trevelyan1983 said:
Prince Charon said:
I remember that.á I lost my enthusiasm for it when the priest decides to fuck with Willow's head.á "Who do you think your goddess worships?" as an explanation for why her powers don't work, because admitting they were neutralizing her powers with a machine would have been bad, or something.
Uh . . . it is, isn't it?
Putting aside the belief system stuff, neutralizing Willow's power and telling her so is only a temporary fix - she just waits until they switch off the machine, or tells them she's all better - the underlying problem never gets fixed.
Make it look like the supernatural forces she relies on don't like being jerked around so she can mind-wipe her friends and stuff, may actually encourage her to look at her behaviour and her habits and implies that she has to then toe their line if she wants her mojo back.
At least, that's how I view it. Frankly, I don't agree that Willow subscribes to any particular God/dess, belief system or set of magical rules, so I doubt that she'd give a damn. But if she did, playing hardball like this might help her to get a grip.
A large part of it hinges on her
never finding out she was lied to about why her powers don't work, or at least not finding out until she's much, much saner. Otherwise, she'll be quite pissed, and undo some or all of their hard work (IIRC, that Willow
did subscribe to a specific, if unnamed, goddess).
Also, I have to much respect for most pagan religions to like someone suggesting that they are subordinate to an outside deity. It read like an opportunistic attempt to gain a convert, and given that we
know that the gods are real in the Buffyverse, he just made an enemy of one that he didn't need to, even if she was pissed at Willow, too. He may have believed what he said, but it was extremely annoying at the time, and even though I'm a lot less religious now (more or less agnostic) than I was then, its pissing me off again, now.
EDIT: Putting the first point another way, playing headgames with someone you
know has lost it is a
very bad idea. I'm more annoyed by that than I am about the religion thing.