Let's Preemptively Judge the Animé Season!

H-Man

Random phantom.
#51
Nobunaga Concerto has a terrible first half, when the protagonist literally doesn't even realize what's going on and acts like a dumbass throughout, but it's stronger on its second half, once he decides that living out the role is better than messing up with history by getting himself killed.

He still acts like a dumbass, though, and the artstyle takes some getting used to. But it could be worse... MUCH worse.

Ranking of series so far:

1: Barakamon
2: Argevollen
3: Akame ga Kill!
4: Momo Kyun Sord
5: Invaders of the Six-Mat!?
6: DRAMAtical Murder
7: Tokyo ESP
8: Bonne Vie
9: Glasslip
10: Locodol
11: Persona 4 The Golden Animation
12: Sailor Moon Crystal
13: Bakumatsu Rock
14: Gundam-san
15: Nobunaga Concerto
16: Terror in Resonance
17: Hanayamata
18: Majimoji Rurumo
19: SurviGaClub
20: AoHaRide
21: Tokyo Ghoul
22: Love Stage!!
23: Nozaki
24: Rail Wars
25: Blade Dance
26: Himegoto
27: Francesca
Bottom Last: Aldnoah
 

H-Man

Random phantom.
#52
Invaders of the Six-Mat!? continues to be fun this week because it does. Funtimes abound as the invaders continue trying to invade the apartment, making use of other plots in their need to fulfill their objectives! Sanae and Koutarou turn out to have the best affinity, but can Kiriha, Yurika, and Tulip overcome this strength?

Either way, I'm tuning in every week!
 

H-Man

Random phantom.
#53
I'm late because I had a con to go through and no new series seemed to have started, though now I need to confirm what the hell is Hentai! and whether or not it applies to this.

ANYWAY Invaders of the Six-Mat!? episode 3. Good fun with the obstacle race - I'm actually surprised that they didn't go with something utterly ridiculous, but still had the cast do some unique obstacles. The winner was actually a surprise, but a bit of a relief too.

I do hope they'll do more magical girl stuff with Yurika soon. As in, validate her issues with evil magical girls.
 

H-Man

Random phantom.
#54
Invaders of the Six-Mat!? episode 4. We finally get some deeper reasons behind the girls' objectives, seeing as how it wasn't truly clear why they would be unable to give up on the room. We also see the girls' feelings for Kotaro start truly working, even if it includes Ruth of all people. And of course, we FINALLY have real antagonists - at least, until the next episode.

I love this show.
 

H-Man

Random phantom.
#55
Final Judgement A

Month's over. Gotta clean this up.

My personal ranking of series I've seen this last month, usually up to episode 3 or so:

The Good
Best Place: Barakamon
This show fits the 'IT WILL SAVE ANIMÉ!' purview quite well. It avoids all fetishism and instead creates an experience where you can actually see and feel the 'life' within the world of the show. It's quite amusing in a manner much like Nichijou, but it does not go for the insane lengths Nichijou is capable of.

Most of the time.

It's reasonable and sensible, it's not stupid, and is proof that you don't need love stories to write a good story. Must Watch.

2: Invaders of the Six-Mat!?
A comedy about one guy and four girls who are trying to take control of a single room. Quite amusing, with harem elements downplayed initially and allowing for a more natural growth so far. The various and conflicting natures of the girls helps make them feel more unique, and although there are a few funservice moments, they certainly aren't pervasive.

I recommend to those who like harems but are bored of the usual clichés. It may not tread whole new waters, but it certainly is an interesting series.

3: Momocute Sord
As if this wasn't going to score higher with me. I gave the original episode a lower score because I didn't like the way it was played or the way the subs were done, but it is made of funservice and, like The Qwaser of Stigmata or Senran Kagura, essentially created for someone like myself to enjoy. I didn't like it because I expected a deep, exciting story and drama, I liked it because I liked the character designs and I wanted to see them in action. And I wanted to see what other changes there would be to the Momotaro story, as well.

It's a funservice festival and it's not bothering me. I don't expect anyone else to like it - never did. As long as I'm not insulted over it...

4: Argevollen
As I described it, this starts off with a very legitimate "Raioh the Animé" feel, and although it certainly is not a Super Robot show, Argevollen certainly acts like one when put against the more standardized mecha. I liked Gundam Wing when I watched it, never really got the issues most people seem to have with the show, and I suppose Argevollen's innate superiority here plays along with that as well. It certainly does feel like a legitimate way a Super Robot would exist within a real military service, especially given the situation at hand.

Not that anyone cares, because you're all so busy with Aldnoah. GODS.

5: Hanayamata
Jumped to top five with episode four. Yeah, I got feels for this one.

I'll admit I still don't like the Keion deal and it's not teaching me much about yosakoi compared to what it could be, but I guess I should let it go because hell, it's like complaining that selector infected WIXOSS didn't teach you the rules. It has a bigger story to tell.

I don't much like the character designs other than Yaya and the eyes look so weird, but I'm bearing with it for episodes like that last one. And besides, I'm sure they'll dance well at least by the end.

6: DRAMAtical Murder
Yeaaaahhhh... complications, huh? Out of my topper series, there's a gay one. There was a freaking gay kiss in episode 3, I can't deny that.

But there's something about this show that I like, guys. Whether it's Aoba's design, or the quite dystopic world... it's just been a sticker on my head. Not something I'm following obsessively, but... well, I liked this more the more I saw. I want to see what comes out of this.

Sometimes it's just something you want, you know?

7: Akame ga Kill!
My description still applies - it's the rebellion against the patriarchy in full. The 'heroes' - as I suppose they can be called - are those who have witnessed the horrors of the main government in charge, and have decided to do something against it. Of course, to do so, they must cut a path through - in blood, always. It's fun and bloody and I don't really want to give back anything.

Except maybe the part where the non-leads are so more interesting. Part of the problem I had with Dragonar Academy - I'm not really interested in Akame or the lead guy. I'm more interested in the other girls and guy who looks like a girl and guy who is gay.

8: Bonne Vie
I like that I finally found subs to this show. It's sort of an annoying thing: too restrained to go all-out like Momocute Sord, and yet managing to avoid the pitfalls of Dragonar Academy. I'll admit I don't like the emphasis on the romance between the two cast members I don't like the most, but then again, it's still early and I still have enough to watch before I'm done.

It still feels too much like early Medaka Box, too. I kinda wish it was more like Medaka Box and had more superpowers. I need to watch more of this...

9: Tokyo ESP
Weird show. It's kinda catchy, definitely more than a few others I've seen this season... but all the same, there's so much making me not want to watch it, that it's annoying. I definitely don't feel like knowing how everyone got their amazing superpowers...

Great start, but it cooled down since.

10: Majimoji Rurumo
Innocent comedy that sends up so many references to SoraOtoshi that I almost wish it didn't play around so much and actually did more similar things, or was set in the same setting or something. Unlike SoraOtoshi, the wishes are a necessity, but are balanced by the fact that our perverted protagonist will come closer to dying the more he wishes.

I'm not sure if I like that. It feels like an unpleasant necessity considering the story will focus on getting the perv and Rurumo together anyway, one way or another.

Plus the fact that there wasn't another witch on episode three wasn't a very happy thing. Not really a major fan, but the humor is bearable enough.

Now stop writing 'Stare' as a word, it's a sound effect dumbasses.

11: Sailor Moon Crystal
Watching this one is easier because it's bi-weekly, I guess. It's got stuff that doesn't appeal to me, like the way all girls wear lipstick and Usagi being so into girls, and the way Mamoru looks when he's not Tuxedo Kamen, but eh. I can bear with it, so far, and even in this season there's been worse stuff.

12: Gundam-san
Ridiculous things happen for two minutes. I'm down with it.

13: Nozaki
Okay, fine, this thing is funnier than I expected and getting over the terrible first episode with its emphasis on shojo romance was good. But I'm still right: the series is less fun if I have to care about this romance thing. When it's about the other characters more, it's more fun to watch.

14: Locodol
I'm following it a little slowly because it is sufficiently embarrassing that I don't want to watch it, but I like the non-ridiculous way they're doing the 'idol' thing. It's not remotely as ridiculous as it could be and the characters do have some nice moments. I still recommend it, at least.

15: Bakumatsu Rock
Yeah, another surprise. I like the music ["Makoto" especially]. Sue me.

16: SurviGaClub
It's ridiculous fun and it has a character who reminds me of Katsu-nee from Senran Kagura, looks-wise, which is always a plus. However, it has a few more fails because it's just a gag comedy and Senran Kagura managed to have more than that, in my eyes. So really, if you don't like girls being shot in the boobs you're not gonna like it. [I don't like that part, no.]

17: Nobunaga Concerto
I'll admit to only watching the first episode, which is the least I've watched of most series I actually liked. The first half of the episode wasn't the most appealing and I admit I've had problems pushing my interest, but... well, it's not the worst thing ever, to be honest. I just don't know if I'm going to stand Notbunaga messing his way through history until the point of his death.

18: Glasslip
Tough watch sometimes. I kinda wish it was more about the glass thing and less about the relationships of the crew going so awry. Besides, even if it's lighthearted... I don't expect enough good things from such scenarios.

It could be worse. But... it's hard to find motivation to watch it. It's kinda like Kana Imouto: you get the feeling from the start that it's going to hurt somehow. And I'm getting it strongly since episode 3...

19: AoHaRide
It's funny. I didn't like it that much. But I'm more willing to put the blame on me not liking lovemance shoujo that much. It's not like 100% Morango, where the characters managed to interest me from the start after I was just curious.

I'll accept that only watching up to the point where I did - which is when the group finally was created - may have been where the story finally got going, and maybe I'll finish it - like Nozaki and Glasslip, both of which aren't bad, at least - but not now.

20: Persona 4 The Golden Animation
I'll admit it. I couldn't continue with it. I kinda want to watch non-Persona 4 after all. Didn't have enough time to bother either.

But hey, as established, people who liked the original series would like it.
 

H-Man

Random phantom.
#56
Final Judgement B

Let's finish this.

The Bad
21: Terror in Resonance
It's a show about child terrorists who terrorize Japan and the adult officers who oppose them. It's Death Note, that's what it really is. But it's made by Watanabe and it's at least not made of terrible designs that'll later go and ruin Castlevania, and I actually like the touch Funimation had in actually subtitling the credits and letting people know who all the people involved in this noitaminA thing were.

I just don't want to recommend it because it's terrorism. It's played straight and bad, and although people didn't die in the incidents used, it's still not a good thing. I'm sufficiently curious about it and I do think it's the best show of this lot, but... as said, terrorism. Don't want, don't watch.

22: Tokyo Ghoul
Cannibals. A guy gets torn apart and his organs are replaced by a cannibal's. He becomes half a cannibal. The story of his trying to live as a cannibal while holding on to his humanity.

It's gross, ugly, and nasty. And damn it, man, it's about CANNIBALS! It's gross and horrible and why did I keep watching this late at night too?!

23: Love Stage!!
Everyone looks so ridiculous, the uke has mood ring eyes, and the premise itself is ridiculous - a guy wants to act with the same 'girl' he acted ten years ago in a happy wedding commercial, only now they both will be the husband and wife, and the 'girl' is actually a really feminine guy. The opening sequence has the 'girl' try on dresses for chrissakes!

Not my thing, obviously, but as said, I'd try out everything that wasn't a sequel this month. AND I DID.

24: Rail Wars
This is so BORING. The characters are so GENERIC. The fanservice is so DULL. The train facts are so UGH. I thought I could muster getting beyond episode 1 by virtue of it being a new and different idea, but 'new and different' does not work with such a boring, boring, BORING series.

I know there'll be better fanservice. I DON'T CARE. This is how uninterested I am - I DON'T CARE ABOUT THE FANSERVICE. And those who know me know how hard that is...

25: Blade Dance of Elementalers
It's Dragonar Academy all over again. Only Dragonar Academy didn't feel so BORING. And as someone in SomethingAwful postulated, you can basically tell all the clichés on episode 1 by virtue of expectation.

Dull lead, generic hags, the closest to original being the school principal being evil. I'll pass.

26: Himegoto
Four minutes of crap I had to watch multiple times to be sure it was worthless crap. GIVE ME THEM BACK.

27: Francesca
Same as above, only worse because the animation was even worse. Ugh...

Bottom Last: Aldnoah
You know, when I heard it was an Urobuchi show, I didn't have much faith that it could be good. I mean, sure, there's Kamen Rider Gaim [which I've lost interest in] regarding 'good writing', but then there's all the other crap he wrote that I don't like. But I went with the 'hey, I'll probably just be disappointed at most' purview and even had some willingness to enjoy the first episode.

I came out of it ANGRY. I HATED that episode. I legitimately hated it so much that it went all the way down to Bottom Last, overcoming Rail Wars - which as said, is a pile of boring - and keeping Blade Dancer from taking the role - a show I have issues from being too similar to a disappointment. And people were claiming something like this was better than Argevollen, which was 'generic' and had an 'angry kid' protagonist? WELL AT LEAST HE HAS ACTUAL EMOTIONS AND ISN'T A ****ING ROBOT, SO I CAN ACTUALLY RELATE TO HIM!

This show is the worst thing to come out of this season and I hate that it has default popularity. GODS!
 

H-Man

Random phantom.
#57
Invaders of the Six-Mat!? episode five! I think it was a little out of place in what it wanted to say. Sanae was, overall, hopeful despite the early setup trying to make her become hopeless, and I thought they'd have actually emphasized that with her trying to get rid of them. The latter part of the combat scene did disappoint me: the group as a whole became useless so that Koutarou could save the day. Still, Kiriha and Yurika were useful in their own ways, and the ending scene was lovely.

Nice beach volleyball, too. While I hope there won't be more episodes like this, I'll like the series if the level is only as low as this.
 

H-Man

Random phantom.
#59
Invaders of the Six-Mat!? episode 6 brings us a big-ass rhinoceros beetle and a cultural fair, as we're moving into Tulip's little arc. It's pretty obvious that Koutarou has some deeper connection to the girls, seeing as how we saw him fall into a pit and connect to what appears to be a goddess before the plot truly kickstarted, but I'm surprised at how the bonding is going. The connections may be a little obvious and I'm going to be bothered if it's a case of convenient amnesia, but...

Kiriha's role was the most subdued so far. I'm surprised by that, in a way... but maybe not as much as I could be. On other news, there's a new antagonist coming up, one which is going to require more than space magitek to defeat. Let's see how Koutarou is going to fix things this time!
 

H-Man

Random phantom.
#60
Invaders of the Six-Mat!? episode 7 settles Tulip's little arc, making Kiriha and Yurika the most useful at settling the plot... outside of Koutarou himself, of course. It seems like he's destined to be the hero our ladies need, one way or another...

I may have criticized the obviousness, but I at least liked how the traits we're shown are similar enough to justify it, after all. And my, seeing Koutarou behave like a knight some times... I wonder if Tulip was imagining all of those aspects until the contradictions were too much. But my, my...

Coming up next is going to be the evil magical girl I've been waiting for! And now we will finally be able to see Yurika be accepted as a magical girl, or will it not be enough? All I know is that I'm going to watch it!

I'll watch Medamayaka later this week. Connection has been crap in a basket.
 

H-Man

Random phantom.
#61
Internet was horrible and my jobs were either very harsh or very covery. So no new series yet.

Invaders of the Six-Mat!? episode 8 starts Yurika's arc with a bang and a half, as we see what an evil magical girl is like. It seems Yurika sometimes is smarter than she thinks or realizes, and we get to see the epic saving action quite early! Which is surprising considering what it results in. It does seem like the cast takes very long to grow and change properly, as nobody still cares for Yurika enough, not that her enemy helped matters any by doing nothing interesting at all. It was still a fun episode, don't get me wrong!

And finally, we learn how Korama and Karama's word-chain games work. They're not good at them.
 

H-Man

Random phantom.
#62
I had to double check it...

Invaders of the Six-Mat!? episode nine breaks the pace as Koutarou was not the ultimate solution, and instead, we see the other girls actually being useful outside Kiriha, who is consistently useful. I'm not sure if I expected what Koutarou's not-girlfriend did, but it was a nice event and it seems like whatever he has, the others are catching. And Yurika's decision at the end was quite impressive! Too bad it came the way it did, in a way...

The way Maki was defeated was quite amusing. I almost thought she'd have blowed herself up instead, but no, she was smarter than that. But I wonder where it'll all go, by the twelfth episode...

Ahh, we're almost done! Only three more weeks, I imagine... and then you people can stop paying attention to this. Until I start posting on the new animés.
 

H-Man

Random phantom.
#63
Invaders of the Six-Mat!? episode ten finally gives some plot for Kiriha, by which I mean it hardly addresses any of her issues unlike the other three, at first glance. It seems like they're going to put every major content piece for her on the next episode. For now, we do have some better examination on her character, but it's still much too little and quite inconclusive. Still, the reveal of the Sun Squadron and the return of this storyline comes forth in good taste.

I also did my best to watch Medamayaki. It's... really hard to watch. Impossibly so. The protagonist is one of the worst people I've seen as far as 'wants my empathy' goes, and sadly he's lacking in it. What a jerk. And the subs sucked, too.

Well, for now I suppose I've seen everything that matters. I'll just keep on talking about Invaders of the Six-Mat!? and another show once it draws my attention. In other news, JoJo's Bizarre Adventure: Stardust Crusaders is currently on break and it's sad.
 

H-Man

Random phantom.
#64
Invaders of the Six-Mat!? episode eleven finishes Kiriha's little arc with a good battle, even if the invaders seemed to be a little too overpowered. We finally understand more about Kiriha and her motivations, but there are some holes in the setup connecting her and Koutarou at this rate. So strange, it is. Ruth's entire obsession with beetles is starting to grate on me, if only because it comes from such an odd thing...

It's a pity the Sun Squadron was as unused as they were, but so be it. The story seems to be longer than I expected.

Sadly, I couldn't find any way to watch Minarai Diva or Nyaruma, and Kantai Collection was delayed for next year. I think this is all I can do for now.
 

H-Man

Random phantom.
#65
Barakamon had a great ending.

So did Invaders of the Six-Mat!?, at episode twelve. I thought it might start a new story arc, but... no, we just got a parting episode. No really resolved feelings, but I think that for a series that didn't really work in the harem focus, that's okay. Everyone is friends and everyone is family. That's quite good, overall.

Today is a day of departures. The end of my favorite series of this animé season. I'm going to miss them, but I'm going to be happy nonetheless. Maybe I'll even start living a little more, hahaha!

Thanks to everyone who bothered to read. Let's see if I'll post again here...
 

H-Man

Random phantom.
#66
Using this thread to spread the word, guys.

Right Stuf is bringing Gundam series to the US once more. The significance of this lies in the fact that we have confirmation that two of the Japan-only works - Turn A and ZZ - will be brought over for real.

There's also going to be Reconguista in G and Gundam: The Origin material. No confirmation on dubs yet from my part, someone please tell me if so.
 

Rising Dragon

Well-Known Member
#67
There's no confirmation on any dubs, just that they're bringing them stateside. G-Reco has some good likelihood of getting a dub, as it's a new show, while the possibility of dubs for ZZ and Turn A are probably slim.
 

gaiamegu64

Well-Known Member
#68
Yes, Turn A! I have never seen a mecha anime where I had a meh reaction to the mech fights, and was more interested in the talking and world building. Also the turn A has such a good design.
 

H-Man

Random phantom.
#69
Okay, so I made my way here. Animés of the Winter Season are going to be diagnosed.

Names are from left to right, up to down, in that order.
Absolute Duo: It's gonna be Dragonar Academy all over again, isn't it? [SEEN]
Aldnoah Zero 2: Pfeh. [NOT GONNA WATCH]
Assassination Classroom: YAAAAAAAAY [SEEN]
Defense Vs. Conquest: I think this is gonna end up like Inou Battle. [SEEN]
Death Parade: Every season needs its bloody death show.
Dog Days": If you didn't like this before you won't like this. [NOT GONNA WATCH]
Doublerarara!! Show: It's a sequel. [NOT GONNA WATCH]
Isuka: Probably the Invaders of the Six-Mat!? of this season, but sounds uninteresting right now.
JoJo's Bizarre Adventure Stardust Crusaders: YAAAAAAAY [SEEN]
Bloody Maria: Sounds sexist.
Fafnir: I'm 50% sure this is gonna involve crossdressing. Also ecchi. Trinity Seven's probably better.
Welcome Home, God!: It's a sequel. [NOT GONNA WATCH]
Kantai Collection: Fine, I'm interested, gonna watch a little. [SEEN]
Happy Meal Graffiti: It's Shokugeki no Souma plus lesbians, I guess. Shaft show, for whatever it matters.
The Basketball Which Kuroko Plays: It's a sequel. [NOT GONNA WATCH]
Rolling Girls: It's a-wait, this might be a Shirobako thing instead. Maybe. [SEEN]
Heroine-less: Okay, is this about the studio or the people?
World Break: Woo, guy has power of light and darkness inside him. Feels generic for some reason.
Sengoku Musou: About time they made a new Sengoku show.
Demon's Contractor: TOTALLY NOT INCEST YOU GUYS
Shounen Hollywood: It's a sequel. [NOT GONNA WATCH]
Fafner: It's a sequel. [NOT GONNA WATCH]
Milky Holmes: It's a sequel. [NOT GONNA WATCH]
Idolmaster: It's a sequel. [NOT GONNA WATCH]
Tokyo Ghoul: It's a sequel. Expect it to be HILARIOUS. [NOT GONNA WATCH]
Tsukimonogatari: It's a sequel for a day. [NOT GONNA WATCH]
Yatterman: Seems to be focused on the badguys this time.
Lesbear: Someone call Raaargh, he needs to write more about Ranma the Bear. [NOT GONNA WATCH]

Not much hope this season, but I'm also not going to watch everything either. Thank goodness too, because fuck Aldnoah.
 

gaiamegu64

Well-Known Member
#70
I have heard things about Milky Holmes. Just remembered hearing about it on MMOgrinder. Anyone know how bad or good it is?
 

H-Man

Random phantom.
#71
Absolute Duo seems to be like Trinity Seven Lite.

It does try to be funny like Trinity Seven was, but it's not that funny, there's some parts where jokes would fit but they're not as obvious, and it took half the episode before it started doing such ridiculous gags. Also it moves pretty fast and I'm not sure how to take it.

Basically, I'm not expecting much, and neither should you, but it seems to be less cliché or boring than Blade Dancer was - one of the two. And at least stuff like 'your entry exam is to beat up your partner' is amusing, but it's just so SHORT!

This is going to be 12 episodes, isn't it?
 

Hoki

Well-Known Member
#72
Tokyo Ghoul: a great comedy show.
 

Hoki

Well-Known Member
#74
It was a joke. Never even seen it.
 

H-Man

Random phantom.
#75
Defense Vs. Conquest is funny enough and, considering it's basically a fukufic minus transgender, I actually am surprised I liked it so. Trinity Seven it is, when it comes to humor, though with a lot more bishounens.

Really, if you like fukufic you should give it a look.
 
Top