And now for the bit I had to leave out. Ron and Hermione.
In this fic, Ron and Hermione are confusing. In the beginning of this story, they lie. I want you to keep this in mind. In the beginning of this story, they knowingly and willingly testify against Harry, saying they had caught him doing things like practicing the Dark Arts, among other things, that made it obvious that he was going Dark. This was supposedly necessary to make everyone believe that yes, Harry really did murder all of those muggles, because as we all know, one of the first signs that someone might be gradually turning evil is that you just randomly up and straight murder everybody. And it worked. Their testimony was key to putting Harry into Azkaban. Do note that unlike most fics where Dumbledore is evil and/or crazy/misguided, Dumbledore did not put them up to this. They lied to him too.
How they could get away with lying to a man who is literally a walking magical lie detector is a question that remains unaddressed within the scope of this fic.
However, this is strange for two very important reasons. The first is one you might have already noticed. They literally have zero motivation to do this. Ron and Hermione lack any sort of reason to hang Harry out to dry like that. They just, apparently, randomly decided to screw him over just for the lulz, seemingly during the very trial itself. Now, while this behavior is expected from characters who might be willing to lie their asses off to make Harry suffer (Draco would totally do that, imo), Ron and Hermione are not two such characters.
So problem one: there is no answer to the question 'why.' At all.
Problem two is arguably even worse. Silvere seems to forget that Ron and Hermione did this not too long afterwards. In a fic that is a monstrous 50 chapters in length, by chapter 5 Ron and Hermione are spun as being 'victims of the trap set by Voldemort and Lucius,' as opposed to what they really were in chapter 1 and 2, which was 'dirty filthy lying opportunistic Judas-wannabes.'
In this chapter, and later chapters like it, they exist in a strange kind of limbo, in which they were both lying but also victims of Voldemort's deception to frame Harry. This literally is a paradox if you stop to think about it. If they were lying, then that means they knew it wasn't true, but decided to say it was anyway (for whatever mysterious reason). If they were victims of Voldemort's plot, then that means that they were telling what they thought was the truth, and thus being perfectly honest. They were merely wrong.
These two stances are mutually exclusive. You cannot be telling the truth and lying about the same thing, at the same time. Plus, they had no motivation. At all.
I can't go into much further elaboration here without getting into MST territory, but suffice to say, Ron and Hermione? They need to change.
Here's my idea, and it starts with a confession. I'm a fan of Ron when he's being a dick. I acknoweldge, and even argue, that he is not this in canon. I understand that the idea of him being a real ass is not canon, and requires a deviation that is clearly in OoC territory. However, the fact remains that I'm only entertained by Ron when he's being a douche. It's personal preference. Not canon. But I just like him better that way. Why? I don't know. Maybe it's because fanfiction tends to lionize everybody and their mother. Harry, obviously. Neville, horrifically. Luna, more often than not. Hermione, almost always. And quite a few others besides. To be honest, it's kind of refreshing to have at least one person that's getting poked in the opposite direction. It's a nice change of pace from everyone and their mother being spun as a badass messiah.
In canon, Ron is kind of vanilla. He's more of a prop than anything. The only times he gets any real character development, it's when he argues or gets angry with Harry or Hermione, but then (usually) apologizes for it later. Sure, you could make him a spell-slinging morally upstanding badass. And that's cool. But to be honest? It is my personal opinion that him being poked towards the dick side of the Force is more entertaining.
SO. With that in mind, I don't want to be giving Ron massive props here. However, by the same token, I want to keep this realistic, and realistically, Ron would never be so much of a bag of dicks that he would cheerfully boot Harry's ass into Azkaban and then take over as much of his life as possible (new Gryffindor Golden Boy, new leader of the DA, ect). That's Malfoy levels of dick, which is well beyond what Ron is capable of.
So here's my idea. Hermione is losing her mind over Harry getting railroaded into Azkaban. She's going through wizarding law, court cases, trial records. Everything she can get her hands on that could possibly get Harry out of Azkaban. This situation hits both of the two things that really set her off. It's Harry in trouble, and it's a blatant miscarriage of justice. This is saving the House Elves colliding head-first with following Harry to the DoM to rescue Sirius. Hermione isn't sleeping. Hermione isn't eating. Hermione hasn't bathed or changed her clothes in days. At this point, she is being fueled entirely by a combination of caffine and mania, and woe betide the person who tries to convince her to take a break, because taking a break is like giving up and letting Voldemort and Fudge win stop talking to me I need to concentrate.
Hermione is kind of obsessed about this. In fact, Hermione is kind of going to read every goddamn book that has anything to do with law and punishment if that is what it takes to get Harry out of a hellhole filled with murderers, rapists, Dark Wizards, and an endless soundtrack of Harry's parents being murdered by Voldemort.
Does Ron care that Harry is in Azkaban? Yes. But here's the thing: Ron doesn't feel the need to do anything about it. Why? Simple. Dumbledore is already doing every he can to get Harry out, as is the Order. Ron simply feels that it's a waste of time to do anything, because really, what could they do? Besides, it's Dumbledore. Harry will be out in no time, and then they can all hang out again and everything will be fine. There's no need to worry about it. Relax.
So. Hermione is going up a wall and across the ceiling, while Ron is blaise abou the whole deal. Naturally, this kind of pisses Hermione way the hell off.
How could you possibly say that, Ronald!? Harry is listening to Voldemort kill his parents right now, and all you can do is shrug and eat a sandwich!?
Look, Hermione, I don't understand what you expect me to do! Dumbledore is working on it. So is mum and dad and Moody and a bunch of other people. They'll get him out eventually.
Eventually? Eventually!? How can you possibly say that like it's okay!? Every second Harry spends there is a disgusting violation of absolutely every right he has! It's a miscarriage of justice! It's ministry corruption!
Yeah? And what exactly do you expect me to do?
I don't know, Ronald. How about you maybe try helping me look through all this!?
Why? That's just a waste of time!
And so forth, and so on. I feel that these reactions are fairly in-character for both of them. Hermione would naturally become absolutely obsessed, and Ron being indifferent to the idea of actively helping plays right into both his personality and his flaws. Ron can be accused of a fair number of things, but the biggest one by far is a lack of empathy and introspection. Pretty much all of his arguments with Hermione in canon were because he was not able to objectively look at himself, or put himself in someone else's shoes. Dumbledore and the Order is working on it, so for Ron, that's as good as problem solved. Sure, Harry's not back, but he will be, eventually. So why get worked up about it? Ron literally cannot understand why Hermione is losing sleep over this, seeing how Dumbledore is on the case. Likewise, Hermione cannot understand how Ron can be so indifferent to the fact that Harry was just railroaded into Azkaban and is being smeared yet again by the media.
I'm not going to lie. Hermione is probably going to punch Ron in the face over this. Either way, it's going to drive a massive rift between them. And it is my personal opinion that this is a canon compliant way to do it.
Thoughts?