Nasuverse Servant Archer, Unknown Soldier

firestorm

Well-Known Member
#26
eldragonmalo said:
I doubt Unlimited Blade Works can even stop Saber!Hercules considering that it did not even kill Berserker!Hercules . Can we get some Stast for Saber!Hercules please? I wonder if Hercules would have Eye of the Mind (true) considering that he do not a Beserker now
...when did anyone use UBW against Berserker? :wacko:
 

Kibbles

Well-Known Member
#27
firestorm said:
...when did anyone use UBW against Berserker? :wacko:
Presumably, Archer in the Fate path. He did off Berserker six times before the big guy got him.

All happened off-screen, though. The game follows Shirou and he ... had his hands full at the time.
 

firestorm

Well-Known Member
#28
Archer lost his memory in Fate, he was just Tracing...
 

grant

Well-Known Member
#29
It's shown that in every different ending he had his memories. Unlimited Blade Works was simply the version where he acted on those memories to try to kill Shirou.

If you mean the anime, he addresses Ilya as Ilya before he dies there.
 

firestorm

Well-Known Member
#30
Eh, either way, Shirou does not only have UBW, he also has Unknown Soldier. UBW and Killing Field together just might do what UBW alone couldn't...
 

Crusader

Well-Known Member
#31
Delta Green Friendly said:
If any DG agent was summoned, you can bet that an "8th Master" would soon appear in the form of Stephen Alzis. He actually enjoys toying with Delta Green for whatever reason. We refer to him as "PARIAH."

On Occult knowledge used by DG, which was part of the post eaten by the bad internet connection, A-Cell and Agent Alphonse always restricted use and knowledge of such things, actively telling agents to leave that stuff alone. Only select agents, the most trusted and stable ones, were given the occult know-how to actually cast spells. Mind, this was during the "Cowboy years" between 1970 and 1990, when most DG agents were the old vets that knew Alphonse was one of the best and most experienced, and thus followed his orders. Even then, the less structured organization of DG should have enabled more to use spells without A-Cell knowing, but most agents simply refused to do so without orders or authorization from A-Cell itself, not trusting the fickle magics of the Mythos.

Ironically, the "Conspiracy years", 1994 to today, have seen a rise in the use of occult knowledge and spells amongst DG cells, often against A-Cell's order or without their knowledge altogether, as well as a dramatic rise in DG casualties due to magic related "accidents". A-Cell's policy remains that Mythos spells should be used sparingly, and only when all other methods have failed.
Stephen Alzis loves toying with everything, if I'm not mistaken. I think even the bad guys in the Type Moon universe would learn to to fear or respect Alzis, should they ever cross paths.

Personally I thought it was a good idea by Delta Green to use the spell for contacting the Deep Ones as a live shooting gallery in order to reduce its effectiveness by making the servitor race hesitant to answer the call of the spell.

Considering what Cell A knows about the hazards of Mythos magic, and only gives the green light for spell utilization against dangers of Dunwich Horror proportions or Great Old Ones, I see their point in restricting use of magic.
 

firestorm

Well-Known Member
#32
I really should do my assignment.

But eh.

Update!

"This eternal war is...UNLIMITED BLADE WORKS!"

And the sky burned.

Saber roared with laughter. "Good, good, very good, young mage! Perhaps you are not as useless of a Master as I first thought? Now, show me the power of your soul!"

One, then four, then nine, then an endless cloud of swords rose into the air, surrounding Shirou. He raised his arm, and three swords spun to point towards Saber, steel edges glinting under the red sky. "The power of my soul...is in these swords!" Shirou whipped his arm towards Saber, and the three blades flew towards Saber, homing unerringly towards his heart.

Saber was already moving. As the three swords stabbed harmlessly into the ground where he had stood a minute earlier, he looked up to see Shirou hot on his heels, with two swords in his hands and five more in the air. "Do you think to fight me sword to sword, young mage? Then you are a greater fool then that imbecile Jason! I am Saber, strongest of the Seven!"

"Who said I would use my own strength?" Shirou asked, and even as Saber brought up his guard, Shirou hurled one sword, then the next, then the five following him, one after the other.

"If you think that your attack will work again-" but Saber never finished. Seven massive explosions in succession sounded, and a ball of fire covered him. As the smoke cleared and Saber stumbled out, arm nearly severed, an eighth sword sliced cleanly into his chest and detonated.

'Two down, ten to go. Damn it Archer, where are you?' Shirou wondered, as he sprinted across the rust-red ground. An earth-shaking bellow of rage sounded from somewhere behind him, and he cursed. He was out of time.

"DIE!" Saber thundered as he bore down on Shirou, gigantic sword swinging down towards his head...

"Shirou, do you understand why you lost?" Archer asked, as they both sat overlooking a Shogi board.

"I don't know. I kept the principle of war you were talking about, mass, in mind at all times."

"And that was correct. However, there is more to the art of war then simple numbers. Given the correct circumstances, a smaller, elite force can inflict devastating damage to a larger one."

"How so? Wouldn't the larger force simply be able to surround the smaller one and attack from all sides?"

"Correct. Hence why I mentioned circumstances. What sort of circumstances do you think would prevent a larger force from doing exactly as you said?"

"Well...it would be somewhere that emphasizes the advantage of the smaller force, so...the front would have to be small, because one for one, the smaller force is superior."

"Excellent, Shirou. You are learning well. Where would such circumstances occur?"

"A canyon."

"Explain."

"Because the canyon mouth is small and restricted, only a fraction of the larger force can fight at any time, while the smaller force can fight all at once, increasing their effectiveness."

"Precisely. Now, a real-life example, or case study as we called it back in Sandhurst..." Archer drifted off for a moment. "excuse me. A real-life example occurred in 480 BC..."


Shirou raised his arm as if to ward off the blow, and Saber's mighty swing smashed into a row of bronze shields. They shattered, they splintered...but they held, and Shirou was already preparing more swords.

Who wants to guess the NP Shirou pulled out?
 

Mercsenary

Well-Known Member
#33
No guess.

Greek phalanx. A formation of usual hoplite warriors with spears and shields that overlap the soldier to their left.

You will die against that wall.

Edit: Battle of Thermopylae?(Spartans?!)
 

firestorm

Well-Known Member
#34
Mercsenary said:
No guess.

Greek phalanx. A formation of usual hoplite warriors with spears and shields that overlap the soldier to their left.

You will die against that wall.
Not a Noble Phantasm.

Here's a hint...read Archer's last line again.
 

Prince Charon

Well-Known Member
#35
firestorm said:
Mercsenary said:
No guess.

Greek phalanx. A formation of usual hoplite warriors with spears and shields that overlap the soldier to their left.

You will die against that wall.
Not a Noble Phantasm.

Here's a hint...read Archer's last line again.
Leonidas's NP, yes? Archer was there, on both sides, charging and defending.
 
#36
Prince Charon said:
firestorm said:
Mercsenary said:
No guess.

Greek phalanx. A formation of usual hoplite warriors with spears and shields that overlap the soldier to their left.

You will die against that wall.
Not a Noble Phantasm.

Here's a hint...read Archer's last line again.
Leonidas's NP, yes? Archer was there, on both sides, charging and defending.
I propose "Strength of the Three Hundred" as a name for that Phantasm.
 

grant

Well-Known Member
#37
While the shield wall was a good tactic until much later in history, the Battle of Thermopylae might not be the best example to give Shirou; the kid's suicidal enough as it is.
 

firestorm

Well-Known Member
#38
Yep. When I posted Servant Leonidas originally, I called it 'Phalanx: Spartan Glory' or something like that. TBH, I was inspired by a scene from one of the Halo books, where the young SPARTAN-IIs are taught the importance of teamwork (IIRC) as they're shown a hologram of the battle. Plus, I didn't want Shirou pulling out Rho Aias, that's just unoriginal.

Thoughts about my writing?
 

grant

Well-Known Member
#39
You could put in 100 more words after the flashback, but that isn't necessary if it makes you give up these two sentences.

Shirou raised his arm as if to ward off the blow, and Saber's mighty swing smashed into a row of bronze shields. They shattered, they splintered...but they held, and Shirou was already preparing more swords.
That's a line worth keeping.
 

Latewave

Well-Known Member
#40
firestorm said:
Yep. When I posted Servant Leonidas originally, I called it 'Phalanx: Spartan Glory' or something like that. TBH, I was inspired by a scene from one of the Halo books, where the young SPARTAN-IIs are taught the importance of teamwork (IIRC) as they're shown a hologram of the battle. Plus, I didn't want Shirou pulling out Rho Aias, that's just unoriginal.

Thoughts about my writing?
Your writing is pretty good. I saw no obvious flaws in the writing.
 

nick012000

Well-Known Member
#42
But, how did Shirou see the battle in order to be able to trace the Noble Phantasm? Did Unknown Soldier show it to him?
 

firestorm

Well-Known Member
#43
nick012000 said:
But, how did Shirou see the battle in order to be able to trace the Noble Phantasm? Did Unknown Soldier show it to him?
Yep. Unknown Soldier was there, remember?
 

firestorm

Well-Known Member
#44
Alright, so I'm stuck on ideas with where to go in the VS Saber story.

With that in mind...anyone have any ideas on what other storylines they want me to go through?
 

grant

Well-Known Member
#45
Maybe Sakura/Rider, specifically why Sakura has control over Rider and what the old bastard worm freak filth* thinks of it.

For battle's, Lancer's a possibility. No question that he'd enjoy this kind of match.



Weird thought went through my head, how do you define 'soldier'? Obviously you've got the WWI grunt, but would insurgents be generally counted as well? I'm not saying that we should make the character Vietcong or a Napoleonic Wars Spaniard, but it's a possible route for adding complexity.
In addition, if Archer's identity is Unknown Soldier then how does he think? Does he use every mind of every unknown soldier in a sort of 'majority rules'? Are there some dominant personalities?
If you want to avoid this you could simply state that WWI was the conflict most associated with anonymous soldiers so they have a WWI mind frame.


*I hate him. I was growling every time I saw him while playing Heaven's Feel.
 

nick012000

Well-Known Member
#46
firestorm said:
nick012000 said:
But, how did Shirou see the battle in order to be able to trace the Noble Phantasm? Did Unknown Soldier show it to him?
Yep. Unknown Soldier was there, remember?
Yes, but Shirou wasn't, so how did Shirou see it to be able to trace it?
 

Vassago

Well-Known Member
#47
nick012000 said:
firestorm said:
nick012000 said:
But, how did Shirou see the battle in order to be able to trace the Noble Phantasm? Did Unknown Soldier show it to him?
Yep. Unknown Soldier was there, remember?
Yes, but Shirou wasn't, so how did Shirou see it to be able to trace it?
Unknown Soldier most likely recreated it.

Noble Phantasm and all that jazz.
 

nick012000

Well-Known Member
#48
Vassago said:
nick012000 said:
firestorm said:
nick012000 said:
But, how did Shirou see the battle in order to be able to trace the Noble Phantasm? Did Unknown Soldier show it to him?
Yep. Unknown Soldier was there, remember?
Yes, but Shirou wasn't, so how did Shirou see it to be able to trace it?
Unknown Soldier most likely recreated it.

Noble Phantasm and all that jazz.
But it's not Unknown Soldier's Noble Phantasm. It'd be the Noble Phantasm of whatever Hero was leading the forces. In the case of Thermopylae, that'd be Leonidas. Unknown Soldier is exactly that: an Unknown Soldier. The random schmuck who got himself killed for someone else's cause and legend.
 

Avider

Well-Known Member
#49
So Shirou saw UnkS's memories.

Or maybe it's a collective NP.

If there's such a thing.

Anyways, the point is it's not that much of a stretch.

Anyways, my problem is more like WHY THE HELL IS HERACLES NOT DOMINATING SHIROU?!

I don't care if he learnt warfare techniques from Unknown Soldier, this is Hera-freaking-cles.

He'll tear Shirou apart. Frankly the whole fight, albeit awesome, is unrealistic. The best Shirou could hope for is a defensive fight, where he should only have a single instant, one chance of touching (much less killing) Heracles.

And this is compounded by the fact that this is Saber!Heracles. I mean, wdf? Two lives gone already?! wdf?!

(I wouldn't have a problem with it if, after being run ragged by Heracles, pressed to the point of desperation, Shirou managed to kill him *once* with tactical traps, feints, and guard lock/break. But this is just... [Alternatively, his once chance he hits Heracles with something that can take all his lives in one go. But too easy again.] )

Why does everyone make Heracles into such a jobber? ;_; I mean, the only one who gets it worse is Gilgamesh.
 

Vassago

Well-Known Member
#50
nick012000 said:
Vassago said:
nick012000 said:
firestorm said:
nick012000 said:
But, how did Shirou see the battle in order to be able to trace the Noble Phantasm? Did Unknown Soldier show it to him?
Yep. Unknown Soldier was there, remember?
Yes, but Shirou wasn't, so how did Shirou see it to be able to trace it?
Unknown Soldier most likely recreated it.

Noble Phantasm and all that jazz.
But it's not Unknown Soldier's Noble Phantasm. It'd be the Noble Phantasm of whatever Hero was leading the forces. In the case of Thermopylae, that'd be Leonidas. Unknown Soldier is exactly that: an Unknown Soldier. The random schmuck who got himself killed for someone else's cause and legend.
Unknown Soldier was on both sides of the conflict, and if his Noble Phantasm, or one of his abilities, allows him to show other people memories, or replay certain events, why wouldn't he have been able to show Shirou the battle?

Shirou could have easily traced it then. There's nothing stopping him. There's, what, 200 or so UnSo's on both sides at that battle, at least? IIRC, Shriou doesn't need to be there to trace something, he just needs to visualize it.

Why does everyone make Heracles into such a jobber? ;_; I mean, the only one who gets it worse is Gilgamesh.
Because not doing so to both of them would make them so broken that anybody who summons them might as well have just won automatically. Gilgamesh was 2/3 God, crushed people on accident while wrestling and restraining himself, and it took a God-created BeastMan, who could fuck for 7 days and nights straight IIRC, to match him in strength.

And Heracles could make Natural formations, like rivers and lakes, his bitch.

"Oh hay dar river, MOVE OVER, BITCH!"

"But--" *slap*

"STFU, BITCHES DON'T TALK BACK!"

Had a temper tantrum at the most random of times, for the slightest reasons, and seemed to be able to throw people off the edge of Gaia when he wasn't close to it.

Oh, and Magic didn't do much of anything to stop them.
 
Top