Ok, one point I missed out off all of them I was making.
Ok, fine. I'll just ignore the whole 'main problem' part.
The forum is actually a semi-inclusive club. Not many people are going to find it without references from authors who post links here to their own stories. The people who would read those authors are only those interested in either that particular series or the setup that the author has created.
So your point is that it's semi-inclusive because people have to find it first? How is that different from any other forum?
As for a lot of members not being authors...why not. This forum is created as a sounding board for new ideas and stories. Hell, the most vocal people here are the one's who either write stories or post comments on said stories or ideas.
That and I never said it was limited to members. I stated that it should just have stories that members have posted in the preview section. These posts are the one's that we edit and commented on and best show what our stances are here. If it is going to have our name on it, it is going to be assumed that these are stories that have been reviewed and helped on by the members of this forum.
When did I say that was a problem?
New ideas and stories? Have you read what's under the talk section of every forum? The past is just as important as the future. And the stories in the C2 may not have been helped on, but they've all been reviewed. Someone here must have read it and recommended it for it to be present. If you have a problem with any particular story then contest its inclusion.
And simply because a story has been posted in the previews section does not mean it is any good. Of course, I'm not saying they aren't. I'm just saying that until I get a nomination, fanfics posted here won't get any special treatment. But of course, that's what this is all about.
If you really want to see those stories in the C2, nominate them. Name them, give me a link and problem solved. If it isn't good, someone else can contest it and with enough support, it'll be gone. It's as simple as that.