MastaofBitches said:
So, I'm gonna leave things as they are for the next... 2 pages, and if it's still a Sakura centric discussion, I'll tank the thread and repost the idea, hopeful allowing the thread to fulfil it's original purpose.
And, then, I'll post the same statement as before and it will go the exact same way.
If you don't like my opinion, then tough shit. I don't like
yours, but that doesn't stop you from posting it. This fic is either hopelessly OOC or else just an outright troll fic, and I will keep saying that no matter how much you try to censor me.
You fail totally to understand the MoS ending, and just how much it affects Shirou, presumably because it would mean nothing to
you, and thus you're making the presumption that he would basically carry on as before, protecting those close to him (like Rin and Ilya), excepting for the most extreme of circumstances. Whereas, in reality (as you would know if you'd actually
played the game), it would turn him into Kiritsugu mark 2, and thus he would have no hesitation in killing Rin, Ilya and anyone else that gets in the way of him destroying the Grail.
Cherry_Fucker said:
They could get in touch with Touko and get her a new body or something. And if someone wants to take Illya from a fucking MoS Shirou then god help them :sisi:
They
could, yes, but they wouldn't.
For one thing, Ilya would want nothing to do with MoS Shirou. If you read the game (which, BTW, MoB hasn't), it's clear that Ilya views his actions there as a personal betrayal (remember,
she was the one who convinced him to support the people he cares for first in the canon ending), and further he has become the person she hates the most, i.e. her father. Secondly, even if she
did want to have a relationship with him, he would kill her, because it's a million times easier than killing
Berserker and, besides, she's the Grail in any case, so getting rid of her ends the war.
Further, finding Touko is not easy. It took Rin a year to find a body, and she had to sell the Matou magic books to afford it. And, even then she never found Touko herself, only one of her doll bodies. There is no way in hell MoS Shirou would put that amount of effort into finding a body for Ilya, even if she somehow
wanted one having been betrayed by him just like she was "betrayed" by her father. Every moment he spent looking for it is a moment he could be saving others, and the resources he would use to pay for it would be resources he could use to pay for other things instead.
Hence why she is being drugged/locked in a basement. She can't exactly get in his way if she's all locked up now can she?
And why, exactly, would Kotomine do
that? What does he have to gain from it? And, even if he did, Rin would make damn sure that Shirou paid for it.
Shirou goes to kill Ilya, finds Gilgamesh who kills Berserker, Shirou kills Gilgamesh, problem solved.
Except that you missed out the "Gilgamesh rips Ilya's heart out" bit. You know, like actually happens
in canon....