Fairy Tail Discussion Thread

Knyght

The Collector
#26
~NGD OMEGA~ said:
What? :huh:

Nothing showed he died. Took a nasty hit and used a rather potent spell yes, but unlike the guy the thing flashbacked to (Simon I think...) we weren't shown anything similar to an actual death from him. Hell, he didn't even fall unconscious.
Would ya look at that! This author is such a TTLG fan. :p
 

fenixzero

Well-Known Member
#27
Lord Raine said:
Assuming magic can actually be taught, I'd like to know why they can't just teach him fire magic so he can feed himself. It says he can't eat the fire that he generates using his Slayer style. It doesn't say anything about whether or not he could eat any non-Slayer fire he creates.
From his talk with Lucy, I think that he can't eat any fire he makes using his magical power.

Its sort of like swallowing your spit, it doesn't cure your thirst because the amount of fluid hasn't increased.
 

Lord Raine

Well-Known Member
#28
fenixzero said:
Lord Raine said:
Assuming magic can actually be taught, I'd like to know why they can't just teach him fire magic so he can feed himself. It says he can't eat the fire that he generates using his Slayer style. It doesn't say anything about whether or not he could eat any non-Slayer fire he creates.
From his talk with Lucy, I think that he can't eat any fire he makes using his magical power.

Its sort of like swallowing your spit, it doesn't cure your thirst because the amount of fluid hasn't increased.
It's worded as being "his [Slayer] fire." Nothing in there about it not being possible if he learns 'standard' fire magic, though it could be argued that the fact that he doesn't is proof that it wouldn't work.
 

fenixzero

Well-Known Member
#29
Lord Raine said:
fenixzero said:
Lord Raine said:
Assuming magic can actually be taught, I'd like to know why they can't just teach him fire magic so he can feed himself. It says he can't eat the fire that he generates using his Slayer style. It doesn't say anything about whether or not he could eat any non-Slayer fire he creates.
From his talk with Lucy, I think that he can't eat any fire he makes using his magical power.

Its sort of like swallowing your spit, it doesn't cure your thirst because the amount of fluid hasn't increased.
It's worded as being "his [Slayer] fire." Nothing in there about it not being possible if he learns 'standard' fire magic, though it could be argued that the fact that he doesn't is proof that it wouldn't work.
Or it could be that people try to master one magic before they move on to another.

Because most of the characters that we see can only see one type of magic. . .

Do know the chapter that was in? I want to check it against the official English release.
 

Lord Raine

Well-Known Member
#30
About what chapter is it that Natsu first uses Dragonslayer? Specifically the part where scales start to appear on his face?

[EDIT]

Nevermind, I found it. Chapter 98.
 

~NGD OMEGA~

Well-Known Member
#31
Yeah, mentioned it a few posts up. The title of the chapter was Dragon Force, which was highly relevant (And the only reason I remembered the ballpark estimate was 100 was the chapter after Erza 'died', and as she's one of my favorites it was a highly critical point. Lulz were had, tears were shed, and page 25-26 was one of the most goddamn epic two page spreads I'd ever seen up till Whitebeard broke the GAR space continuum not with raw badassery but with raw heartwarming forgiveness).

Edit: Huh, looking back Grandine was the one who met up with Igneel. She even mentions Wendy. How'd I miss that one... o_O

Still not sure from that though if my pet theory is correct just yet... depends if that location was 'real' or not...
 

~NGD OMEGA~

Well-Known Member
#32
http://www.onemanga.com/Fairy_Tail/160/18-19/

... Double page spreads just keep getting more epic. GOD DAMN. The fight choreography, assuming I was seeing things correctly as sometimes it's hard to tell fire from smoke and debris, was damn fine too. Things are coming to a close, and at this point TOTALLY forgiven. Wow. Just wow.
 

fenixzero

Well-Known Member
#33
~NGD OMEGA~ said:
http://www.onemanga.com/Fairy_Tail/160/18-19/

... Double page spreads just keep getting more epic. GOD DAMN. The fight choreography, assuming I was seeing things correctly as sometimes it's hard to tell fire from smoke and debris, was damn fine too. Things are coming to a close, and at this point TOTALLY forgiven. Wow. Just wow.
This is probably the last fight in this arc.

Because I have noticed that every fight in an arc except the last one or two, usually only last one chapter.

It makes everything 'faster' but it can be a bit anti-climatic. . .

Good chapter. I like that he wasn't crazy strong like against Gerard, but then again that could be because Zero is that level. . .
 

Watashiwa

Administrator
Staff member
#38
I'm fucking bored of this manga now. Its so god damn predictable, and there's little to no development of the plot whatsoever.

Anything that was previously overarching and interconnecting seems to have disappeared, replaced by the now episodic; new bad-guy appears. Greater Dragonslayer Power is unlocked, bad-guy is defeated. REPEAT.


><
 

~NGD OMEGA~

Well-Known Member
#39
Really? I liked it. :huh:

It did the thing I theorized, though the dragon appearing was WTFy. And given this was a grand total of one arc that covered the concept of Dark guilds that was covered before, tying back to Igneel's chat with Grandine in which Wendy was mentioned, other guilds, and similarly revealing a bit more about what could only be Mistgun and that Anima thing, I wouldn't call it turning episodic. Like at all. Not the best arc in the series, to be sure, given I favor Erza's arc, but I certainly wouldn't call it complete fail.

Similarly, both Dragon Slayer powers used here were shown previously. Granted the Dragon was New, but that's been hinted at for ages.
 

Lord Raine

Well-Known Member
#40
Timewave Zero said:
I'm fucking bored of this manga now. Its so god damn predictable, and there's little to no development of the plot whatsoever.

Anything that was previously overarching and interconnecting seems to have disappeared, replaced by the now episodic; new bad-guy appears. Greater Dragonslayer Power is unlocked, bad-guy is defeated. REPEAT.


><
Dude. There's only one point driving the plot. Find out where the dragons went, why they left, and what it means. And maybe bring them back. That's one mystery. One thing. And when that gets resolved, the manga will be over.

Exactly how much progress are you expecting? Each arc thus far has involved a bit more of the puzzle falling into place. Thus, I have no real problems with it. It's not like we're having arcs that serve absolutely no point whatsoever.
 

Knyght

The Collector
#43
They just posted a Fairy Tail Special chapter on onemnaga. This is at the front.

So, yes it's official.
 

~NGD OMEGA~

Well-Known Member
#44
Ha ha. Oh wow. Lucy totally got screwed over several times that special. Pure lulz.

Also, how in the hell did Natsu survive giving that dress to Erza? More importantly, why in the hell did she keep it? You know what, screw it, that dress, why? Just Why?
 

Watashiwa

Administrator
Staff member
#45
~NGD OMEGA~ said:
Ha ha. Oh wow. Lucy totally got screwed over several times that special. Pure lulz.

Also, how in the hell did Natsu survive giving that dress to Erza? More importantly, why in the hell did she keep it? You know what, screw it, that dress, why? Just Why?
Ready to ship some Erza/Natsu now?
 
#46
~NGD OMEGA~ said:
Ha ha. Oh wow. Lucy totally got screwed over several times that special. Pure lulz.

Also, how in the hell did Natsu survive giving that dress to Erza? More importantly, why in the hell did she keep it? You know what, screw it, that dress, why? Just Why?
She treasures everything that she's given. It's probably a remnant from when she was a slave. Natsu probably heard that she liked dresses and asked some hilarious questions in a shop to get it.
 

Aegis

Well-Known Member
#47
Timewave Zero said:
~NGD OMEGA~ said:
Ha ha. Oh wow. Lucy totally got screwed over several times that special. Pure lulz.

Also, how in the hell did Natsu survive giving that dress to Erza? More importantly, why in the hell did she keep it? You know what, screw it, that dress, why? Just Why?
Ready to ship some Erza/Natsu now?
I've been ready since the Grey's arc
 

fenixzero

Well-Known Member
#48
Timewave Zero said:
I'm fucking bored of this manga now. Its so god damn predictable, and there's little to no development of the plot whatsoever.

Anything that was previously overarching and interconnecting seems to have disappeared, replaced by the now episodic; new bad-guy appears. Greater Dragonslayer Power is unlocked, bad-guy is defeated. REPEAT.


><
I feel the same way, somewhat; but it prevents the series from being bogged down one major fights.

And I think that its being done that way for the anime animators, that why they can embellish the fights and the arcs to give them a more proper length. Ultimately preventing them from gaining on the manga.
 

~NGD OMEGA~

Well-Known Member
#49
Fairy Tail has always had short fight scenes. I mean hell, a majority of them are usually over in the course of a little over a single chapter (of actual fighting of course), when the standard is usually in the ballpark of three, give or take certain circumstances. Not sure I'd trust the anime to extend them either, as they seem to be rushing a bit, which is rather bothersome.
 
#50
Damnit Knight, I wanted to post that...

:) Oh well, I can still tell you all to look at that chick on the bottom right molesting Lucy. :wub:
 
Top