This came to me after i finished watching this anime for the 10th time. Can the Fate Stay Night plot be mixed with the now completed HP series? If anyone wants to try this out tell me so I can read it! Please no Yaoi Like GenocideHeart I am about to abandon HP fanfics becuz of the overwhelming Yaoi content. :angel:
Nasuverse Wierd Idea
- Thread starter JackofDeath2445
- Start date
we just need a simple way to get someone there and the story instantly kicks off. Unless you want the complicated way and like relatives abandoning the main dude to Japan and thats how he got there. -_-Except, you know, the Nasuverse has its own magical organization based in Europe (London, to be exact).
And yes, Steel is correct in that the Nasuverse rarely meshes well with other magical systems. This is definitely one of those times, for oh-so-many reasons.
EDIT: Also, Portal plot devices... *sigh* That doesn't even fix the problem that Harry shouldn't then be able to use his magic, or wouldn't be able to use that places magic, or whatever. It doesn't work well.
And yes, Steel is correct in that the Nasuverse rarely meshes well with other magical systems. This is definitely one of those times, for oh-so-many reasons.
EDIT: Also, Portal plot devices... *sigh* That doesn't even fix the problem that Harry shouldn't then be able to use his magic, or wouldn't be able to use that places magic, or whatever. It doesn't work well.
Maybe...
Neither of these are really my area of expertise but, aren't noble phantasms, at there most basic, just objects that have gained power because people believe they have that power? If so you could have wands be very minor noble phantasms, with people believing that they allow for easier casting of magic.
Another possibility is that wands only became required because of some kind of magical upheaval that was a side effect of the grail war. I am not entirely sure how this could be pulled off but it is one idea.
If nothing else, you could always have Harry Potter be summoned as Caster.
Neither of these are really my area of expertise but, aren't noble phantasms, at there most basic, just objects that have gained power because people believe they have that power? If so you could have wands be very minor noble phantasms, with people believing that they allow for easier casting of magic.
Another possibility is that wands only became required because of some kind of magical upheaval that was a side effect of the grail war. I am not entirely sure how this could be pulled off but it is one idea.
If nothing else, you could always have Harry Potter be summoned as Caster.
Wha...?
Well, if you really dumb it down, yes. But that's kind of like saying that because Excalibur is famous and powerful (and people believe it), all swords should have the same power as it. It doesn't work like that.
At most, the wands would be conceptual weaponry (though, not really). Noble Phantasms are objects that can be described as 'crystalized mysteries', their singular fame is sort of what gives them their power... to a point anyway. It's much more complex than that.
Well, if you really dumb it down, yes. But that's kind of like saying that because Excalibur is famous and powerful (and people believe it), all swords should have the same power as it. It doesn't work like that.
At most, the wands would be conceptual weaponry (though, not really). Noble Phantasms are objects that can be described as 'crystalized mysteries', their singular fame is sort of what gives them their power... to a point anyway. It's much more complex than that.
:huh.: Like I said, I don't know nearly enough about either system. It's the best idea I could come up with in two minutes that didn't involve a portal to another world. Anyway here is my reasoning:
The singularity may give noble phantasms the greater part of their power, but how powerful are wands really? It could be that all it requires to cast lower level spells with a wand is for the caster to believe that their wand is powerful and will work. That could be the reason for Ollivandor telling those who purchase wands from him all about their wand. As the wizard's reputation grows, others begin to believe that that wizard's wand is effective and thus it grows more powerful. I know it does not fit exactly into either magic system exactly, but for a basic idea for a crossover, I don't think it is too horrible.
Of course that could just be my lack of sleep talking. :huh.:
The singularity may give noble phantasms the greater part of their power, but how powerful are wands really? It could be that all it requires to cast lower level spells with a wand is for the caster to believe that their wand is powerful and will work. That could be the reason for Ollivandor telling those who purchase wands from him all about their wand. As the wizard's reputation grows, others begin to believe that that wizard's wand is effective and thus it grows more powerful. I know it does not fit exactly into either magic system exactly, but for a basic idea for a crossover, I don't think it is too horrible.
Of course that could just be my lack of sleep talking. :huh.:
Or there is the way of him actually dying when he was one and Fate 'somehow' wanted to give him a second chance and it so happens that it when Kirei Kotomine touched the holy grail and Fate just put him there next to Shiro during the fire. Come on, if Fallen Heroes of the past appear becuz of the Grail's magic then why can't magic transport a kid there.
Inter dimensional Magic is known as True magic in the Nasuverse, and Zeltrech is the one that uses it.
Regardless, mixing the two systems doesn't look so well in my view, they're just that different.
I'm not going to develop on why this isn't exactly feasible, but how would you explain accidental magic in that case?
Regardless, mixing the two systems doesn't look so well in my view, they're just that different.
I'm not going to develop on why this isn't exactly feasible, but how would you explain accidental magic in that case?