Harry Potter What fits best?

[the DragonBard]

Okay, assuming that you could take the HP characters and plop them into other fantasy worlds to learn magic, which characters would you pick for which worlds, and why?

I'd have Hermione in Magic: the Gathering as a Blue/White mage, or D&D as a Wizard/Loremaster.

Reasons: Hermione is an intellectual, which covers Blue, and tends to believe in order and rules, which covers White.

Being a brain and a human encyclopedia also covers Wizard/Loremaster as well.

 

[kingdark]

ron would be a fanatical cards player of yugioh, strategy is inportant, and with the right cards, he would be unbeatable.

spelling sucks right now, but i have a headache, so for now bear with it will ya?

 

[David Alan Abramczyk]

I can't explain for the life of me why, but the idea of Neville Longbottom at Mahora Academy fills me with a sense of child-like glee.

 

[tungsten]

I forget the name of it, as I never saw it, but a friend described this anime to me.

There are only a cetain number of spells everyone can use in their lifetime, and after using them all up, you die.

I'd put Voldemort in that world.

Right before he's about to crush that annoying Potter boy once and for all, he casts his last spell and bites the big one.

Should've kept count, huh?

 

[David Alan Abramczyk]

I know the one you're talking about. Dunno the name though.

 

[Dubrichius]

I forget the name of it, as I never saw it, but a friend described this anime to me.

There are only a cetain number of spells everyone can use in their lifetime, and after using them all up, you die.

I'd put Voldemort in that world.

Right before he's about to crush that annoying Potter boy once and for all, he casts his last spell and bites the big one.

Should've kept count, huh?

I have a very strong suspicion that it's Maburaho that you're thinking about.

 

[tungsten]

I forget the name of it, as I never saw it, but a friend described this anime to me.

There are only a cetain number of spells everyone can use in their lifetime, and after using them all up, you die.

I'd put Voldemort in that world.

Right before he's about to crush that annoying Potter boy once and for all, he casts his last spell and bites the big one.

Should've kept count, huh?

I have a very strong suspicion that it's Maburaho that you're thinking about.

The name sounds about right, though I couldn't say for sure, of course.

 

[Prince Charon]

I forget the name of it, as I never saw it, but a friend described this anime to me.

There are only a cetain number of spells everyone can use in their lifetime, and after using them all up, you die.

I'd put Voldemort in that world.

Right before he's about to crush that annoying Potter boy once and for all, he casts his last spell and bites the big one.

Should've kept count, huh?

I have a very strong suspicion that it's Maburaho that you're thinking about.

The name sounds about right, though I couldn't say for sure, of course.

Is that the one where the protagonist has about eight spells to start with, is prophecized to have extremely powerful children, uses up all his spells to save the girls who are trying to get into his pants, and then becomes a ghost?

 

[the DragonBard]

I forget the name of it, as I never saw it, but a friend described this anime to me.

There are only a cetain number of spells everyone can use in their lifetime, and after using them all up, you die.

I'd put Voldemort in that world.

Right before he's about to crush that annoying Potter boy once and for all, he casts his last spell and bites the big one.

Should've kept count, huh?

I have a very strong suspicion that it's Maburaho that you're thinking about.

The name sounds about right, though I couldn't say for sure, of course.

Is that the one where the protagonist has about eight spells to start with, is prophecized to have extremely powerful children, uses up all his spells to save the girls who are trying to get into his pants, and then becomes a ghost?

Yes.

In this world, the number of spells you are born with is an indicator of how powerful the spells you can cast. The MC is rare in the fact that, while he was born with a low number of spells, when he uses them, they are often in the upper echelons of power.

And it is Maburaho.

 

[Lord of Bones]

From D&D;
Lord Voldemort - NE Male Gravetouched Human Necromancer/Archmage
Harry Potter - NG Male Human Wizard/Fatespinner
Albus Dumbledore - NG Male Human Wizard/Loremaster/Archmage

Fatespinner accounts for Harry's luck. Dumbles strikes me as a loremaster with archamge levels to account for the greatest wizard in the world shtick. Riddle is a necromancer, but you can drop the archamge and replace it with master necromancer or nightmare spinner.

 

[SotF]

From D&D;
Lord Voldemort - NE Male Gravetouched Human Necromancer/Archmage
Harry Potter - NG Male Human Wizard/Fatespinner
Albus Dumbledore - NG Male Human Wizard/Loremaster/Archmage

Fatespinner accounts for Harry's luck. Dumbles strikes me as a loremaster with archamge levels to account for the greatest wizard in the world shtick. Riddle is a necromancer, but you can drop the archamge and replace it with master necromancer or nightmare spinner.

Voldemort doesn't quite fit as a Necromancer. He's more of a generalist though with spell focus (Evil) or the like.

Harry has a TON of Luck feats to mess with

 

[Lord of Bones]

From D&D;
Lord Voldemort - NE Male Gravetouched Human Necromancer/Archmage
Harry Potter - NG Male Human Wizard/Fatespinner
Albus Dumbledore - NG Male Human Wizard/Loremaster/Archmage

Fatespinner accounts for Harry's luck. Dumbles strikes me as a loremaster with archamge levels to account for the greatest wizard in the world shtick. Riddle is a necromancer, but you can drop the archamge and replace it with master necromancer or nightmare spinner.

Voldemort doesn't quite fit as a Necromancer. He's more of a generalist though with spell focus (Evil) or the like.

Harry has a TON of Luck feats to mess with

Undead, phylacteries, immortality - that more-or-less sums up evil-necromancer-lich-wannabe. At least, he'd have Spell Focus (Necromancy).

 

[GenocideHeart]

In Magic: the Gathering terms, Voldemort would be a monoblack control deck with artifacts thrown in. Basically, a Phyrexian wannabe.

...except he's too INEPT to be a Phyrexian. Phyrexian!Voldy would be actually scary.

 

[BakaNeko]

Are we talking about what fits best or what I'd like to see? Because the Harry, Hermione and Ron from the first 3 books would fit SO well in the Rayearth universe. Sticking together and what not.

...Rayearth, why the hell did THAT come up?

Anyway what I'd like to see is the ENTIRE Hogwarts characters transplanted into Mx0. There aren't any evil baddies yet, just wholesome school competition.

Actually I'd love it if Harry was set in the Taiga Kuzumi role, and maybe Luna as Aika Hiiragi.

 

[Solarman]

M:tG... hm... Based on their personalities:

Hermione would be U/w, she's more into the knowledge of magic than justice, but she still believes in justice and the light. Azorius after Dissension.

Ron would be W/r. Interested in justice and maintaining the light, but impulsive and passionate, even if he is a good strategist. Boros.

Harry would be... hm... he's tough to place. He's a bit of everything other than Black, but mostly white, I think.

Dumbles was mono-U. No question about it, and Moldybutt was mono-B/artifacts. Phyrexian wannabe indeed.

Luna is a perfect Izzet candidate, U/r... chaos and logic combined...

Snape is weird, sorta B, sorta R, sorta w. He's a very dark (black) mage, but he's a traitor to the darkness because of his emotions (red, somewhat white)... which are not so wholesome (red/black), but enough to drive him to fight the Dark Lord and support the light (white to an extent)....

Draco is another weird character, B/w, I think. He's an amoral jackass for the longest time, but he can't quite drop the last of them, so he's not completely black, but he's nowhere near main-white.

The Weasley twins are R/u, Izzet experimenters as well. But they're the kind of Izzet who do what they do from the enjoyment of the chaotic side of their magic.

Hagrid's mono-g, or G/r.

Other characters are not so well-defined, so they're harder to place.

 

[GenocideHeart]

Harry is like one of those weird Nephilim decks that are a jumbled mess of cards and try to do everything and accomplish NOTHING....

 

[Souffle]

You guys know a creepy amount about MtG. I don't even know what tapping is...


In other news, I could see Harry being Emiya Shirou. Would this be better or worse? We'll see after his luck rolls :V

 

[SotF]

Voldie plays L5R with a Shadowlands deck...
Harry plays Spycraft, not sure which faction, possibly just Freelance.

 

[The Eromancer]

HAH!! Could you imagine all of them being in the Slayers universe?

 

[Lord of Bones]

From D&D;
Lord Voldemort - NE Male Gravetouched Human Necromancer/Archmage
Harry Potter - NG Male Human Wizard/Fatespinner
Albus Dumbledore - NG Male Human Wizard/Loremaster/Archmage

Fatespinner accounts for Harry's luck. Dumbles strikes me as a loremaster with archamge levels to account for the greatest wizard in the world shtick. Riddle is a necromancer, but you can drop the archamge and replace it with master necromancer or nightmare spinner.

Draco Malfoy - CN Male Human Sorcerer
Severus Snape - LE Male Human Wizard/Master Alchemist
Dobby - LG Small Male Fey
James Potter - LG Male Human Wizard/Master Transmuter

 

[the DragonBard]

I can't explain for the life of me why, but the idea of Neville Longbottom at Mahora Academy fills me with a sense of child-like glee.

Neville would be a D&D Druid, or a M:tG Green.

 

[the DragonBard]

In Magic: the Gathering terms, Voldemort would be a monoblack control deck with artifacts thrown in. Basically, a Phyrexian wannabe.

...except he's too INEPT to be a Phyrexian. Phyrexian!Voldy would be actually scary.

Actually, Voldie strikes me more a Black/Red, maybe with some Blue.

Remember, Red specialises in destruction and rage, which is definitely something Voldie would fit with. Blue for mind control and cunning.

 

[the DragonBard]

James Potter - LG Male Human Wizard/Master Transmuter

Actually, I'd figure he's NG Sorcerer/Arcane Trickster.

 

[SotF]

Dobby is more of a Chaotic Good character.