Ranma as a girl

AbyssalDaemon

Well-Known Member
#1
What the hell is with the recent surge of having girl!Ranma stories? It's getting to be almost impossible to find any good Ranma stories with him as a guy on sites like fanfiction.net.
 
#2
We can blame Fukufics for that I think.
 

Moshulel

Well-Known Member
#3
AbyssalDaemon said:
What the hell is with the recent surge of having girl!Ranma stories? It's getting to be almost impossible to find any good Ranma stories with him as a guy on sites like fanfiction.net.
Yes, that's really annoying, nevermind you the fact that most of them ignore the way Ranma is.

Yay! I was a male for all my life and now in just a few short months i accept being female! :angry:
 
#4
now THAT is something i'd never write...

though i'd rather let the female side out to wreak havoc on the NWC...

Only person of them who would survive would be Genma... and that is only because Patricide would be considered unmanly...

the rest of them :lonegunman: :flameon: :evil:
 
#5
What about Shampoo? I'd hit it.
 

Dubrichius

Well-Known Member
#6
Dark Knight Gafgar said:
What about Shampoo? I'd hit it.
Don't forget Kasumi. She's someone you can never stay angry at.
 
#7
True. But I mean, even long-haired Akane was more hittable than Kasumi. You'd just have to crack the shell first (through torture).
 

SimmyC

Well-Known Member
#8
Yeah, Fukufics is probably to blame with the wave of girl!Ranma! Of course it is hard to find original good ideas before. Just that, I doubt girl!Ranma is the way to go. :no:

As for which one is hittable, of the character designs that I have seen, I'd probably go with Shampoo or even Nabiki. Heck, Ukyo isn't that bad looking either when she looks feminine. That being said, Kasumi is also nice on the eyes and her personality and attitude certainly helps in this field too.

That being said, I was never a 'huge' fan of Ranma's art. Decent, but well, I guess I'm more used to the more traditional 'anime' look of recent series.
 

cilrais

Well-Known Member
#9
I'm alright with the occasional girl!Ranma fic, as long as rape and/or pregnancy isn't involved.
 

Hawk

Well-Known Member
#10
If it's ( extremly ) well written, I can deal with those as well.

The problem is finding such fics, as most of those involving Ranma getting preggers or raped are utter crap.
 

toraneko

Well-Known Member
#11
Dark Knight Gafgar said:
But I mean, even long-haired Akane was more hittable than Kasumi.
Haha, yeah, that's a good one. Seriously this time.
 
#13
Fatuous One said:
True. But I mean, even long-haired Akane was more hittable than Kasumi. You'd just have to crack the shell first (through torture).
Who'd hit that, a dog?
Completely disregard her... charming... personality and only take her body into account. Yes, I'd most definitely hit that.
 
#15
Whatever you say.
 

SimmyC

Well-Known Member
#16
I'll have to go with the majority here. Discounting again her personality, while Akane might not bad looking by any stretch of the imagination, I still prefer the others over her. Certainly when you compare Shampoo or even Kasumi, IMO, Akane just... doesn't compete. All IMO of course.

And again, this disregards her 'spiffy' personality. Heck, in the case of Love Hina for example, I can acknowledge that Naru is a babe. I may prefer Motoko and Mutsumi's look over her, but that doesn't take away the fact that she is a babe. Akane? Not so much. Again not bad, but not something I'd 'hit' first either.
 
#17
Thus far I've only read the first volume of Ranma 1/2 (and I'm not likely to be reading much farther than that, as the only book store that sells manga in my area only has copies of volume 1 and volume 32 available, and I'm sure as hell not skipping 31 volumes), so I can't really say much on the other girls like Shampoo and Ukyo who haven't appeared by the end of volume 1, but I can say with full confidence that I'd do each and every single one of the Tendo girls. Except post-haircut Akane. Hell, even the state of her hair after it got sliced up by Ryoga was better than after she had Kasumi go over it. It'd almost look better if she shaved it off entirely (almost). Normally I don't give a shit about hair - I'm more interested in what's below that part - but for some reason short-haired Akane has about as much sex appeal to me as a female Tauren.
 

cilrais

Well-Known Member
#18
Dark Knight Gafgar said:
but for some reason short-haired Akane has about as much sex appeal to me as a female Tauren.
There is definitely some female tauren fanart floating around that is hotter than short-haired Akane, and I'm not even much of a furry fan.
 

GenocideHeart

Well-Known Member
#19
I actually have to agree with DKG. Kasumi isn't hot, she's cute. Even long-hair Akane is higher in the hot-o-meter than Kasumi.

Short haired Akane fails, though.
 
#20
QFT.

And for those of you who've forgotten again, for me that means "Quite Fucking True".
 
Top