HP/FSN

[JackofDeath2445]

I hope I'm the first guy who asked of this.

A Harry Potter and Fate: Stay Night xover, Here is some simple requirements:

1)No Slash!!!!!
2)Logical cause for the crossover(How did harry get to FSN universe)
3)pairing: Hp/Rider or Hp/Harem

That is all, if you guys can put some lemon on it then that will be great. But you don't have to. I don't really care if it is rated K or NC-17 as long as there is some good action scenes on it. Evil HP characters is encouraged but it's your choice to decide to depict them as evil or not.

Anybody want to take it?

 

[zeebee1]

The first thought that comes to minds is that Harry is a legend in the wizarding world. He'd have low stats, but he'd probably be a caster anyways.

Though he'd be pathetic even for a caster.

 

[Mereo Flere]

Can Harry die in this challenge?

Because, that's the only thing I see him doing if he's summoned as a servant and, truth be told, he doesn't even match the weakest one, Avenger. Even if he's somehow a Master, he'd be screwed simply because magic works differently, and supplying prana alone would be a major issue in the Holy Grail War.

Now, if he wasn't fighting, it becomes more doable, but considering that you're asking for action scenes, as well as a pairing/harem, it's hard to do a story like that without having it feel forced. Evil Harry Potter would allow for dirty tactics to be used, to even up the sides, but then that's an OC pretending to be Harry Potter inside of a crossover that you'd also have to be able to build up an emotional connection with at least one other character.

It's possible to do it, but it would take simply too much effort to make it worthwhile.

That, or make it a crackfic.

But, well, you can do that with anything.

 

[JackofDeath2445]

The Harem thing is just a choice, you can not choose to do that if you don't like it. I know of the problem with the mana. it was the main thing on that a bunch of guys argued about in the FSN forum. Can't we just solve that problem with some kind of compromise ? Evil Harry Potter would be acceptable so long as he kills many wizards from his world. Look to make Harry less OC, make him crack! Any human would have cracked under the pressure he has gone through. It would make him less Oc and more human.

 

[Mereo Flere]

A compromise?

Well...

I don't plan to write this myself, but I can help sort out the details if someone really feels like they want to do this. There was a Ranma crossover with Fate/Stay Night, that seems to have a good foundation, but that's because it had a lot of thought put into it.

 

[Fatuous One]

...

Maybe you could actually make a challenge instead of "please write this crossover for me!"

 

[JackofDeath2445]

Fine...... <_< Dont care what you guys do to it. Can someone just write a 'good' xover of this? Oh yea, Fatuous One do you have any solutions with the mana problem?

 

[Mechatrill]

Huh... F1, didn't you have some HP/FSN stuff written up? I remember seeing some snippet or another about that in your dumping groungs...

 

[Fatuous One]

Hm?

Oh, yes, I did.

That was a parody, following the Wizard of <s>Oz</s>Hogwarts as he follows the shiny, gravel pathway and tries to figure out what the fuck is going on.

I never planned on continuing it ('though, I never 'plan' anything). It was merely a random thought I had.