Flirting, Sex, and the Terror of No Rules in Japan

AJ_Katon

Well-Known Member
#2
goldenarms said:
Another article I came across while randomly surfing. This deals with the reality of dating in Japan, and sometimes bring to light certain things we've come across in manga/anime.

Flirting, Sex, and the Terror of No Rules in Japan

Agree? Disagree? Personal experiences? Discuss!
Informative. Kinda explains alot about the anime I've watched.
 

Contrabardus

Well-Known Member
#3
This is pretty spot on actually. I've dated a few Japanese girls. My first girlfriend was from Osaka. Most of the girls I've dated have been Japanese actually.

I've been exposed more to the culture more than most non-Japanese Americans. I don't mean by way of watching Anime and Manga. That is an effect of my exposure, not the cause of it as is often the case. It doesn't hurt that I can speak enough Japanese to hold a conversation on a better than conversational but not quite fluent level.

My mother's best friend is an immigrant from Japan who moved here in her twenties and we've known her family since I was a toddler. Her three sons are my broest of bros. I've been over there several times. I don't really have an Asian fetish, but Japanese girls tend to like me because I'm familiar enough with their culture that I'm more comfortable for them to be around. I know how to be polite and can pick up on their rituals and go along with them. I'm speaking of women from Japan, not 2nd+ generation Japanese American women. They are a completely different animal.

Don't get me wrong, my dating habits are American. I'm not shy and I'd be considered sexually aggressive compared to most Japanese men, but I understand the expected rituals of the culture and understand how they expect things to work socially. I'm often the only guy around outside their family that knows the 'rules' so to speak, and I don't just mean that in regard to romance rules.

A gas water heater is a must if you're dating a Japanese girl.

Japanese people in general get neurotic without structure. That sounds worse than it is, but generally speaking they expect there to be limits and boundaries in life in general. It's pretty important to the culture.

I think a lot of it stems from both their boundaries regarding physical contact coupled with the concept of coexisting within limited space. Everything in Japan is as compact as it can be and still be functional, and while some contact is unavoidable in an environment like that, it's generally impolite to touch or grab other people. The concept of personal space is both alien in some regards and stronger in others than it is in the west.

For example, expect to be crammed together shoulder to shoulder in public transportation, but touching hands, grabbing shoulders, and generally any active physical contact, romantic or not, is generally considered impolite. That's somewhat flexible in regard to close friends and family when not in public with some limited exception. A rowdy guy friend who is considered a peer might put an arm across his buddy's shoulders when talking to them for example.

Prolonged eye contact is generally seen as passive aggressive as well.

Carrying people on your back is another good example, it's considered a sign of great trust to let someone do that, and generally reserved for younger family members, or someone who is romantically involved. An adult or adolescent male will not want to be the one on someone's back. That's why it's made to be something to be embarrassed about and a big deal when it comes up in anime.

There are lots of rules regarding those sorts of things that are 'unwritten' and generally the sort of thing people are just expected to know. Some are easier for Westerners to get their head around than others.
 

Rising Dragon

Well-Known Member
#4
Contrabardus said:
Prolonged eye contact is generally seen as passive aggressive as well.
I had a male teacher who had been a teacher over in Japan.  He remarked that a lot of his female students had thought he had taken a romantic interest in them because he was used to making eye contact with his students, which isn't the thing over in Japan, like you said.

I dunno if those schoolgirls were appreciative or offended by it, though.  He didn't really divulge on that with the rest of my class.
 

goldenarms

Well-Known Member
#5
It's interesting to think of these things while reading manga now. Before, I felt like a lot of MCs were kind of dumb for not going after girls that are much more bubbly and fun, preferring to stick it out with the crazy tsunderes. Now, it sort of makes sense.

Also it makes me ask interesting questions like "Is Sakura the seme and Sasuke the uke in their relationship?"

EDIT: Holy crap, does Supacat have some things to share! Some of it is just wild... Supacat's Experiences With Sex and Flirting in Japan
 

Contrabardus

Well-Known Member
#6
goldenarms said:
It's interesting to think of these things while reading manga now. Before, I felt like a lot of MCs were kind of dumb for not going after girls that are much more bubbly and fun, preferring to stick it out with the crazy tsunderes. Now, it sort of makes sense.

Also it makes me ask interesting questions like "Is Sakura the seme and Sasuke the uke in their relationship?"

EDIT: Holy crap, does Supacat have some things to share! Some of it is just wild... Supacat's Experiences With Sex and Flirting in Japan
This is accurate, but also from a female perspective.

Ladies in Japan are a bit more flexible and less rigid about active roles. They also tend to be more sexually free than the guys, and I don't mean that in the manner of 'slutty'. Guys are completely messed up and neurotic in regard to sex, with heavy cultural pressure to behave a certain way.

Women are too, but are encouraged more to go along with the guy and be more fluid sexually. Guys are kind of expected to be particular about sex and have fetishes and the women are expected to go along with it.

Without fail, a Japanese woman will just sort of lie there the first time, but are easily prodded into doing more over time.

Having a wingman in Japan is a must, things get awkward fast without one.

The article may be accurate if you're a woman trying to get laid in Japan, I wouldn't really know how that is. However, if you're a guy, this makes things sound worse than they really are. Men tend to lead the way and women are expected to be submissive to them in sexual situations.

Also, you've got to be careful in Japan. Women will often 'resist' sexual advances. They'll squirm and say "no" to touching and push their partner away. This is expected and you are not raping them by continuing and are expected to remain gentle but persistent.

I know this might freak some feminists out, but I'm being serious here. This is actually foreplay in Japan and you're not supposed to stop. If you do stop you'll end up with a woman who is pretty frustrated with you the next day. It's a bit like feeding a fussy baby in a weird way. If a girl is actually refusing advances they'll be more forceful. It's weird and can seem a bit strange at first, and it can leave a westerner feeling like a bit of an asshole, but you really can tell the difference between a girl being 'kawaii' by way of being coy and a woman that actually wants you to stop. It's not really a subtle difference, but can make westerners nervous and feel a bit weird the first time they deal with it. This is perfectly normal and will probably happen the first few times you sleep with any woman from Japan no matter how experienced she is.

After you've been with a woman for a bit and things are more casual and comfortable, it might stop. It depends on the girl, sometimes they'll do it on and off, and sometimes they'll just drop the act altogether. Again, this is not rape, it's a role that women are expected to play in the bedroom. The tune quickly changes once things get started and it's not something that can easily be mistaken for actual resistance.

There are occasions where the woman will not play coy, but that's very rare and generally only happens with people they are very familiar with and have known for a very long time.

Girl on top sex is not normally a first time thing. It's also generally more subdued than it would be between westerners and the guy is still mostly more in control than the woman is. It's actually somewhat like getting a massage for the guy. There is also a bigger focus on oral stimulation. A Japanese woman will use her mouth a lot once she gets more comfortable in bed with someone, and I don't just mean oral sex.

It's somewhat taboo, but not super unusual for a woman to be more sexually aggressive in bed. Often it's associated with S&M or bondage sex and is considered 'humiliating' for the guy.

Once you're dating, it's okay to look at her in private, but don't expect her to make more than a moment's eye contact. She'll probably look a lot when you're not looking directly at her and will look away when you notice. It's a kind of game where you both try catch the other doing things like that without revealing that you notice, but not really. You're both actually expected to notice and just not say anything to keep it going because it's romantic.

Overall, things are a lot easier for a guy trying to get laid with a Japanese woman than the other way around. Don't get me wrong, the guys are usually more willing than the ladies, but the courtship phase is harder for a Japanese guy to get through due to the cultural differences. Western women are often weirded out by the norms of Japanese dating. The male roles are more pronounced and less flexible. Flirting isn't actually as bad as this article makes things sound. You do need to pay a lot of attention to a Japanese woman and can't expect her to tell you things that you'd expect a western woman to. For example, sharing a meal is indeed a thing, and she's really going to expect you to know what she likes without her saying anything. The same goes for gifts.

You're kind of expected to behave in a manner that would be considered incredibly creepy to a western girl. She's going to expect you to watch her constantly, poke through her stuff, and learn her habits. However, you're also expected to kind of do it on the sly and not openly. You do kind of want her to catch you doing it sometimes, but not admit what you're doing. It's cconsidered 'sweet' when this happens. This works both ways, so if you're dating a Japanese girl and catch her going through your stuff, she's probably not robbing you. She's trying to figure you out so she can be the sort of intuitive this article talks about.

This is one reason why western guys with Japanese girls are more common than the other way around. Partially because of the stalker like behavior that is culturally expected, and partially because of the 'roles' expected in the bedroom. Western women have a much harder time dealing with what is 'expected' of them than western men are. Things are less likely to work out between a Japanese man and a western woman because of it.
 

da_fox2279

California Crackpot
#7
Damn, Contra, you're just full o' knowledge, ain't ya? This is rather neat, and it helps clear up a lot of things one sees in Japanese TV and movies that you don't understand, not being from that culture. Thanks for sharing this info.
 

AJ_Katon

Well-Known Member
#8
This explains a few doujins...
 

goldenarms

Well-Known Member
#9
AJ_Katon said:
This explains a few doujins...
I know, right? And with this knowledge in my head, I was pulling my hair out after stumbling in on the second part of Kuro no Kin Hirakanai Kagi.

Character: "If he feels way, then I must properly reply to his feelings."

Me: "No! You fucking DON'T need to do that! He's a creeper, girl! You were correct the first time when you were instinctively repulsed with his actions of trying to rape you in your sleep! He even said it in plain subtitled English! What the hell, man!"

And I never finished watching it. Did not help that my first experience with the show was said creeper dude beating himself off while moaning her name, which was a huge contradiction to the wackiness that I was fully expecting to have happen on screen. A shut-in girl who has powerful hallucinations getting a haircut from a wacky hair stylist? I came looking for comedy, not Perfect Blue: The Sibling Edition.
 
Top