The Force Awakens Spoiler Thread

Contrabardus

Well-Known Member
#1
What the title says. If you've seen the film or don't care about having the film spoiled this is the thread for it. No holding back on plot reveals.
.
.
.
I'm starting off by listing most of the major stuff off, you've been warned. Read no further if you still haven't seen the film and don't want it spoiled....
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
I'll say that this is probably the most well acted Star Wars film to date overall. Yes, previous entries have had some great actors, but the cast as a whole does a better job than any previous Star Wars film. No one is going to win an Oscar for acting here either, but everyone does a good job being convincing in their roles and handling the heavy stuff well.

Some of the shots in the trailer don't actually appear in the film. Such as the lightsaber being handed off or Kylo Ren igniting his lightsaber in the snow forest. That shot is on the Starkiller base. The name makes sense as it basically sucks up an entire star and then throws the absorbed energy at hyperspace speed at its targets, destroying several planets in the process. This makes for a very cool destruction sequence at the end of the film that isn't just an explosion, but rather the consumed star consuming the planet from within.

The McGuffin of the film is a map that leads to Luke Skywalker. It's a partial map, the New Order has the rest, but so does R2-D2, who spends most of the movie in 'low power mode', or a self induced coma. He comes on when convenient towards the end.

Poe Dameron obtains this from Max Von Sydow, who then immediately dies at the hands of Kylo Ren. He gives it to BB-8, who is then the central focus of the film. Our heroes spend most of the film trying to get him to the resistance, while the First Order is trying to find him and the map first.

Poe Dameron doesn't die in the crash at the beginning of the film. This is obvious if you've seen trailers prior to the film, no he's not a clone. At least it doesn't seem like it at this point. He says he was thrown from the Tie Fighter crash and woke up in the desert. I don't see the Resistance cloning him without telling him about it, the New Order might do something like that, but I doubt the good guys would.

Several planets are destroyed in the film. It's unclear how much damage this causes to the New Republic. The New Republic and the Resistance are not the same thing. The Republic does not appear to be officially at war with the New Order, but is not so secretly supporting the Resistance within New Order territories.

Kylo Ren is Han and Leia's son. This doesn't stay secret very long and is revealed early on in the film.

Rey is the main hero of the film and likely the trilogy. She has strong force powers and picks up a few Jedi tricks quickly. A little too quickly actually, she may have been trained by Luke and then had her memory taken from her before she ended up on Jakku. I suspect the look on his face may have been surprise that she had returned as much as anything else. She is old enough in the flashback we see of her being left there that she could have been a Padawan for a few years by that point, she also takes to the lightsaber pretty easily for someone with no real combat training. Finn at least is trained as a Stormtrooper, and it's clear they do have some melee training. Especially if she's Luke's daughter.

Finn is a Stormtrooper who defects. He gets cold feet at his first battle and can't handle the slaughtering of innocent and rescues Poe Dameron to help him escape the order. He has a thing for Rey, and she seems to return those feelings at least somewhat. He may also have the ability to become a Jedi, but it's unclear. He's definitely not as strong with the Force as Rey, but is able to handle himself with a lightsaber. He does lose both times he tries to fight with one, but does handle the weapon pretty well despite that. He is passed out and injured, but appears to be in stable condition at the end of the movie. Kylo Ren kicks his ass in a lightsaber fight, but he managed to hold him off to start with. I suspect he may also receive Jedi training at some point in future films.

Stormtroopers are not clones. They are taken from their families at a young age, given designation numbers, and Finn's actual "name" is FN-2187. Poe gives him his name in the escape sequence and he uses it from then on. In case you didn't catch that reference, 2187 is Leia's cell number in A New Hope. [It's also the name of an abstract short that had a heavy influence on Lucas's original Star Wars.] They are then trained by the First Order as Stormtroopers from the time they are infants. This is likely a remnant of how it worked in the Empire during Palpatine's rule once they abandoned the clone army for a more traditional force. It's also clear that Stormtroopers are both men and women, but men are far more common.

It seems to be implied that Kylo Ren is the one who turned on Luke Skywalker and destroyed his attempts to train new Jedi. I suspect he had multiple students and that most of them died. One may have been a romantic involvement, because Rey's lineage is never revealed in this film, and I still suspect she may be Luke's daughter. Especially given her supposedly extraordinary abilities in the force. It is not clear why she was abandoned on Jakku, but it may have been to protect her from something. It is extremely doubtful that she is Han and Leia's daughter given the amount of exposure she has to both of them in this movie with no mention of it. Though it is entirely plausible that they might be her aunt and uncle and might not have met her before.

The way Luke looks at her when she appears in front of him may also hint at it. His expression says a lot, and he's not exactly happy to see her, nor does he seem upset. She's probably going to have a hard time convincing him to train her.

I suspect that Snoke is actually the one who turned on him and that he turned and took some of his younger students with him, who then become the Knights of Ren. I like calling him Emperor Gollum.

We only see the other Knights of Ren in a vision Rey has when she finds Luke's Lightsaber. Han Solo takes Rey and Finn to a bar where it is inside a box in a back room. How it got there is never really explained in the movie and it's kind of cheeky about it. There will be comics and novels that go into it most likely, I doubt we'll hear about it in later films.

Captain Phasma is never really utilized. She's intimidating in the film's opening, but largely loses her menace throughout the film until she's captured and humiliated in the finale. They never show her fate, but it's implied they toss her down a garbage chute. She may or may not have survived the destruction of Starkiller Base. I suspect she has and that she may appear in future films and possibly redeem herself as a villain.

Han Solo dies. He is killed by Kylo Ren in the climax of the film. They confront each other on a bridge within Starkiller Base and he is impaled on his lightsaber and his body falls off the bridge and into a void. The base is destroyed shortly after, there is no doubt he's dead and gone for good. He likely won't be appearing as a ghost, but may have a cameo in future films as a recorded message or something.

Rey ends up with the Millennium Falcon and has Chewbacca with her at the end of the film.

Leia is the one who talks Han into getting himself killed. She urges him to try and save their son and convinces him to try and speak with him when he sees him, which gets him killed.

Luke has no lines in the movie and only appears in the final moments outside of a brief shot that may or may not be of him in the 'vision' Rey has. We see someone who is cloaked with a metal arm touch R2-D2, but the arm we see in that shot looks different from the one Luke has in the final shot of the movie. I suspect that might actually have been a shot of Rey's mother, and that it may be her who puts the lightsaber in the possession of Maz, the bar owner who has a thing for Chewbacca. It seems like the Wookie might be uncomfortable with that and may have been deliberately avoiding her. The pair have no direct interactions in the film, so it's hard to say for sure. Han seems amused by it at least and gives the Wookie an excuse for being gone when she asks him about Chewie.

Luke just turns around and looks at Rey, and that's the final shot of the film.

Anyway, it was an almost religious experience seeing the movie. It was great all around, though as I said, not Empire either.

A lot of that might have to do with the state of the prequels. I remember being hyped for Episode 1 and then having it be what it was, but this is that same feeling, but with a movie that actually doesn't disappoint.
 

Ordo

Well-Known Member
#2
A couple of things to add, Finn picks up things fast, he made a good gunner both times he was given that task and when he had a blaster in hand was a deadly shot. When using the Lightsaber against Kylo he did manage to tag the knight of Ren in the shoulder so he's certainly got potential.

As for Rey, I can't say for sure if she's a descendant of Anakin but I do note her Victory over Kylo was plausible due to the injuries he'd suffered from Finn and Chewie. It also didn' hurt that Kylo was trying to turn her when she sank into the force. That said the look on her face when she did it is concerning....that was anger. Justifiable anger, but we all know how well anger and force users go together.

As for Leia getting Han killed....I hate to admit it but yeah that's how it plays out. Truth be told I think Leia misread the situation. She figured Snoke turned Kylo like Palpatine turned Anakin.....Kylo seems to WANT to be evil and is actively trying to purge himself of the light within him.
 

Contrabardus

Well-Known Member
#3
Ordo said:
A couple of things to add, Finn picks up things fast, he made a good gunner both times he was given that task and when he had a blaster in hand was a deadly shot. When using the Lightsaber against Kylo he did manage to tag the knight of Ren in the shoulder so he's certainly got potential.

As for Rey, I can't say for sure if she's a descendant of Anakin but I do note her Victory over Kylo was plausible due to the injuries he'd suffered from Finn and Chewie. It also didn' hurt that Kylo was trying to turn her when she sank into the force. That said the look on her face when she did it is concerning....that was anger. Justifiable anger, but we all know how well anger and force users go together.

As for Leia getting Han killed....I hate to admit it but yeah that's how it plays out. Truth be told I think Leia misread the situation. She figured Snoke turned Kylo like Palpatine turned Anakin.....Kylo seems to WANT to be evil and is actively trying to purge himself of the light within him.
In regard to Rey, I strongly suspect that she's been trained at some point. The most telling scene is when she uses the Force to convince the guard to release her and leave the door open and his weapon behind.

She had never seen a Jedi or Sith do something like this before, not even Kylo. It seemed to just pop into her head as an idea and she immediately pulled it off with minimal effort. The first couple of tries didn't work, but once she cleared her mind she managed it too easily. That to me seems like something that is probably a suppressed memory and not just instinct from being strong with the Force. It's something I think would need actual training, and more than just natural ability to pull off.

She also handles herself a little too well in a fight to have no training at all. Again, more than just natural ability, and I don't mean just when she finally takes the lightsaber. She fights off attackers earlier in the film and handles the blaster pretty well for someone who supposedly never handled such weaponry before.

I strongly suspect she's been at least partially trained and mind wiped. I think that the Force calling to her is as much her own repressed memories trying to surface as the Force itself.

In regard to Kylo, I think you could have said the same thing about Anakin. He did basically try to purge the good from himself, not at first, but once he was turned he definitely did so. This is apparent in the hallway discussion between him and Luke in Return of the Jedi. Rebels makes it pretty obvious as well in the scenes he's in, and that's canon too. The similarities between him and Anakin are not accidental. He wants to be like his Grandfather at the height of his power, but I'm not so sure he knows the circumstances of his death either. Vader turned back in the end, so his pleas to him to guide him would probably not really be reaching him, and you'd think Anakin would be advising him against his path.

Leia definitely misread the situation as well. I think she was thinking that maybe Ben's father could get through to him where his uncle could not, but I don't believe it was any deeper than that. I don't think she knew enough about the circumstances surrounding Vader to really make that sort of call about how similar they are or are not. I get the impression it's not well known to begin with, and it's probably not something Luke would have easily spoken about outside of generalities. Even he wouldn't know much about the details of exactly what happened.
 

mario_zx

Well-Known Member
#4
Rey's capabilities with the force does seem to imply prior training, plus there is also the scene where she is able to take information from Kylo's mind when he was probing her, it was how she found out his greatest fear.

If she really is Luke's daughter then I think what might have happened is that when Snoke turned Kylo, he took her as well, mind wiped her and then left her on Jakku, and the sight of his nephew being turned and losing his daughter pretty much broke Luke.

As for Finn I get the feeling that he has some strength in the force, not as much as a Skywalker, but enough that he would be noticed, when he first defected Kylo picked up on him way to fast.
 
#5
I think she's Luke's daughter. I don't think she was trained as a Jedi though. I got the vibe that she's just heard all the stories (which are true, all of them) and had heard of Jedi controlling people's minds. Incidentally, my brother-in-law said he'd read that particular Stormtrooper was Daniel Craig. Anyone know if that's legit?

Also, injured or not, I see no good reason why Kylo Ren was on the ropes so much. All previous Sith types would have made short work of two civilians even with a prior injury. Of course, the injury itself doesn't make sense in context of the movie. The first time he's on screen he stops a blaster bolt with the Force. Also, every other time someone was shot with Chewie's gun, they go flying away like a Tarantino movie. How was Kylo able to no-sell it like that? It should have knocked him right off the bridge.
 

Contrabardus

Well-Known Member
#6
point09micron_process said:
I think she's Luke's daughter.  I don't think she was trained as a Jedi though.  I got the vibe that she's just heard all the stories (which are true, all of them) and had heard of Jedi controlling people's minds.  Incidentally, my brother-in-law said he'd read that particular Stormtrooper was Daniel Craig.  Anyone know if that's legit?

Also, injured or not, I see no good reason why Kylo Ren was on the ropes so much.  All previous Sith types would have made short work of two civilians even with a prior injury.  Of course, the injury itself doesn't make sense in context of the movie.  The first time he's on screen he stops a blaster bolt with the Force.  Also, every other time someone was shot with Chewie's gun, they go flying away like a Tarantino movie.  How was Kylo able to no-sell it like that?  It should have knocked him right off the bridge.
I don't think she was ever a Jedi either. I don't think she made it past Padawan and was likely very young when all this went down. I don't think her age in the flashback sequence where she was left behind was fabricated by the mind wipe. She was probably very young, but also old enough to have been trained at least a few years.

It's also plausible that it wasn't Luke that left her there, but that she might have been kidnapped and abandoned by Snoke or someone trying to protect her from him. One of the Knights of Ren who hadn't gone completely bad yet or another Jedi student who was later killed by them. It's also plausible that her memory loss wasn't done by someone else, but is simply how she coped with the tragedy of what happened to her, both being abandoned, and what likely happened to her prior to that. We don't know the details of any of it right now and probably won't for another movie or two.

Kylo has shown the ability to stop a bolt of energy in mid air. It's not a huge stretch that he might have been able to stop the knock back effect of the blaster bolt. He also didn't take it center of mass, and that might matter as well. It basically just grazed him along the gut.

It's also important to note that Kylo isn't fully trained. This is an important plot point if you'll recall, and one reason why I strongly suspect that he wasn't the one who masterminded what happened to Luke and the Jedi he was training. Snoke is the master here and limiting the amount of training the Knights of Ren have and how powerful they are is probably part of that control. He knows what happens if Sith apprentices get too powerful, especially in greater numbers. It's also why the line that Kylo be brought to him to complete his training is so important. It provides an explanation for why Rey and Fin would have been able to handle him.

I suspect Kylo also was still a padawan level trainee when this went down. He's clearly older than Rey, but also not that much older, probably within ten years. His training was not complete and he wasn't very powerful. That's why Rey and Fin were both able to stand against him with a lightsaber and little to no apparent training. Fin has probably had some as a stormtrooper, and as far as the movie tells us, Rey has never been trained in anything outside of scavenging. It's also odd that she knows so much about starships and how they work. Scavenging for parts alone would not have taught her all that she seems to know about how ships work. She's as knowledgeable as a ship's engineer in the movie, or at least as much as a well trained and experienced mechanic would be. She's educated and while we don't see her doing so, it's pretty clear that she can probably read and write.

Anakin worked for a junk yard and obviously had experience actually fixing things for his master. He grew up in that environment and working on repairs was part of his duties as a slave. Watto probably taught him a lot. Rey doesn't seem to have any such mentor or master. Natural ability is one thing, but she goes above and beyond that.
 

Meinos Kaen

Well-Known Member
#7
Regarding Rey: I don't really feel she's supposed to be related to Luke or anything -if they did, I'd roll my eyes SO HARD- or to have had any sort of training before hand. In her vision we see her being left alone on Jakku as barely more than a toddler. I think she's simply strong in the force, and if you remember in the first movie Luke himself did some pretty amazing things on the first try just because of sudden bursts of force insights. Like with the blaster deflecting thing on the Falcon, or when he destroyed the death star. I think this was felt as way too quickly because we had two in quick sequence -mindscan and then mindcontrol- and they were in stressful situations with no buildup. They felt more tropey than what Luke did in Episode IV. But I agree that many things about her development felt rushed.

Regarding the other characters, I'll make more long winded posts later, but I wanted to talk about Finn at least.

While I agree that Rey is the protagonist, I'd argue that Finn is the main character. He's pretty much the motor behind everything important in the movie, from Poe getting free to the rebels knowing how to destroy the weapon to Rey actually surviving her next encounter with Kylo Ren. He's also the one showing the best character growth -I won't say most because that's Rey, but his own actually feels well paced-. It also helps that he's the best actor among the newcomers, and this comes from a person who didn't like the biggest thing he's been in before this, Attack the Block. Boyega pleasantly surprised me.

And I have to agree with saying that he's probably going to get some Jedi training, mostly because otherwise I see no way for Rey on her own to beat Ren. The guy has been set up as a beast.
 

Ordo

Well-Known Member
#8
Rey has been rooting through Star Destroyers for some time and other crashed craft looking for valuable parts, she may have picked her knowledge that way, also I think she worked on the falcon for her boss at some point which explains her skill there. As for her abilities, if she's not a Skywalker, and didn't receive previous training then I am thinking she's like Quinn lon Vos with Force Psychometry (which I think is still canon after the Dark Disciple book) or she can see/feel what people are doing in the force and then make use of it. Ren probes her mind and after she defends herself from it she makes a few attempts to manipulate a storm trooper. Ren hurls her into a tree and then she yanks the lightsaber into her hands. Ren draws on the force to fight, she let's it flow into her to fight back when he's off guard.

As to Kylo, he's been taught well enough to be a danger to most people but there are obviously holes in his training. I mean Vader had more self control than he shows in this movie. When Vader got pissed he generally just force choked a person or stood silently radiating hate into the force. Ren goes Apeshit twice and tears apart whatever room he is in with a lightsaber (Which did lead to a fun scene where a pair of Storm troopers decide they should patrol elsewhere.) The fact Snoke is bringing him back for more training is concerning.....though could provide for a bit of a twist on the next movie. Imagine the film following Rey as she tries to get Luke back into the fight and Finn as he wakes up to find himself in the middle of open war between the First Order and the Republic (I'm relatively sure firing a superweapon at four planets counts as an act of war.) as we see Kylo getting the Darkside version of Yoda's training sequence.

And unless I'm way off, I'm pretty sure Finn, Poe and Rey are going to have their hands full since Snoke has Kyloe Ren and six other murderous bastards (At least) under his direct control. So even if we can get Luke back into the fight, taking down the Knights in an effort to clear a path to Snoke will be tricky.

Things to note:

- The First Order has improved upon Imperial OPSEC since no one outside the order had any idea they'd built a superweapon until they'd fired the damned thing.

- I caught that Finn was about to be sent away for "Reconditioning" which to me implies he broke through whatever program they run Storm Troopers through to make them loyal, on his own. This may be an indication of how strong his will and connection to the force really is.

- I'm having trouble reconstructing the timeline of Ben's fall. I mean to stand that tall over dead Jedi trainees (if that is indeed him) he'd need to be what...19 20? And Rey was five when she was left behind so.....hmmm maybe they all just look younger than they are....
 

Contrabardus

Well-Known Member
#9
In the flashback sequence Rey is much older than a toddler, she's not yet a tween, but she's probably 8-10 years old in that flashback sequence. That's still enough for her to have some level of training, especially if she's a Skywalker.

It's important to point out, that they wouldn't be hiding her lineage and making a mystery out of it unless it mattered. She might not be a Skywalker, but she's obviously not nobody either. Given the scope of her abilities, training or not, being a Skywalker makes the most sense. Unless she's a secret clone of Darth Vader or something, which I doubt, she's probably related to Luke.

You can't learn to fix a car by scrapping one. Being a scavenger is a different skill set from being a mechanic. I'm pretty sure pulling parts from wrecked ships didn't teach her how to work on spaceships. That makes no sense, not even in Star Wars context. She's also working freelance and doesn't have a boss. The guy at the counter is basically a pawn broker and I don't believe anyone there technically works for him. They aren't slaves, and he doesn't seem to have any authority over them. That's why he tried to buy BB-8 instead of just demanding the droid, and why he sent thugs after her to steal it when she refused. There is zero reason to think he would have her working as a mechanic at all. That's skills she picked up elsewhere, I'm almost positive about that. The boss alien does not seem friendly with her at all, and she isn't shown as having any friends there. Her only attachment to the place is waiting on someone to come back for her.

I don't think she's just pulling these things off or mimicking Kylo. For starters, he's using different powers, why would she figure out the ability to manipulate a weak mind from an attempt to read her mind? It's a different power, maybe similar, but different. Being thrown and frozen in place wouldn't really show her how to pull a weapon towards her.

It's not likely something she picked up from stories about the Jedi either. There's no indication that those powers were commonly known in any of the movies but one, and that's Episode 1 with Watto knowing about the mind trick. From the way he put it, it wasn't something he knew from personal experience and was something that he picked up through rumor, but probably through someone from his own race who had encountered Jedi. Jabba knew, but it was clear he knew about it from first hand experience and it was also pretty obvious that he had encountered Jedi before.

They were considered mostly legend even in the Old Republic because there weren't that many of them in the galaxy. Most people living in even the Old Republic never encountered a Jedi Knight, much less a Jedi Master. Even at their peak there were only a few thousand at most in the entire galaxy. From the way they were talking about the Jedi and the force in the movie, I got the impression that such stories and legends were incredibly vague and probably didn't include details such as the Jedi Mind trick.

What Luke did was more plausible. He made a shot that he mentioned previously he'd made in the past on the Death Star. Yes, he used the Force, but it wasn't some impossible thing that he'd never been able to accomplish prior to that. The blaster deflection thing was also not really all that amazing considering Obi Wan was right there and guiding him, and that he didn't do all that well at first. Han Solo was sitting right there and saw the entire thing and wasn't impressed with it, so it wasn't something that seemed outlandish to him.

He doesn't really do anything of note with the Force until Empire, and that was after a few years worth of training on his own. I believe him retrieving Obi Wan's journal from his old hut as shown in the current run of comics is canon as well, so he had some guidance beyond what Obi Wan initially told him.

I'm pretty sure Rey has had some form of exposure to the Force and how to use it in her past. What she does in the movie doesn't make sense without at least some prior experience. Even if it was just her being around the training of the Jedi and not being trained as a formal student. Even if she's not a Skywalker, she may have been one of the young trainees or waiting to become one.

It would explain why she was left on Jakku if she was such a child. Luke or one of the students who hadn't turned left her there to keep her safe from whatever happened with Snoke and Kylo Ren. I'm 90% sure she's a Skywalker though, she seems a bit too strong to be from another family, and the movie makes it pretty clear she's not a Solo. Kylo Ren would have recognized her if she was, and there was no reason for Han or Leia to not bring it up once she met them if that was the case. If she was Luke's daughter, there is a chance they might not have known her well enough to recognize her.

Adam Driver is 32 years old. He was probably born shortly after RotJ concluded and his character is probably a few years younger than he is, but not much younger, 29 maybe, where as I believe Rey and Fin are supposed to be several years younger. Rey seems to be the youngest and I'd guess her character is probably 19-20 years old. Boyega and Ridley are both 23 and I also believe their characters are supposed to be younger than their actual ages by a few years.

Fin is fresh out of training and in what is presumably his first combat mission during the opening, I don't think it's ever explicitly stated, but it is heavily implied. Given the First Order being what it is and facing a resistance, that can't be much older than 19 at most.

Kylo could have been an older teen when he turned against Luke and that would have put Rey at about the right age for that flashback segment assuming what happened to her was related to that. It's Star Wars, so everything is likely connected and nothing is coincidence. There will be family ties and past events intersecting as more is revealed, it's just the nature of the franchise.

As I said, I don't think Kylo was the one who masterminded it all, I'm confident he only followed the one who probably really turned against Luke, Snoke. It was probably Luke that scarred his face the way it is and why he's so hot on finding and getting rid of him.

So Kylo wouldn't need to be older than 16-19 when it happened and it would explain why his training is so incomplete. If he was 19-20 then he probably would have been basically a Jedi Knight by that point and mostly trained. That doesn't mesh with his level of training in the movie. Not unless he got a late start, which is possible, but I don't think that was the case here. He's not near the level Obi Wan was in Episode 1 or Anakin in Episode 2, and that's about where he should have been if he was really that old when all this went down.

I think the timeline events we see, indirect evidence such as Kylo's level of training, and the ages of everyone involved all match up well for Rey to be a lost padawan at least, and her being as strong as she seems to be in the Force suggest she's probably a Skywalker. Again, it's a franchise that is pretty focused on a particular family history and the symbolism of her ending up with the Falcon kind of plays into that idea as well.

On an unrelated note, we'll probably see Lando in the next movie. That will be interesting.
 

Ordo

Well-Known Member
#10
All right, I picked up 'The Force Awakens" visual dictionary so some notes and my thoughts.

- Once The New Republic and Empire signed a peace treaty called the Galactic Concordance, they disbanded much of the military and turned towards reshaping galactic politics.
- De fanged by the GC the old Empire withered away to a few hardliners that eventually broke off and headed for the Unknown Regions to found the First order.
- The Resistance is a small private force run by Leia that keeps watch over the F.O. and is tolerated by the republic which is too mired in politics to do anything.
- The galactic senate is no longer based on Coruscant but is now hosted by memeber worlds on a rotating basis.
- Apparently the resistance is using outdated New Republic Surplus gear and equipment.
- The F.O. has improved and standardized Storm Trooper training for the coming war.
- Mer-Sonn Munittions and BlasTech (to avoid treaty restrictions) created a spin off company (Sonn-Blass Corp) based in F.O. space to produce weapons for the order (meaning they're leadership should be the first ones with their backs against the wall if the N.R. was smart.)

- Finn 23 standard years of training from birth and noted as being highly skilled in simulation (lacks combat Zeal and submission to authority).
- Finn's goal in training was to protect his squad not serve the Empire, and his familiarity with being part of a team leads him to instinctively pair with and trust strangers.
- Being part of the sanitation detail was an element of his training rotation (makes sense from a military instruction standpoint.)
- Finn's good nature and moral compass could not be wiped from his mind as it is from other who undergo stormtrooper training.
- Ren draws upon the power of contradictory teachings of Jedi and Sith (and his own internal conflict) to fuel his power
- Ren's cape is singed from Multiple battles (So he's not just been stomping around looking mean)
-Deadly Lightsaber skills earned him the title of "Jedi Killer" suggesting he wasn't taking Rey or Finn seriously....or his story is inflated.
- Uses a cracked Kyber crystal in his Lightsaber....which says a lot about him actually....
- Rey is marked as a gifted mechanic (going to have to read the novel to see if this is explained) with an innate sense of how machinery fits together and functions
- The book notes Rey's fighting skills with a staff translate into other short-ranged melee weapons she's never used before
-Since the disappearance of Luke and the shattering of the Fledgling Jedi the cosmic force has lain dormant, seemingly quieted to those able to sense it's presence. The adventures of Rey and Finnon Jakku coincide with a turbulence in the cosmic force. a sudden ripple indicating the awakening of newfound ability.
- The First Order fleet could not match that of the New Republic's at it's height....but due to the N.R. disarmament the fleet now stands unchallenged. (facepalm)
- TIE fighters now have rudimentary deflector shields. Special Forces TIE's now have heavy weapons turret, limited hyperdrive and enhanced shield projectors. (Some one in the F.O. got a clue.)
 

Meinos Kaen

Well-Known Member
#11
Contrabardus said:
WALL OF TEXT
Not reading through all of that. Couldn't she just be born with a strong force connection without being a Skywalker? The Jedi weren't a family business. And just like her, Luke and a lot of other Jedis did things they didn't know they could do or found themselves naturally gifted because the Force guided them. That's one of the themes of the entire saga. Luke learned being a great X-Wing pilot without ever being on a X-Wing before actually being in an X-Wing.

Not saying you can't be wrong, but I'm just saying that explaining everything Rey is with: she's a secret Skywalker, she was trained before Kylo Ren was killed and then abandoned for some reason when not her, Luke, Kylo, Leia, Han or anyone else hanging around Luke recognize her or she recognizes them is maaaaaaybe rushing it a little.

Not saying it can't be possible. But it'd need everyone to have been mind-altered because reason and getting yeeeeeet another trilogy about the Skywalker family. Lame.

If Tekken can quit the Mishima, Star Wars can quit the Skywalkers. I miss the Old Republic.
 

Contrabardus

Well-Known Member
#12
So Kylo is something more similar to a Gray Jedi than a Sith? Pulling from both sides of the Force and using the turmoil to fuel his power?

That's interesting. I wonder if the entire order is like this, or if it's just him. He definitely seems to lean more towards the Dark side though.

Very different and darker than the way the Grays are portrayed in the EU.

I did notice the absence of the term Sith from the film. It's unclear if the Knights of Ren are a different philosophy just yet. We don't know that the other Knights have a connection to the Force as Kylo does. None of them appears to wield a lightsaber type weapon besides him.

Snoke's abilities and the source of them are also a mystery really. He intends to complete Kylo's training, but we don't know what that entails exactly.
 

Contrabardus

Well-Known Member
#13
Meinos Kaen said:
Contrabardus said:
WALL OF TEXT
Not reading through all of that. Couldn't she just be born with a strong force connection without being a Skywalker? The Jedi weren't a family business. And just like her, Luke and a lot of other Jedis did things they didn't know they could do or found themselves naturally gifted because the Force guided them. That's one of the themes of the entire saga. Luke learned being a great X-Wing pilot without ever being on a X-Wing before actually being in an X-Wing.

Given the established lore of the franchise, I don't see her managing what she did in the movie without experience and at least a little training. Not even if she's exceptionally naturally gifted.

Not saying you can't be wrong, but I'm just saying that explaining everything Rey is with: she's a secret Skywalker, she was trained before Kylo Ren was killed and then abandoned for some reason when not her, Luke, Kylo, Leia, Han or anyone else hanging around Luke recognize her or she recognizes them is maaaaaaybe rushing it a little.

Not saying it can't be possible. But it'd need everyone to have been mind-altered because reason and getting yeeeeeet another trilogy about the Skywalker family. Lame.

If Tekken can quit the Mishima, Star Wars can quit the Skywalkers. I miss the Old Republic.
Yes the Force guides Jedi and lets them do amazing things, but not nearly as quickly or as easily as you seem to think. Another big thing made clear by the movies is that Jedi training is very difficult and does not happen quickly or instantly. It's part of what makes the Dark Side so appealing, as it is a faster and easier route to power that can be used to achieve personal goals. Being a Jedi and using the Force requires a lot of training before someone would be able to do things like what Rey was pulling off. Even someone using the Dark Side, the faster and easier path, would probably need a lot more training and experience before managing some of what she did.

Luke was a naturally gifted pilot, but he still had to learn how to pilot the way he did with practice. He did it by flying around shooting pests and presumably dangerous creatures near where he lived in the canyons of Tatooine. Episode 4 explicitly states this, just like Anakin learned how to handle himself in a pod racer and dealt with a lot of failure before winning a race and also spoke to ship pilots and traders, as well as getting a limited amount of instruction in the layout of controls from the pilot of Padme's ship in Episode 1 prior to finally getting behind the controls of a starfighter.

They both had prior experience, instruction, and practice and weren't just instantly amazing.

Luke had experience piloting functionally similar but less powerful craft and knew his way around ship controls. The thing you see him playing with when he's giving C-3PO an oil bath is a model of his own ship that he flew around in the desert. It wasn't an X-wing, but it was enough to teach him enough to know how to handle the basic controls of flight for that style of ship. It's why he was confident in his abilities to fly an X-wing and why he suggested buying their own ship when negotiating with Han Solo on the price of transporting them.

She might not be a Skywalker, it's just more likely at this point that she probably is. From the way they're handling her backstory it's almost too obvious. That could be misdirection, but I don't think so at this point.

It makes sense from a logical narrative standpoint right now and fits what we know of the family a bit too well. The Skywalkers are the strongest Jedi ever, and the films are their family story up until this point. Plus, the plots of Episode 7 and Episode 4 mirror each other a lot, and she is in every way in Luke's role, right down to Han Solo being her short term mentor just as Obi Wan was to Luke and dying in front of her eyes in almost the same way.

I don't expect we'll see a non Skywalker lead Jedi character until the spinoff movies get into Jedi stories or in the next trilogy, whichever comes first.

There are too many reasons for her to be a Skywalker, and not really enough that suggests she might not be. If anything, it would create another plot thread to complicate things even more, and I think they're avoiding that for this trilogy, at least at this point.

Given the limited information available, I'll be very surprised if she's not revealed to be Luke's daughter. Snoke's history with Luke will probably be the big twist in the next film, because it's pretty clear that it's almost universal that everyone suspects that Rey is either a Skywalker, or in some cases, another Solo. I seriously doubt she's a Solo from what we see in the film, and that makes her being a Skywalker a lot more likely.

I think the plan here is to present us with an obvious reveal, and pretend that is the 'big secret' in the next movie to distract us from the real twist that occurs in the final act. Kind of like they did this time with Kylo Ren being a Solo in this one. It was heavily suspected and speculated on for quite a while that he was a member of that family. Then they kill Han Solo in the finale as the real twist. Now it's Rey's turn, and I suspect the details of the relationship between Snoke and Luke will be the real reveal in episode 8.

If he's not revealed to be one of Luke's Jedi students, it will probably be something like he is the true father of Anakin or a clone of Emperor Palpatine or something along those lines.

Another and weirder possibility is that if Snoke is Anakin's father, that she may in fact be Luke's aunt. That's not impossible at all, but might be a bit convoluted. Pretty sure she's a blood relation to Luke somehow or another though, at least based on the information currently available in the currently released films.
 

atlas_hugged

Well-Known Member
#14
Every scene in the movie was well done, except for a few poor choices (kylo ren should never remove his mask, that is the face of a boy band vocalist, not a sith lord).

My main problem is the overarching plot was just A New Hope v2, only worse. I think the main issue lies in Rey's character arc. She was an interesting character, until she started vomiting force powers. A side problem is that Kylo falls a bit short too.


Compare Rey and Luke in their respective arcs:

Luke meets a mentor, who begins training him in the ways of the force, on screen, by having him fight blind against a taser droid. Later in the movie, in the only instance of explicit force usage Luke gets, he fires blind into the death star, letting the force guide him as Obi Wan instructed (both while alive, and as a force spirit). A power was established in a training scene, and that power was used later.

Rey has no such scenes. She gains new powers as the plot demands, which could be setting up an interesting reveal later (she was actually Darth Revan the whole time!), but right now destroys any sense of tension. After her Jedi Mind Trick, I completely lost any fear that she was in any danger. And I was right. Later she learns to force pull under duress, out force pulls a trained force user. Later she goes Super Saiyan, and gets sweet lightsaber skills out of nowhere.

I'd have been fine if she was able to beat an injured and stressed Kylo Ren. I'm not fine with how she was able to do so. It reeks of lazy writing, and I don't know how I'll be able to watch the second movie with any sort of dramatic tension for her scenes.

All it would have taken is a few scenes actually showing Han mentoring her. Maybe he has some security footage on the Falcon that shows Obi Wan teaching Luke some force stuff, he shows it to her to engage her about the legends, and she is shown really getting into Obi Wan's lectures about the force. Maybe make it explicit that Luke's Lightsaber is actually teaching her force knowledge. I don't know. Just give me anything to establish she's good with/learning a particular force ability before she actually needs to pull it out of her ass to save her ass.

It's a damn shame, because her character was interesting until the jedi mind trick.

As far as Kylo Ren goes, he's a great villain, the only problem is his abilities seem a little too informed, and not really displayed. Sure, he was seriously injured in the end fight, but (and this is partly due to the problems with Rey), I was left wondering how this guy was able to pose any kind of threat to luke, or luke's other apprentices.
 

Ordo

Well-Known Member
#15
Every scene in the movie was well done, except for a few poor choices (kylo ren should never remove his mask, that is the face of a boy band vocalist, not a sith lord). 
I think that's the point. One, he's not Sith but a Darksider trained by Luke and Snoke, Two....evil can come in varying forms, and three notice he keeps the mask on for the most part when in front of subordinates. He knows the mask is far more intimidating than his face and he's using that for all it's worth.
I was left wondering how this guy was able to pose any kind of threat to luke, or luke's other apprentices.
1. It's clear that he wasn't alone when he killed those apprentices, there were six other warriors beside him during that slaughter.
2. Snoke's role in the massacre is unknown.
3. Luke was likely away when it went down...and returned to late to save his fledgling students.
 

Ordo

Well-Known Member
#16

....Well...there were at least two female Storm Troopers in this film so...yeah plausible.
 

Contrabardus

Well-Known Member
#17
In regard to that last lightsaber fight.

Rey was not instantly awesome. Except for the very end of the fight, she spends the entire battle running away from Kylo, who is heavily injured by that point and using pain to keep himself on his feet. That's why he's pounding on his wound, to keep himself from passing out by using the pain to jolt himself into alertness. She's on the defensive the entire time despite this until the finale when she 'digs deep' and manages to throw him off of her before the crack in the planet's surface splits them apart from each other.

Fin is also pretty much immediately destroyed. He lasts about a minute and has clearly had combat training for melee weaponry. Kylo underestimates him and gets a small wound to his shoulder as a result and then immediately crushes him afterwards. Once Kylo takes him seriously, Fin gets curb stomped.

It's also worth noting that Kylo is clearly still messed up from killing his own father. So he's probably not at his best level of control there.

As was said, he's not supposed to be Darth Vader or a Sith Lord. That's kind of central to his character in this movie, he's still not at that level and he fears he might not be able to reach it. This is directly stated when Rey gets into his head.

Still say she has had prior training in, or at least exposure to, Jedi powers in the past. She might not have been trained, but may have seen Jedi using their powers in the past at least, and that may have planted the seeds of the abilities in her mind so she could pull them off the way she did during the film. Something along the lines of what Qui Gon said to Anakin, to paraphrase: "I'm not allowed to train you yet. So watch me and pay attention to what I'm doing carefully and you might pick something useful up."

Skywalker or not, I'm willing to bet she was there when shit went down with Luke's Jedi and was left on Jakku to protect her from the fallout. I don't think it was a case of deadbeat parents, but a deliberate act intended to keep her safe and out of the mess that resulted from that. Much like how Luke was left on Tatooine so he could say safe and out of the way until he was ready. I also think that her ability to take care of herself in that environment stems from her exposure to the Jedi and possible training. Though again, pretty sure if she was trained at all, it was very basic beginner's training at best and that she hadn't even reached the level of padawan yet, or had just barely done so.

I also think Kylo might know who she is, but hasn't said anything for some reason. His reaction to being told that Fin had help from 'a girl' on Jakku was very interesting. That may also have something to do with why she survived a lightsaber battle against him and was able to fight him off. He may have been dealing with an internal conflict over who she is, and I suspect that he may have been the one who left her on Jakku originally to protect her from becoming what he was going to be. It could be he did so indirectly and had her sent there using someone else, but either way I think he may have been the one who allowed her to leave and end up there.

She might be a Solo and Han and Leia just think she died during it all, but I doubt it. There was no mention of her by either one during conversations about Kylo and I'd think it would have come up, even if they do have a hard time dealing with it. Neither one seemed to even consider it during the film either, which is telling. Evidence that she's probably Kylo's cousin is stronger than her being his sister, and still enough of a familial tie that he might try to protect her before he went off the deep end.

It could also have something to do with his obsession with Vader and he was intentionally leaving someone who could oppose him later so he could do what Vader could not. A sort of test for himself if you will.

I suspect that Kylo knows more about her origin than he let on during the film and he deliberately kept quite about it for some reason.

Also, who says those apprentices are dead? The other Knights of Ren came from somewhere after all. I do suspect that there was some death during those events, but I also find it very suspicious that it's never mentioned that his students were killed or anything about a slaughter. Only that there was a betrayal and that Luke didn't take the aftermath of whatever it was very well. We don't know the details of that yet, and as I mentioned earlier, I think Snoke is the true betrayer here, but also that Kylo Ren is not the only one he recruited from the ranks of the former Jedi students. It could be that few, if any of them, died and that he instead managed to turn them to the Dark Side.

I do think that some of the students remained loyal and were killed, but turning most of his students to darkness would probably have been a bigger blow to Luke than simply killing them would have been. He's a war veteran and able to cope with seeing his friends die, and I don't see simply killing them as enough to send him into exile as a broken man. Having his students turn against him, including his nephew, and possibly losing his daughter or niece in the process might do it though.
 

Ordo

Well-Known Member
#18
Rumor has it that Daniel Craig played the Storm Trooper Rey Mindtricked....can anyone confirm?

Also....When Rey has her vision....

“The idea of the voices was, we wanted the audience to feel – but not necessarily be presented right in your face — this idea that familiar, Force-strong voices were connecting with her. At least as well as they could…You do hear a little bit of Yoda. You hear Luke yelling out, ‘Nooo!’ from that moment in Empire. And you hear Obi-Wan at the end say, ‘Rey, these are your first steps.’…Here’s the cool part. We asked Ewan McGregor to come in and do the line. And he was awesome and we were very grateful. He was incredibly sweet and handsome, and all that stuff. Then he rode off on his motorcycle. Literally the coolest voice over actor ever.”
And as to the future.

“Everyone who has seen these movies thinks about ‘I am your father …’ and ‘There is another …’ But neither of those things were in [1977’s original] Star WarsStar Wars didn’t say Luke was the son of Vader. Star Wars didn’t say Leia was the sister of Luke. You didn’t understand what these references were: the Empire, dark times, Clone Wars. There were these things that were discussed that don’t get explained. George [Lucas] dropped you into a story and respected you to infer everything necessary to understand what you need to know…Can this movie actually also hold, ‘And Rey is this … And Finn is that … And this is where Poe is from …’ This is the first of a series. There is a story to be told. And it will be.”
 

Contrabardus

Well-Known Member
#19
Ordo said:
Rumor has it that Daniel Craig played the Storm Trooper Rey Mindtricked....can anyone confirm?
That's him. It's confirmed in several articles that site Daisy Ridley and JJ Abrams as sources and his IMDB page. He is uncredited in the role, so his name does not appear in the end credits, at least not in the theatrical version.

One such source.

They were apparently filming Spectre right next door and he's a buddy of Abrams's, so he hopped over got in costume and did it for a lulz.
 

seitora

Well-Known Member
#20
So...

Even brushing past the nuances of how inconsistent everyone's relative skill level is, did this movie perhaps feel too 'actiony' to you?

If you watch the original Star Wars, there really wasn't that much actual action in the film. There's things here and there like when Ben fights off the desert people, cuts off the guy's hand, and Han shoots Greedo, or when the Stormtroopers fire at the Millenium Falcon as it leaves Tatooine, but they're all really brief, small-scale skirmishes. The duel between Vader and Ben and then the Death Star run are the only parts where you really get any significant amount of action, and even the duel is pretty short.

All the other films too have significant downtime, though I would say Revenge of the Sith has the least, mainly filled out by the political drama shortly after Anakin kills Count Dooku.

In contrast, The Force Awakens can't seem to go more than a few minutes without a major gunfight or shipfight. The initial segment on the first planet Han and co. go to where Rey finds the lightsaber is about the longest period of slower pacing the movie has.
 

Contrabardus

Well-Known Member
#21
seitora said:
So...

Even brushing past the nuances of how inconsistent everyone's relative skill level is, did this movie perhaps feel too 'actiony' to you?

If you watch the original Star Wars, there really wasn't that much actual action in the film. There's things here and there like when Ben fights off the desert people, cuts off the guy's hand, and Han shoots Greedo, or when the Stormtroopers fire at the Millenium Falcon as it leaves Tatooine, but they're all really brief, small-scale skirmishes. The duel between Vader and Ben and then the Death Star run are the only parts where you really get any significant amount of action, and even the duel is pretty short.

All the other films too have significant downtime, though I would say Revenge of the Sith has the least, mainly filled out by the political drama shortly after Anakin kills Count Dooku.

In contrast, The Force Awakens can't seem to go more than a few minutes without a major gunfight or shipfight. The initial segment on the first planet Han and co. go to where Rey finds the lightsaber is about the longest period of slower pacing the movie has.

It's consistent with almost all the other movies though. Episode IV had the disadvantage of needing a lot of exposition and world building. Plus there were more technical limitations and budget constraints. The action sequences tended to be more compartmentalized because no one had done special effects like that before, ever.

Once they get to the Death Star things ramp up and don't really let up once they get going.

Episode 1 also had similar pacing to Episode IV. Not a lot happens throughout most of the film.

Empire and Jedi jump from one action sequence to the next, and so does Episode III. Episode II had quite a bit as well, but had to deal with the ham fisted love story as well and that dragged things down.

If you're comparing it just to Episode IV, sure, the pacing is very different. However, if you're looking at it compared to the franchise as a whole, it fits pretty well as far as that goes. It might be a bit more hyper, but overall it's pretty consistent with the other films.
 

Ordo

Well-Known Member
#22
 

seitora

Well-Known Member
#23
Contrabardus said:
Empire and Jedi jump from one action sequence to the next, and so does Episode III. Episode II had quite a bit as well, but had to deal with the ham fisted love story as well and that dragged things down.

If you're comparing it just to Episode IV, sure, the pacing is very different. However, if you're looking at it compared to the franchise as a whole, it fits pretty well as far as that goes. It might be a bit more hyper, but overall it's pretty consistent with the other films.
Not really. Empire starts off at Hoth, and while there's the whole sequence with the ice monster, it's again, 'small-scale' until the Empire invades. There's the whole entire sequence on Dagobah too which is fairly slow-paced, and Cloud City's first half doesn't really have any action, Han shooting at Darth Vader's hand aside. The narrative spices it up with short scenes here and there, like going through the asteroid field or the Vader vision scene on Dagobah.

Return of the Jedi starts off really strong on Tatooine, then we get some build-up between Dagobah and the Rebel Alliance base. There's fighting the Stormtroopers during the initial landing on Endor, then we get the entire freaking nativity scene with the Ewoks before we finally get the climatic battle of taking down the shields, Luke fighting Vader, and the Rebels destroying the Death Star.

Attack of the Clones had the garbage love story, but it also had the whole subplot with Obi-Wan investigating the missing planet, going to the Jedi Academy to find data, then actually going to the planet and investigating the clones.

In comparison, Force Awakens doesn't feel like it had anywhere near the amount of downtime that these other movies did. Perhaps my biggest issue is that the first two trilogies followed some parallels, with the first movie of each trilogy being for world-building and having significant downtime, but Force Awakens takes far less time to establish things and hits the pedal hard.
 

Contrabardus

Well-Known Member
#24
seitora said:
Contrabardus said:
Empire and Jedi jump from one action sequence to the next, and so does Episode III. Episode II had quite a bit as well, but had to deal with the ham fisted love story as well and that dragged things down.

If you're comparing it just to Episode IV, sure, the pacing is very different. However, if you're looking at it compared to the franchise as a whole, it fits pretty well as far as that goes. It might be a bit more hyper, but overall it's pretty consistent with the other films.
Not really. Empire starts off at Hoth, and while there's the whole sequence with the ice monster, it's again, 'small-scale' until the Empire invades. There's the whole entire sequence on Dagobah too which is fairly slow-paced, and Cloud City's first half doesn't really have any action, Han shooting at Darth Vader's hand aside. The narrative spices it up with short scenes here and there, like going through the asteroid field or the Vader vision scene on Dagobah.

Return of the Jedi starts off really strong on Tatooine, then we get some build-up between Dagobah and the Rebel Alliance base. There's fighting the Stormtroopers during the initial landing on Endor, then we get the entire freaking nativity scene with the Ewoks before we finally get the climatic battle of taking down the shields, Luke fighting Vader, and the Rebels destroying the Death Star.

Attack of the Clones had the garbage love story, but it also had the whole subplot with Obi-Wan investigating the missing planet, going to the Jedi Academy to find data, then actually going to the planet and investigating the clones.

In comparison, Force Awakens doesn't feel like it had anywhere near the amount of downtime that these other movies did. Perhaps my biggest issue is that the first two trilogies followed some parallels, with the first movie of each trilogy being for world-building and having significant downtime, but Force Awakens takes far less time to establish things and hits the pedal hard.
I think you're Remembering Force Awakens wrong and that the action sequences are just sticking out in your mind more. You also seem to have forgotten there's a lot of talking and scene setting on Tatooine in RotJ before the action kicks in, plus the segment where Vader arrives on the Death Star prior to that. It's twenty minutes before there's any sort of fighting, and then there's another lul in the action where they set up the Sarlacc fight.

Force Awakens starts off with a short battle with Poe, then we've got BB-8 and Rey on Jakku as a slow segment where not much happens, then Poe's torture, and then another action sequence after that with the escape from the Star Destroyer, then Fin arrives on Jakku and it takes a few minutes before the action sequence when the First Order attacks kicks in, there are several segments with the bad guys giving exposition, a few involving the Snoke hologram throughout the film, Kylo pitching a fit, Han explaining things on the Falcon, another slow segment in the bar with more exposition, then things slow down when they find the resistance for a bit, plus Rey talking to Kylo and escaping capture isn't an action sequence either, the rescue segment with Han and Finn on Starkiller Base isn't an action sequence either and nothing happens but dialogue and sneaking around until after the segment when Han faces Kylo, and from there we have the finale of the assault and escape from Starkiller Base.

There's plenty of down time in the movie actually where things aren't exploding that you're not recalling here. It's actually paced about the same as The Empire Strikes Back and Return of the Jedi.

There are only six action sequences in the film, five if you count the two that run together as one sequence. The assault on the Jakku village which is pretty short actually, Poe and Finn's escape is also pretty short, the First Order attacking and escaping on the Falcon, the Pirates and things on the barge [the escape in the Falcon and the barge are almost one long sequence], the assault on the bar where Rey is captured, and then the final battle that bounces between the air battle and the team trying to take down the shields and rescue Rey. That's probably really only about 30 minutes of total action over the course of the two hour film.
 

Altered Nova

Well-Known Member
#25
This movie was great. I wasn't a huge fan of them rehashing the "oh no the badguys have a new planetbuster superweapon" plot for the third flippin' time, and I'm not convinced that emo too-edgy pretty boy wannabe Vader is a good villain (but I'll give him time to grow into the role for the next movie) but overall it was fantastic. Great characters, great action sequences, and lots of great nostalgic fanservice for the older fans.

I love how the stormtroopers are actually somewhat competent this time around. Just two TIE fighters were a credible threat to the heroes in the first spaceship chase, and I fuckin' lost it when Finn lights up a lightsaber for the first time only for a random kung fu trooper with a lightsaber-proof electrostaff to suddenly step up and whoop his ass. Captain Phasma ended up being a total disappointment though. She was easily captured and humiliated by the heroes. Why the hell does she even have the authority to single-handedly shut down the planetary shields from any random computer terminal on the base? You'd think that would be something that could only be done from the control room and only by multiple technicians working in tandem. And why was she willing to shut the shields down? A good stormtrooper would rather die than betray their comrades like that!

I also thought it was interesting that the First Order does not seem to practice the same "You have failed me for the last time" ruthlessness the Empire was famous for. Vader would have force choked the life out of Finn the moment he noticed him not following orders, but Phasma just has him scheduled for "reconditioning." At one point I was sure that Ren was going to murder one of his lieutenants who had delivered bad news about the droid, but instead he takes out his rage on some inanimate objects. Even supreme leader Snoke didn't seem like he planning to kill any of his subordinates for their incredible failure. Is this a kinder, gentler version of the dark side? Or does the First Order just not have enough resources to be able to waste personnel like that?
 
Top