Akamatsuverse Honour Debts - Wife or Mistress(es)?

Prince Charon

Well-Known Member
#1
When Naru puts her glasses on in the hot springs, that first day, she recognizes Keitaro. No, not from when she was two, that would be silly. She recognizes him from photographs Granny Hina showed her (optionally, she showed them to all the girls, but that's not the point). See, the Narusegawa clan owes the Urashima clan some old honour debts (the Urashima might be the Narusegawa's hereditary lords, which would be even more important), and Naru's father wants her to clear the debts by becoming either Keitaro's wife, or mistress.

Naru is less than pleased with the idea, but not enough to ignore giri - plus, Keitaro isn't bad looking, she's had time to get used to the idea before they meet, and she actually knows right there in the onsen that he could have a good reason to be where he is. This Naru may also be a bit more kuudere than tsundere, at least toward Keitaro. Either way, she's less inclined to beat him up than in canon.

Poor Keitaro, meanwhile, has no bloody clue about any of this, as Granny Hina hadn't bothered to discuss it with anyone else in the family, until Keitaro got to Hinata (she called his parents from Hawai'i). When Keitaro calls his parents about it, they give tentative approval, instead of what he was hoping for, which was a way out - they think that some responsibility will force him to grow up, and Granny did tell them that 'mistress' was an option, so there's less pressure, as far as they're concerned.

Not sure how all the girls would react. I could see Motoko being pretty calm about this, as she's a traditional girl, Mutsumi might see it as an opportunity to have them both, and Suu has a daddy and at least two mommies, so she probably won't find it that odd. I'm less clear about the rest, though.

You could have one of the others be the girl with the debts, or maybe have more than one (e.g. Kitsune's gambling debts being owed mostly to Keitaro's father), but while a harem ending is certainly plausible, its not required.

So, any takers?
 

Ordo

Well-Known Member
#2
I think this could work, though I'm going to have to let the idea settle for a day or two before I give you a final answer. I like that the debt can be repaid by Naru becoming his mistress. I know she won't want to do that, but I can see Kanako viewing it as a valid option. Naru takes the Mistress position, and Kanako takes the role of wife....giri is satisfied and everyone is happy...

That won't happen but it's a nice goal for Kanako to work towards.
 
#3
Alternatively, Keitaro's ancestors subscribed to the Genma Saotome School of Raising Children, and thus through a series of wacky and implausible legal circumstances by the time he arrives at the Hinata House he's actually engaged to everyone.

Yes, including Tama-chan.
 

ringlhach

Well-Known Member
#4
Tama-chan doesn't exist when he gets to Hinata House, though... I propose that she/it fixates on him right after it hatches instead, and he ends up with a turtle stalker.
 

zeebee1

Well-Known Member
#5
I think Keitaro had the bad luck to be an Urashima. He's surrounded by bad relatives.
 

Prince Charon

Well-Known Member
#6
Ordo said:
I think this could work, though I'm going to have to let the idea settle for a day or two before I give you a final answer. I like that the debt can be repaid by Naru becoming his mistress. I know she won't want to do that, but I can see Kanako viewing it as a valid option. Naru takes the Mistress position, and Kanako takes the role of wife....giri is satisfied and everyone is happy...

That won't happen but it's a nice goal for Kanako to work towards.
Oh, yes, she would. Mind you, there's still the happiness of the other girls to consider, but that's more something Keitaro would think about, than Kanako.

@Dark Knight Gafgar: Apart from Tama-chan, that's a reasonable alternative. For Tama, I'd go with ringlhach's idea (or, maybe Tama imprints on Motoko, instead).
 

Prince Charon

Well-Known Member
#7
Another idea for this, in the saishodokin/harem branch:

Something causes Naru to believe, correctly or not, that being his wife is not an option, so she decides to try to find a wife for him that they can both accept. Lets say that the Aoyama have a higher status than the Narusegawa, so Motoko would certainly be an option. Kitsune is Naru's best friend, but she might not view the foxy woman as good wife material. Then you have Shinobu, who Naru could dominate pretty well, and who has a very yamato nadeshiko feel to her. Mutsumi would be all for a saishodokin relationship, of course. I don't really see Naru picking Kaolla normally, but circumstances might change that, or she could be brought in (most likely unintentionally) by Motoko or Shinobu. Likewise, Kanako would need to make a much better impression, to get Naru to support her (OTOH, I'm not sure he could marry Kanako, despite the lack of blood relation, unless its a Molmol wedding).

You might pick all of them, a few, or only one (obviously only one would be wife - unless they go to Molmol - but a few extra mistresses are certainly possible, if you really want to).

Then, of course, you have Keitaro's opinion, and he really doesn't want to hurt anyone...

On another note, suppose Kanako is forced to acknowledge that she can't legally marry him (assuming that's true), so she starts pursuing the mistress position, whether Naru becomes wife, or not.
 
Top