I'm not a Wimmer fan or anything. I hated Ultraviolet. But I still enjoyed Equilibrium. Sure it looks like it had not much of a budget (soldiers with motorcycle helmets?) but it seemed to me they did pretty well with what they had. Yes it's very derivative, just like most everything else these days. Yes the action is not realistic, but it looks stylish, so who cares? It's not like action in movies ever is. It's a lot more believable than having people fall 20 feet and rebound off the surface of a lake by stabbing it with a sword. More believable than using a car to kill a helicopter.
The reviewer there also somehow missed what any idiot should be able to see. When Preston claims he's not feeling, his superiors clearly DON'T buy it. It's obvious Prozium doesn't kill off all emotion, it just numbs them. Sense offenders are killed as a deterrent, and because they'd probably just stop taking the drug again anyway. It's clear that the leaders of government aren't on the drug. And the society is brought to its knees when bombs destroy the Prozium factories, not when the screens are shot.
As for Dune, I figured it would be better to at least see it and then judge whether it was worth getting the thrice as expensive collector's edition. If I don't like it it's no big deal. It was cheaper than the lunch I had that day.