Should I?

[H-Man]

Okay, so, first off, some background:

The original post.

The continuation.

Now, to sum it up: I read this fic last year, at some point around the middle of the year. It attracted me, but eventually I lost interest, mostly for the reasons listed on that post.

Then, about six months later, I wrote that 'review'.

The problem is... well, it was far too much time for me to probably judge it correctly, and I sorta became edgy, especially after reading that article from the second post.

So... here's my problem: should I reread the fic, in order to figure out just how off I was, despite the fact that I just CAN'T stand the way the author is guiding the fic... or should I stay with my possibly-wrongful biased opinions without true justice (while they ARE mostly correct, be aware that I haven't read the fic anymore since the first time I read... so my opinions are based only on memories)?

Give your reasons why, though.

As for how I feel about reading it, anyway... it's like shoving a knife through my stomach while cutting off my throat and legs.

 

[Moshulel]

Question: What fic ?

 

[H-Man]

This one.

You see, it's not a badfic like most, with bad grammar and all... it's the plot, characterization, and what-not that sucks.

(And yes, I know this is a bit controversial, since I do feel like I should reread it... oh well.)

 

[Moshulel]

Ok..... just read first two chapters.
Bad points: Pokemon fic ... i don't like them
Mary Sue : Sue them
And i stoped reading ( i don't like pokemon at all)

 

[H-Man]

...okay. So, given anything else... besides the fact that it's a PokÚmon fic, and the main female character, how bad did you reckon it was?

 

[Moshulel]

I wouldn't hail it as "the best fic". A medium level fic in my opinion, but i might be influenced by the fact that i loath Pokemon

 

[H-Man]

Duh... I don't think it's that good either. I was using sarcasm on the title of the review.

Speaking of which, what's your opinion on it?

 

[runestar]

What harm could it do? It's not as if a bad story will shorten your lifespan somehow by making you puke blood or something like that, right?

I would say give it a go. If you want to review something, at least ensure you get your facts right, so it would be good to refresh your memory, however sure you think you are of them. :mellow:

 

[H-Man]

Actually, related events led to a near-shortening of my life, but I don't want to talk about that.

 

[Moshulel]

Actually due to the fact that i hate Pokemon i can't form a subjective opinion. Anyway if youy like Pokemon i guess it's no harm to read it. But i say ney !!!