Star Wars Prequel Trilogy

drakensis

Well-Known Member
#1
Here's a challenge that came up when I was chatting to a few friends about what we would like to see done given the current run of reimagined TV series.

Take the original Star Wars trilogy and plot out a different (preferably better) story and universe for the prequels without contradicting the information in A New Hope, Empire Strikes Back or Return of the Jedi (something that the actual prequels had trouble with). (Alternately, what would the prequels be like if only the first movie was canonical). Feel free to work only with the information presented during the films, without any extra information from scripts (for example, the word Sith is not used so far as I am aware).

Bonus points awarded for:
- no visits to Tantooine (really, it's the arse end of everywhere)
- no chibi-Anakin.
- no Jedi wearing desert robes: Luke's outfit in RotJ should be representative
- break up or dispense entirely with the droid duo

For example, instead of clone troopers, what if the Clone Wars were a series of conflicts between the Republic's member states provoked by clone imposters who had replaced high officals and heads of state.
 

Prince Charon

Well-Known Member
#3
drakensis said:
For example, instead of clone troopers, what if the Clone Wars were a series of conflicts between the Republic's member states provoked by clone imposters who had replaced high officals and heads of state.
I like that idea. IIRC, there was a thread like this on Spacebattles.com, though I doubt I'd be able to find it, again. One memorable suggestion had Anakin already an adult, a fighter pilot in a local defense force, I think, by the time Obi-wan met him.
 

Watashiwa

Administrator
Staff member
#4
Reminds me of the Return of the Jedi rewrite contest some guys over on Stardestroyer.net have going.

Same idea, just with Episode VI. And they're giving out prizes.

What's interesting is that they've got some of the early scripts for RotJ, so those are being used as references in some of the rewrites.
 

ttestagr

Well-Known Member
#5
About the clothes, what about something like Obi-Wan was wearing? Except that almost every poor to middle class person wears the same.

With very few jedi considering a galactic population, they generally fit in by wearing extremely average, unremarkable clothes. Their only means of identification is also unmistakeable. The Lightsaber being lit.




I have a lot of backstory thought up for this idea, for use in my Star Wars OT AU where Leia and the Tantive IV managed to escape to Tatooine undetected.
 

InfinityEngine

Well-Known Member
#6
Here's 10 things I would change (in no particular order):

1. Anakin becomes Darth Vader at the end of Episode 2.

2. Obi-Wan is Anakin's father (I think this was an early idea of Lucas' but I'm not sure) and that comes back later to help turn Anakin to the Dark Side.

3. Sidious has a Sith Council (breaks the Rule of Two, but gives Anakin competition).

4. Episode 1 would start with Anakin as a teenager, at least (closer to the age of Luke in Episode 4).

5. Episode 3 would be about Darth Vader and the new Empire taking out the Republic and the Jedi (also would give us a chance to see the new Death Star in action and blow up a few planets). It would also open up the opportunity far more epic battles.

6. Episode 2 would be about the Clone Wars and Anakin turning to the Dark Side as he hunts Asajj Ventress.

7. Obi-Wan would fight Count Dooku to the death (he was Qui-Gon's master after all).

8. No chibi-Boba

9. Clone Wars would be the central focus of the first two episodes, starting at the end of Episode 1 and ending at the end of Episode 2. None of this Naboo Invasion then Timeskip then War bullshit. Preferably, the war is beginning in Episode 1 and Anakin gets pulled into it.

10. No midichlorians. It's like bullshit religious science.

Whatever. Those are just a few ideas. I couldn't actually write it, but those are a few things I'd want to change at least.
 

bluepencil

that's why it's trash can, not trash cannot
#7
What? No Artoo? Oh, come on... R2 was awesome. And THIS definitely needs to be used:

http://forum.spacebattles.com/showthread.php?t=141144

As for Episode One, while the entirety of Star Wars can be called the Rise, Fall, and Redemption of Anakin Skywalker... it can also be seen as the triumph and the defeat of Sidious. Again, with the philosophy that antagonists are more important to the plot than protagonists.

ACT ONE:
We open up to a sweeping view of the galaxy, and onto a Republic ship. Within, a kindly old man is discussing amicably with several young Jedi. The young knights make their thanks for the lift, as the Jedi Temple at that point did not have specific Jedi craft in their service. Soon they enter into a discussion about what the Force IS, and between the light and dark sides. The eldest jedi knight, perhaps an alien of some sort, says that the Dark Side is always a temptation - but the jedi teachings are more than capable of handling it. The Sith have been defeated long ago.

"Indeed..." says Palpatine. "The Sith were defeated. I have much to be thankful for, that it is your kind of Jedi that now protects this galaxy."

A smaller, sleek black ship attacks the Republic transport. It is disabled. Boarding parties enter, led by droids.

"Do not fear." says of the Jedi. "We will protect you. We are Jedi."

Palpatine smiles thinly. "Of course, you are."

Battle droids enter and quickly overwhelm the defenders. The Jedi dispatch them, until droidekas arrive.

"Those are Trade Federation battle droids! What do they hope to accomplish with this senseless attack?"

Yes, this is essentially te Ebon Hawk scene. Then Maul enters, stepping through the smoke, badassery fully established. "Pathetic Jedi. Hand over the Chancellor, and die." Of course, they refuse. Fsshk-voom. Double-bladed red saber. Gibs.

He stalks over to the control room, cutting through anything and anyone that gets in his way. Palpatine stands there, unfazed, and turns to face the Sith. Maul snarls and deactivates his lightsaber.

Fade to black.

ACT TWO:
The Jedi Temple. Qui-gon and Obi-wan are being tasked with rooting out the recent disappearance of Jedi. Droids should not be able to kill Jedi, specially Trade Federation droids. It is unknown if the Jedi are being hunted or that they were stumbling into something that called for their elimination.

Their first lead is to go to Naboo, which is being blockaded by the Trade Federation in a supposedly 'legitimate act of economic sanction'. Their pressure upon the planet is secondary to finding out what happened to Senator Palpatine. He was dropped off on the planet, after his ship was reported destroyed. Play up the unconscious arrogance of the Council, that only the Force matters.

ACT THREE:
The act plays out mostly the same as the original, except that Qui-gon expresses surprise at the military might assembled to invade a relatively out of the way world. Daring to try and kill Jedi is a serious offense, Obi-wan quips. The Trade Federation cannot hope to win.

ACT FOUR:
The Droids land close to the palace, admist flak and anti-orbital fire. Qui-gon and Obi-wan are in the same transport, and discuss about how droids lack the ability to feel fear. Mindlessly trying to overwhelm the enemy with metal and the sheer weight of numbers... how crude.

"But that doesn't help our situation any if we get shot out of the sky, master."

The transport is critically hit and begins to crash. It explodes. Obi-wan and Qui-gon are falling. "How can you remain so calm about this?!" Obi-wan yells.

Qui-gon quirks an eyebrow. "Trust in the Force, padawan." A few more moments of freefall, and he decides to turn around, facing up. Then he lands upon a droid glider feet-first. He cuts free the droid control orb with his lightsaber and with the Force, makes it swoop to catch Obi-wan.

"So we're just going to surf down from orbit, then?"

"We're not that high up, padawan." Qui-gon replies, amused.

"... I hate you."

"No you don't." It is clear that Obi-wan is suffering from one hell of an inferiority complex.

They crash into the trees. The droid army passes below. Then they hear a screeching noise. A Gungan is fleeing, riding one of their beasts. YES, IT IS JAR-JAR. Blaster shots spatter against a shield.

The Jedi drop onto the beast's back. "Hey! Yousa get off! No gots time for hitchikers!"

"We are Jedi. We're here to help."

"Ooh, Jee-dai. Den you can usa dis." He hands over a blaster. Qui-gon and Obi-wan look confused.

"We have better ways of-..."

"Yousa can throw, right? Even Jedi should know be throwing!" He then passes over a glowing blue sphere. It seems to be ticking. They throw it.

Eventually, they manage to ditch the army; which chose to march onto Theed rather than waste time pursuing a native. They have the time to talk.

"Mesa Jar-Jar. Mesa banished. Not mesa's fault swamp gas so combustible." YES I JUST TURNED JAR-JAR INTO A MAD SCIENTIST. "Is hard. Life here, is pretty pretty, see? Weapons bad. But fire... fire is fun!"

"I... was given to understand Gungans are an amphibious species."

"Fire be REALLY FUN!"

"I think I'm beginning to understand, master.|

"Now bad peoples come again, in metal boxes! They so silly. Metal boxes! Gungans took away metal boxes long ago. Is why Naboo so peaceful!"

"I doubt if Naboos defenses can hold for so long. We must get to the capital quickly. The Trade Federation seem to control most of the open routes, though."

"Ooh... then yousa needs bongo!"

Obi-wan looks puzzled. "Bongo? What's a bongo?"

Later:

"THIS IS A DEATH TRAP!"

"What did I tell you about negativity, padawan? It closes your mind and muffles your ability to feel the force."

"Jar-jar, please burn my master."

"Mugy... I means, okays!"

Qui-gon just sighs.

... etc.
 

drakensis

Well-Known Member
#8
It is a period of civil war. Rival states within the Galactic Republic
settle their differences through violence and battles rage across
the stars.

The Jedi Knights, protectors of peace and justice, seek to protect
innocents caught up in these struggles and to someday restore
order to the galaxy.

On the planet Genosis, captives from a dozen worlds have been
enslaved by the warmasters of the Trade Federation. It would
require an army to free them. Or a Jedi...


SCENE ONE
A battered freighter limps towards Genosis. Behind it a pair of corvettes fire ion blasts after the ship, but retreat as a squadron of drone fighters approach. Inside the cockpit, QUI-GON JINN and BAIL ORGANA watch as OBI-WAN KENOBI listens to a headset. QUI-GON and OBI-WAN wear black jedi uniforms, BAIL wears a tan and white Aldebaran uniform.

OBI-WAN: (taking off the headset). "They bought it. We're cleared to make for Genosis."
BAIL: "Good work, Kenobi. I'll get my men ready for the attack." (Leaves the cockpit).
QUI-GON: (Looks at Obi-Wan for a moment). "Don't lose your head down there, my young apprentice. I know you want to find your brother but he may not even be there."
OBI-WAN: "He is Master Qui-Gon. I can feel him through the Force."
QUI-GON: "You've come a long way since you were Yoda's student. But you aren't a Jedi yet."

SCENE TWO
The freighter makes a re-entry and breaks up. Under the cover of the explosion, space-suited Aldebaranian commandos and the two Jedi Knights freefall towards the surface, activating grav-chutes at the last minute to make a safe landing. They break into teams, the two Knights leading a squad to seize command of a land-train.
The land train approaches a prison camp and crashes into the gates, scattering the guards. The Jedi and the commandos quickly take control of the camp although several prisoners are killed in the crossfire.
QUI-GON: "Everyone onto the truck. We're here to take you home!"
Two prisoners approach Obi-Wan. They are a teenaged OWEN KENOBI and ANAKIN SKYWALKER.
OWEN: "Obi-Wan? Is that you?"
OBI-WAN: (Hugs Owen) "I promised I'd come for you. Who's your friend."
OWEN: "This is Anakin Skywalker."
They board the land train and it moves off. Anakin jumps off suddenly and runs to one of the fallen bodies.
OWEN: "Anakin! Obi-Wan, we have to stop for him!"
OBI-WAN: "We're on a schedule, Owen. We can't stop." (He jumps out and runs to Anakin, who has lifted the body to reveal a girl (BERU) alive beneath it).
ANAKIN: "I heard her crying."
OBI-WAN: (glares at him and then smiles down at the girl) "Hi there. Have you ever ridden a swoop?"

SCENE THREE
A space port pad. The commandos are protecting a large transport under BAIL's command. Around them, droid-soldiers are closing in. The situation is desperate.
Then the land-train smashes through the perimeter, scattering droids and forming a barrier. Prisoners run out of it, heading for the ship.
Two swoops fly through the gap behind the train, one of them with Anakin on it, the other with Obi-Wan, the little girl in front of him. They skid to a halt by the ramp and Obi-Wan gives the girl to Anakin to carry aboard.
QUI-GON: "Obi-Wan Kenobi! If you'd been a minute later, you would have been left behind!"
OBI-WAN: "Sorry master. I was delayed."
BAIL: "Everyone aboard!"
The commandos retreat aboard and the ship takes off, leaving the droids behind.

SCENE FOUR
The freighter breaks atmosphere, but droid-fighters are chasing it. Aboard, Anakin finds Owen and sets the girl down between them.
OWEN: "Isn't your new girlfriend a little young for you, Anakin."
ANAKIN: "Very funny." (to Beru) "What's your name?"
BERU: "Beru."
ANAKIN: "Well Beru, this is Owen. He's going to look after you while I make sure the joker flying this doesn't hit anything."
He runs off, leaving Owen with Beru. Then the ship shudders and Beru breaks into tears. Owen hugs her.
Anakin bursts into the cockpit. Bail is wrestling with the controls and alarms are going off as Obi-Wan and Qui-Gon extinguish the fires.
ANAKIN: (slips into the empty co-pilot seat) "Who taught you to fly?"
BAIL: "The Aldebaran Naval Academy... What are you doing to the hyperdrive!?"
ANAKIN: "Disabling the safety lock-outs. You don't really think they're going to let us get far enough away to jump normally, do you?" (Stabs at a control) "Hit it!"
BAIL: (moves a lever and the ship jumps to hyperspace). "You must be a Corellian. No one else is that crazy."
ANAKIN: "Stop complaining. It worked didn't it?"
One of the computers starts smoking.
OBI-WAN: "Is that the navigation computer?"
ANAKIN: "Not my fault!"
BAIL: "I hate you."

SCENE FIVE
The freighter, half-buried in the sands of Tantooine. A long column of the prisoners are walking towards a barely visible settlement.
QUI-GON: (looking at the ship) "Well, that went well."
OBI-WAN: "Anakin said that any landing you could walk away from was a good one."
QUI-GON: "It's an old Corellian proverb. I don't think it applies here."
In the background Anakin limps out of the shelter of the ship on a crutch. He has a cast on his leg.
OBI-WAN: "He's strong in the force, isn't he Master."
QUI-GON: "Yes. He's also reckless and angry. Like another young apprentice that I remember."
Anakin limps to Owen and Beru.
ANAKIN: "Are you sure she isn't your girlfriend now Owen."
OWEN: "You were right. That isn't funny. Are you coming?" (Gestures towards the settlement)
ANAKIN: "Aren't you going with your brother?"
OWEN: "He's a Jedi, I couldn't stay with him anyway. We agreed I'd change my name, drop out of sight. If anyone knew my brother was a Jedi then their enemies might go after him. This seems like a good world to settle down on. No one would look at one more wasteland moisture farmer."
ANAKIN: (shakes his head) "Owen Kenobi..."
OWEN: "Lars. Owen Lars." Anakin looks at him and he reddens. "It's Beru's family name."
ANAKIN: "Owen Lars, moisture farmer. I never thought I'd see the day."
OWEN: (defensively) "It can be a good life. Why don't you give it a try?"
ANAKIN: "No chance. There's a huge galaxy out there, Owen, and I want to see all of it. Prince Bail said he could use a good pilot."
OWEN: "Where does that leave you then?"
He and Anakin laugh.
QUI-GON: (walks up) "Actually, young Master Skywalker, I may have another option for you..."

tbc.
 

Prince Charon

Well-Known Member
#10
drakensis said:
ANAKIN: "Aren't you going with your brother?"
OWEN: "He's a Jedi, I couldn't stay with him anyway. We agreed I'd change my name, drop out of sight. If anyone knew my brother was a Jedi then their enemies might go after him. This seems like a good world to settle down on. No one would look at one more wasteland moisture farmer."
ANAKIN: (shakes his head) "Owen Kenobi..."
OWEN: "Lars. Owen Lars." Anakin looks at him and he reddens. "It's Beru's family name."
ANAKIN: "Owen Lars, moisture farmer. I never thought I'd see the day."
OWEN: (defensively) "It can be a good life. Why don't you give it a try?"
ANAKIN: "No chance. There's a huge galaxy out there, Owen, and I want to see all of it. Prince Bail said he could use a good pilot."
OWEN: "Where does that leave you then?"
He and Anakin laugh.
QUI-GON: (walks up) "Actually, young Master Skywalker, I may have another option for you..."

tbc.
Vastly better than canon, I must say.
 

TheClueless

Well-Known Member
#11
My suggestions are basically as follows:

1) I would have is that Episode 1 end where George's Episode 2 ended. The Clone Wars have begun.

2) Episode 2 should be about the Clone Wars. Look to the run of Star Wars issues in the Dark Horse comics that "covered" the Clone Wars. Let us see Anakin do things that - admittedly assisted behind the scenes by the Chancellor (and future Emperor) - result in Anakin becoming a hero. Let us see how the warfare, and the hard decisions that any officer in a war would need to make, are slowly eating away at Anakin. This way it's believable that he *does* become a man who kills Dooku - despite *knowing* that this isn't what a Jedi would do - and who eventually sides against the Jedi as a whole.
 
Top