.

On the other hand I bet you could combine Mamoru and Luna in a compact human head in a cat body, or increase Usagi brain by adding Rei's head to it, or adding half a ton of muscles to Makoto or any number of fun treatments for the weak humans to survive Youmas or...
 

GenocideHeart

Well-Known Member
#41
...please stop. You're giving me the creeps. :blue:

Anyway, my idea: Sailor Saturn raised by a Phyrexian praetor. Because all she needs is a healthy dose of phyresis and she'd be the ultimate Negator.

GLORY TO THE INEFFABLE. :snigger:
 

Prince Charon

Well-Known Member
#43
Usagi raised by the God-Emperor of Man from WH40K.
 

Leonite

Well-Known Member
#45
2 Senshi (with Hakura a definite) fall into a wormhole, and meet the gang of 5D's. Weither this is in The Enforcer/Team Satisfaction Days, post those Days but before Jack makes it big or during the DarkSigner arc onwards would be up to the writer. Obviously at somepoint the wormhole opens up again, and the guardians follow them back to become their legal guardians.

Now that I'vew given you this idea, picture this: The inners are pinned by an unusally powerful enemy, who's resistant to elemental attacks. Suddenly the baddie goes flying, due to the fact that Crow has just slammed into him on his duel runner.

Good idea or bad idea?
 

GenocideHeart

Well-Known Member
#46
Does Crow die in the crash?

If he does, it's an awesome idea. Overwanked piece of shit Mary Sue...
 

S J C

Well-Known Member
#47
Usagi gets sent to live with her distant cousin Akiha Tohno.
 

Leonite

Well-Known Member
#48
GenocideHeart said:
Does Crow die in the crash?

If he does, it's an awesome idea. Overwanked piece of shit Mary Sue...
Nope, only Kalin/Kiryu has any precedent to die, being a future Dark Signer. Plus, if Crow dies the the futuure is screwed for the 5D's world.

*Actually likes Crow*
 

MWkillkenny84

Well-Known Member
#49
No adult member of the Tomoe family survive the lab accident. Hotaru?
Welllll
No guardian for Hotaur, but she'll grow with a cousin of her.
What's her name?
Hayate. YAGAMI Hayate.
Cue on Mistress 9 who choose, after a certain event, to pass from a parasitic relationship with Hotaru to a SYMBIOTIC relationship.
Mistress 9: I DO NOT WANT TO MAKE THAT SO-CALLED CORRUPTED PROGRAM'S END!!!
 
Top