Good lord... I actually thought this was pretty much over after my last post... (last real post, not that one I thought I had made in the Daily things thread that was mistakenly posted here...)
About the Precia thing, does it matter? Some constitution extend citizenship to all progeny of a citizen. So Fate was under TSAB jurisdiction because she was Precia's daughter (at least that is one way to see it). Plus Fate was taking something that belonged to them (the Jewel Seeds) so I can see why they prosecuted her.
She may have been under their jurisdiction, but even if she was she had no exposure to that society... Which was the point in regards to her upbringing... and in any case I still felt that in the face of her coercion by her mother, she should have been released free and clear with a stern note about not being able to get out of it if breaks law in future.
The TSAB does not really like it that much either, Lindy said she felt bad about having to recruit Nanoha and Fate in the sound dramas.
That is a personal view... obviously if it were official.. it would not be done.
I could understand this were the Belkin wars *just* over with, that is quote clearly not the case... this would be like us using extreme draft and recruitment policies now for events that occurred back before WWII even occurred.
THis is a fantasy show so if it is clearly good based on the show then so be it.
That is really the whole problem with the discussion... the 'clearly good' is what I'm not seeing. And not all fantasy shows are 'good'... Record of Lodoss Wars comes to mind... As does a few others...
Then there is the fact that well Mochidean is probably older than earth in the show with plenty of experience in dealing in a more technological age and growing wiser.
Their experience in dealing with a 'more technological age' is from fear to make large portions of tech forbidden...
Perhaps in time our reality well become like that of the TSAB because its been what 50 years at most we had enough amazing tech to do half of what we do today.
I'm hoping more Star Trek route myself, though I fully realize that is not likely in the least... I'd at least like to avoid the upcoming wars in Trek history...
as of now we don't know a lot about the higher ups of any military or government branch. We should accept it as being good Bearue and not evil since it is fantasy.
And I say again just because it is fantasy does not make it good...
I do think that if it ever came to a First Contact scenario, the TSAB would be one of those organizations that would treat the Earth in a "fair" sense and not screw it totally while protecting their interests.
I do not think the TSAB would totally screw earth over... unless it became in their interests to do so...
No... in such a scenario, I simply do not believe the TSAB would take Earth seriously.
About the Limiters, actually I really think that you might not be getting why they were placed on the three Aces. It was not a case of having Hayate be unable to say fight against an evil plot by the TSAB (I mean the release codes where in possession of allies of her: Chrono and Carim). It was for the sake for the TSAB being able to stop Hayate if she went rogue, or evil.
I've stated it before... hamstringing your top agents, especially when they are assigned to rapid response or high risk missions, is outright stupid on their part... I have no real issue on limiters on lesser agents due to potential for training and loyalty problems... but we are talking the better part of a decade of loyalty by those three...
With that logic, no one can ever be wrong about anything.
Christ are you even listening to yourself?
Sure am... the thing to keep in mind is this...
We as a group have limited canon material to go by... near everything civilization wide for the TSAB being discussed in the thread, and their level of darkness and goodness and what not, is interpretation of depicted events, and interpolating those onto the Midchildean and TSAB society as a whole...
*Two* of three seasons of anime centered on corruption in Midchildean society... and the remaining one a rogue from that society... because she had to (note in no way am I defending her actions, and am quite convinced she was insane by time of canon start)
They (the TSAB ) are not facing some great enemy... they are facing corruption from within and from the byproducts of their own society and the way they operate and function... *how much* of a representation of the *whole* society it is the real issue... I say this is a representation of huge deficits considering it has been repeatedly stated how noble, honorable, clean, and best of best those in the TSAB must be... Yet two thirds the plot centers on their corruption... and more on flack from it.
I still insist the single best model for the TSAB as comparison is Stargate series SG1 command... they did plenty of good, were far better than any bad guys , more stable than nearly any other good guys... and yet were pretty much out for themselves and did some pretty not so good things in parts of that series.... we also had in it government corruption, infighting between branches of military, and issues with chain of command... and politics interfering with effectiveness.
The TSAB isn't perfect. No governing body is. Everybody tends to do things to fulfill their self interests. Some people just think that their self-interests are the same as whatever beliefs they think are correct.
This... I agree with...
Take a look at Gil Graham and Regius Gaiz, they have noble goals: Graham wanted to protect the dimensions from the threat of the Book of Darkness, Regius wanted to strengthen the ground forces without relying on powerful mages to protect Mid-Childa.
This is where we diverge. You and me have differing views of noble goals...
A noble goal is *not* noble if you or the society you are a part of judge your actions to do it as wrong... both these guys knew full well what they were doing, and it did not stop them... I've listed Grahams crimes as I saw them elsewhere in this thread already, I'm not re-listing them... and before it is mentioned that is *my* interpretation of his crimes, it is... but I seriously doubt the TSAB liked very much what he did in regards tot heir personnel or resources.
With both... it went beyond goals... becoming both crime(s) and an obsession to them... a very unhealthy one considering what they entailed.
Also keep in mind that the TSAB is by essence, a young organization. It hasn't even existed for a hundred years, evidenced by the fact that their founding members are all still alive, so there are still a lot of work to be done, cleaning up the messes that the Ancient Belkans left, while keeping stride with the new threats that may appear on any part of their jurisdiction.
Heh... you guys cannot have it both ways... one is arguing because they are a older society than us they are more enlightened and good because of that age... and you are defending the darkness/corruption because they are newly formed...
Even just from the Belkin wars 150 years is not a short time...
By that reckoning, the U.S. is *much* younger than the nations of Europe... but I do not really see them as all that better and in some cases worse... Egypt is certainly older, and look what is occurring there as we discuss this...
A society is good or bad based on its actions and moral outlook, obviously the standard will vary asked on whom is doing the judging...
Age does not equate good or wise, or bad or dumb...
To make this clear i don't agree with his "TSAB is eeeeviiil" argument but i do simpathize with his right to defend his stance. The fact so many about the bureau's higher ups still remains a mistery also makes difficult to apport solid evidence xDU
This is actually one of the nicest statements in the thread... For the record... I am not saying they are evil... I do disagree with a ton of their stances and actions...
Well, Copernicus was mocked and ridiculed when he said that the Earth revolves around the sun, because everyone believed it was the other way around. Who's laughing now?
Well... Galileo was pardoned after 502 years... I can hold out hope someday you guys will see my point of view... but I doubt it.
@Kaijo
I'm going to parody your scenario....
Imagine, if you will, a nightmarish creature emerging from a black dome in the ocean. A number of mages gather above it, fight it. And finally, three powerful young girls gather to hit it with a Triple Breaker...
Nanoha: "Starlight..."
Fate: "Plasma Zanber..."
Hayate: "Ragnarock..."
PCHeintz: "WAIT! STOP!"
Nanoha: (pausing) "Huh? Why?"
PCHentz: "You cannot fire off those attacks.... you have to ask the monster to pause in its activities, let you call in and ask for permission, have them debate it, have them vote on it, have them approve it, then call back allowing for the power up..." .
Nanoha: "..Is he for real?"
Hayate: "I'm afraid so..." "I'll call it in"
PCHeintz: "I have some nuclear, biological and chemical weapons for you to use instead! It may not be safe, but it should prove effective, and BETTER because I have some right over there!"
Hayate: "I'm afraid not... we, or rather our adopted society, has a fear of tech and we would not even know how to use it..." "I've made the call... can you wait Mr. Monster"
Monster: RAAAAR.....
PCHeintz: Sighs.... "I knew he would say that"
(The three girls look at it and each other, and pray for deliverance and the speed of their politicians).
A minute later...
(PCHeintz and Nanoha and company are all dead... because politicians were really stupid sending in top agents with limiters and thus them, innocent civilian #1 (PCHeintz) whom attempted to help, and a whole ton of people and a decent sized portion of the city they were in are all gone... the city due to orbital bombardment from safe magical weapons, even if the weapon could not kill people.. falling debris and destroyed material and unsafe monster guts did)
Without his cheats/warnings, Jail was caught completely off guard.
But Jail would have had no reason to bother with any form of defense or true hiding... *because* he had inside information and supposedly believed he would be informed...
Your cynicism is based on belief. You're arguing that Santa can't fly his sleigh because he's too fat and heavy, and the rest of his us saying, "Dude, Santa isn't real."
PC, we've gone several pages now. Put your evidence up. Show us, from the source material, how the bad things totally ruin the Bureau because of magic. Because you have exactly 1 example with the brains and Regius, out of several incidents that we've seen.
It's time for you to put up. Show your evidence.
I could argue the idealism you guys and ascribe to these guys is just as based on belief...
Shrugs... I've been answering stuff all along... realistically... both views are based merely off stuff in the series... we merely came away with diametrically opposed views of it...
I agree that it is not real, I do not agree as some here are putting it that due to it being fantasy, or due to them being older, or more experienced, automatically makes them 'better'...
Mistakes are mistakes... you can blame their politics or make excuses for plenty of stuff... ascribe noble goals to people whom lost their sense of right vs. wrong... it does not change that all these things are occurring...
They are not perfect, they are not something like the last bastion of all the is light and good and pure in the world to hold against the darkness... They are not the greatest thing since sliced bread... ditto for Magic... both magic and tech have their place. A society turning their back on knowledge is to me repugnant...
Neither of us seems to really get the other side...
Heh... when I made that first post... on 'safe' use of magic... I should have known it would blow outward form there to go this route....