Relationship ideas

Old Iron

Well-Known Member
How about we shift gears away from the character death and why things don't work? Focusing on why things don't work really isn't going to produce many ideas since there's an argument for every single possible relationship not working.

I did have a rather odd idea over midnight shift though. Yuuno, as an adult from the StrikerS or ViviD era, is thrown into another timeframe through some manner of very dangerous Al Hazardian artifacts. Said timeframe isn't some long, bygone era but rather the events leading up to A's. Now he gets to interact with the Wolks as an adult when he first runs into them and even his childhood friends. The timeline is screwed anyway by his simple presence, so there's any number of relationships that could be forged there. And not all have to be of romantic nature.

Bonus points if Fate or Nanoha wind up getting dragged along for the ride.

Also, I bought that Yuuno/Signum book. Damn my weakness!
 

Kaijo

Well-Known Member
I'll just note that I'm not trying to debunk it so much. Just that I don't really see the point of even bringing it up. Characters in manga look alike, and have same VA's quite ab it. My rule of thumb is not to to presume there is any relationship stuff going on, unless the characters themselves note it, because eye color and hair color alone is a poor way to judge. Hell, Amy and Shari both have blue eyes and brown hair. Why don't people mistake them for sisters? I wouldn't presume them to be sisters, unless characters in the show began to note the similarities and wonder about it themselves.

That said, if someone wanted to write a fic where people mistook Vivio for Fate and Yuuno's daughter, that's fine. It's all in how you set it up and write it, after all.

I took a slightly different track. :p
 

Old Iron

Well-Known Member
Ahahaha! I remember that one. It was a most welcome find amongst the sea of... stuff that I'd been wading through in an effort to find an appealing fic.

And I suppose all the appearance work is owing to searching for a viable thread from which to base a story idea from. Canon, yeah, no way. Fanfiction... well, we all know the madness that's out there. I'm guilty of it myself. =P

Gods... I recall one idea that was getting tossed around between my beta and I. Yuuno and Reinforce were Hayate's parents owing to dimensional fracturing somehow sending them into the past and onto another planet. By the time they make it back to Earth... yeah. It was insane. I think Young Yuuno hooked up with Fate through Lindy hijinks and then the Materials showed up in StrikerS and Stern had it bad for Tre. I think there might have been two more versions of Reinforce floating around and Old Yuuno had to give the talk to Hayate when she said she was interested in Signum. Oh, and Levi fell in love with Vulnificus and tried to give him a robot body.

EDIT: Typing is hard with a cat on the keyboard.
 

lhklan

Well-Known Member
Old Iron said:
How about we shift gears away from the character death and why things don't work? Focusing on why things don't work really isn't going to produce many ideas since there's an argument for every single possible relationship not working.

I did have a rather odd idea over midnight shift though. Yuuno, as an adult from the StrikerS or ViviD era, is thrown into another timeframe through some manner of very dangerous Al Hazardian artifacts. Said timeframe isn't some long, bygone era but rather the events leading up to A's. Now he gets to interact with the Wolks as an adult when he first runs into them and even his childhood friends. The timeline is screwed anyway by his simple presence, so there's any number of relationships that could be forged there. And not all have to be of romantic nature.

Bonus points if Fate or Nanoha wind up getting dragged along for the ride.

Also, I bought that Yuuno/Signum book. Damn my weakness!
Hmm, this is interesting. Yuuno would probably be stuck between the choice changing history with an unknown future or letting history repeat itself for the future he knows. Chances are he'll probably chose the former.

Now as for relationship... well, since he's an adult here, how about Sachie Ishida aka the doctor who treats Hayate? It doesn't have to be romantic, just a mutual interest in taking care of Young!Hayate.
 

Kireen

Well-Known Member
Old Iron said:
I did have a rather odd idea over midnight shift though. Yuuno, as an adult from the StrikerS or ViviD era, is thrown into another timeframe through some manner of very dangerous Al Hazardian artifacts. Said timeframe isn't some long, bygone era but rather the events leading up to A's. Now he gets to interact with the Wolks as an adult when he first runs into them and even his childhood friends. The timeline is screwed anyway by his simple presence, so there's any number of relationships that could be forged there. And not all have to be of romantic nature.

Bonus points if Fate or Nanoha wind up getting dragged along for the ride.
Interesting, so the premise is that he has to screw the timeline anyway, meaning that that one of the best place for him to show up will be between a Raketen Hammer and Nanoha?

And also which Nanoha and Fate will get dragged along, the adult ones or the young ones once he returns back?

Cause if it's the first case then it's easy game, they know how the wolks fight while the wolks don't, they know where Hayate lives and will probably have battle logs saved on their device they could show around to convince people.

If it's the later it will be more interesting to see the reactions of the young versions to their future selves.
 

keroko

Well-Known Member
Kaijo said:
I'll just note that I'm not trying to debunk it so much. Just that I don't really see the point of even bringing it up.
Because fun. Nobody was really considering this to be a factual argument.
 

Old Iron

Well-Known Member
Kireen said:
Interesting, so the premise is that he has to screw the timeline anyway, meaning that that one of the best place for him to show up will be between a Raketen Hammer and Nanoha?
For the most part, yes. Something that would effectively destroy any hope of not screwing the timeline.

And also which Nanoha and Fate will get dragged along, the adult ones or the young ones once he returns back?

Cause if it's the first case then it's easy game, they know how the wolks fight while the wolks don't, they know where Hayate lives and will probably have battle logs saved on their device they could show around to convince people.

If it's the later it will be more interesting to see the reactions of the young versions to their future selves.
I was thinking the adult version if only because there wouldn't be a way to go back to their own time. The downside there is that it's likely to be a not very interesting story unless one of them is attempting to run a interference plan against the other.

But having one of the kids get dragged back to Yuuno's time would certainly make for a very... complex story. Since one of them wouldn't have existed in that timeline for the entire length of A's to StrikerS/ViviD.
 

Kireen

Well-Known Member
Old Iron said:
I was thinking the adult version if only because there wouldn't be a way to go back to their own time. The downside there is that it's likely to be a not very interesting story unless one of them is attempting to run a interference plan against the other.
I don't see why they would try to interfere with each other, unless they have a very big fight about screwing with the timeline or not, ending up fighting each other. But who's going to be in which side?

Not to mention that it sounds like a cheap excuse to have a serious Nanoha VS Fate rematch.

But having one of the kids get dragged back to Yuuno's time would certainly make for a very... complex story. Since one of them wouldn't have existed in that timeline for the entire length of A's to StrikerS/ViviD.
That or it could go like in DBZ where changing the past creates a parallel timeline, so the one that ends up in the future will meet with the canon characters, and maybe after dropping his tag along back to her proper timeline Yuuno could end up in that timeline's future.

As for the relationships, if Yuuno decides to actually help Nanoha against Vita, maybe she would develop a crush on her savior, only to discover that it's the future verion of the Ferret usually on her shoulder.
 

ragnarok1337

Well-Known Member
Kireen said:
As for the relationships, if Yuuno decides to actually help Nanoha against Vita, maybe she would develop a crush on her savior, only to discover that it's the future verion of the Ferret usually on her shoulder.
Now that'd be a fun twist. And potential for a bit of drama, because Nanoha keeps comparing present-Yuuno to his future self, and finds the younger Yuuno wanting. And the younger Yuuno isn't sure if he should follow in his older coutnerpart's footsteps, and become what Nanoha thinks is her ideal man, or to do his own thing and possibly change his destiny in the process.
 

Old Iron

Well-Known Member
ragnarok1337 said:
Kireen said:
As for the relationships, if Yuuno decides to actually help Nanoha against Vita, maybe she would develop a crush on her savior, only to discover that it's the future verion of the Ferret usually on her shoulder.
Now that'd be a fun twist. And potential for a bit of drama, because Nanoha keeps comparing present-Yuuno to his future self, and finds the younger Yuuno wanting. And the younger Yuuno isn't sure if he should follow in his older coutnerpart's footsteps, and become what Nanoha thinks is her ideal man, or to do his own thing and possibly change his destiny in the process.
It would make for the trappings of an excellent coming of age type of story. And since Yuuno now has this massive decision to make, it'll have some not insignificant effects on everyone else as well.
 
Note that Yuuno in StrikerS is only 19, and Miyuki in Nanoha/As is 17. Not a large age difference. Plus the whole 'Uh, yeah, the ferret you keep cuddling is me when I was a kid' thing. :)
 
Top