A new awards thread, so that I can finally put up all of the lovely comments the judges made for you guys.
New IF scores will go in here from now on, and the old thread will remain as a discussion thread here.
Remember, NO COMMENTS!
IF1 will go here, next post is IF2, etc.
Oh, right, judges: if you notice that I don't have your comment up, I'd appreciate it if you sent it to me. The more feedback the authors get, the happier they are.
New IF scores will go in here from now on, and the old thread will remain as a discussion thread here.
Remember, NO COMMENTS!
IF1 will go here, next post is IF2, etc.
IRON FIC 1: The world doesn't have to make sense
Zero Requiem: Errata (Code Geass)--Iron Ficcer Mereo Flere
English: 18.667
Theme: 18.667
Details: 15.667
Story: 19.333
Other: 18.333
TOTAL: 90.667
Definitely a fantastic piece, the reviewers raved about how cleverly the themed was turned on it's head.
Raindrops (Naruto)--Iron Ficcer Andrew Joshua Talon
English: 18.333
Theme: 17
Details: 17.333
Story: 16.667
Other: 17
TOTAL: 86.333
A very derivative piece, AJT went in an unexplored direction and mixed a bit of his Alt-Canon (an alternate alternate?) into his submission. The result was interesting, to say the least.
A WINNER IS FOUND! Congrats Mereo Flere, you are the winner of the first Iron Fic contest!
Zero Requiem: Errata (Code Geass)--Iron Ficcer Mereo Flere
English: 18.667
Theme: 18.667
Details: 15.667
Story: 19.333
Other: 18.333
TOTAL: 90.667
Definitely a fantastic piece, the reviewers raved about how cleverly the themed was turned on it's head.
Raindrops (Naruto)--Iron Ficcer Andrew Joshua Talon
English: 18.333
Theme: 17
Details: 17.333
Story: 16.667
Other: 17
TOTAL: 86.333
A very derivative piece, AJT went in an unexplored direction and mixed a bit of his Alt-Canon (an alternate alternate?) into his submission. The result was interesting, to say the least.
A WINNER IS FOUND! Congrats Mereo Flere, you are the winner of the first Iron Fic contest!