Ranma ½ Is it any good

Dumbledork

Well-Known Member
#77
So far it's mainly a Ranma/Vampire Princess Miyu crossover so far, but Hellsing and Sailor Moon will be added to the mix. Ranma and Kasumi are not normal vampires but vampire shinma (and not affected by the sun, garlic, crosses,...)

Ranma is Miyu's sister as well as son/daughter. Sounds strange, but it's explained in the fic and even makes sense B)

The biggest turnoff for most people here will probably be that Ranma prefers his female body (and has so for a long time, just keeping up appearances to fool his father and the other morons) and Kasumi admits that she's bisexual but has a preference for women.

It's a rather well written and the story flows easily even if it's a bit rushed. The thing that annoys me though is 'Nodoko' and 'Kodashi'
 

PCHeintz72

The Sentient Fanfic Search Engine mk II
#78
How about this one:


Title: Death Reborn Evolution
Author: Shanami
Crossover: Sailor Moon and Ranma
Language: English, Rated: T
Genres: General/Friendship
Pairing: Hotaru T./Sailor Saturn & Ranma
Chapters: 8, Words: 35,485, Reviews: 110 Updated: 4-2-10 Published: 12-31-09
Status: In-Progress
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Events on Phoenix Mountain are altered subtly, leading Ranma into a new set of magical adventures. Magical Ranma-chan w/ wings story. R/Hotaru/Usa friendship, moving into the SM arc.
Initial reaction to description would make it a no go... but it could be good if the author is being flippant.
 
#79
Smells like rotting trash.
 

ringlhach

Well-Known Member
#80
It's very bleh. I've read most of what's up; Ranma gets killed at the failed wedding in v38, and then is reborn as some sort of female ice/water phoenix. Nodoka takes her and raises her in Juuban. Not bad, as far as I remember grammar/spelling, but story... yeah.

On the flip side, Hotaru, Nodoka and Chibi-usa have gotten character development, and Setsuna isn't out to kill Ranma-chan (yet).

At least he's honest about it in the summary.
 

Ordieth117

Well-Known Member
#81
I believe I've read Death Reborn Evolution, but I don't recall much about it. Positive feelings, but nothing special.
 

Lawra

Well-Known Member
#82
nuclear death frog said:
Smells like rotting trash.
Pretty much. It's basically an OC Ranko character with everything from the manga up to that point erased conveniently by Nodoka.
 

Seed00

Well-Known Member
#83
ringlhach said:
It's very bleh. I've read most of what's up; Ranma gets killed at the failed wedding in v38, and then is reborn as some sort of female ice/water phoenix. Nodoka takes her and raises her in Juuban. Not bad, as far as I remember grammar/spelling, but story... yeah.

On the flip side, Hotaru, Nodoka and Chibi-usa have gotten character development, and Setsuna isn't out to kill Ranma-chan (yet).

At least he's honest about it in the summary.
The old 'Take Ranma to Juuban after failed wedding and meet senshi a, b, or c'?

Haven't seen that one in a while.

No further comment.
 

Dumbledork

Well-Known Member
#84
The memories are slowly coming back. I find the story interesting. There are not many Phoenix!Ranma stories.
 

PCHeintz72

The Sentient Fanfic Search Engine mk II
#85
Dumbledork said:
The memories are slowly coming back. I find the story interesting. There are not many Phoenix!Ranma stories.
Thyere are several... including the ones by E-Type and Ozzallos... and at least one where he ends up with Kiima pretending to be Akane. But almost all make everyone very OOC.
 

genhoss

Well-Known Member
#86

PCHeintz72

The Sentient Fanfic Search Engine mk II
#87
I do not like to click on raw links blind... can you provide a author name and title?

EDIT: nevermind, the author is mykon1, found it by pattern matching the link in my own database. Though I do not know the story link, since I don't have that one.

Author tends toward Ranma-chan lock sex stories, though not all are lemon most are. The writing of what I've seen is ok readability wise, but most would find the material and plot offensive for any of several different reasons.
 

genhoss

Well-Known Member
#88
Sorry bout that but they were on mediaminor which has questionable content which is why i just linked the author story page instead, next time i will be a bit more detailed
 

PCHeintz72

The Sentient Fanfic Search Engine mk II
#89
genhoss said:
Sorry bout that but they were on mediaminor which has questionable content which is why i just linked the author story page instead, next time i will be a bit more detailed
The fact you linked the author page does not bother me at all... I merely meant you should have stated who the author was, I would normally say series and/or title, but since you were asking int he Ranma section I assumed Ranma.

When I see a raw link with no info, depending whom it was from I tend to ignore them.
 

Drunken_Loli

Well-Known Member
#90
Sorry for the thread necro.

<a href='http://www.fanfiction.net/s/2314624/1/' target='_blank' rel='nofollow'>The Road to Cydonia</a> its a X-Com/Ranma crossover is it worth the read? Its at 500,000+ words and I'm looking for something to read. There isn't a summary about the fic on the page, instead a summary on the current chapter.
 

Dreamingfox

Well-Known Member
#91
Drunken_Loli said:
Sorry for the thread necro.

<a href='http://www.fanfiction.net/s/2314624/1/' target='_blank' rel='nofollow'>The Road to Cydonia</a> its a X-Com/Ranma crossover is it worth the read? Its at 500,000+ words and I'm looking for something to read. There isn't a summary about the fic on the page, instead a summary on the current chapter.
I actually enjoyed reading this one. It's long, has good character growth and development.
 

PCHeintz72

The Sentient Fanfic Search Engine mk II
#93
Tenmu said:
Drunken_Loli said:
X-Com/Ranma crossover
Holy shit, do want.
I did not care for this one way back when I attempted to read it, got a few chapters in, and had to stop.


For Ranma XCOM crossovers, I prefered '1 War - 3 Sisters' by A Brown aka Nighthawke, and the multi arc saga by Ar-Kaos.
 

Dreamingfox

Well-Known Member
#94
PCHeintz72 said:
Tenmu said:
Drunken_Loli said:
X-Com/Ranma crossover
Holy shit, do want.
I did not care for this one way back when I attempted to read it, got a few chapters in, and had to stop.


For Ranma XCOM crossovers, I prefered '1 War - 3 Sisters' by A Brown aka Nighthawke, and the multi arc saga by Ar-Kaos.
Link please.
 

FlinFlon

Well-Known Member
#95
Dreamingfox said:
PCHeintz72 said:
Tenmu said:
Drunken_Loli said:
X-Com/Ranma crossover
Holy shit, do want.
I did not care for this one way back when I attempted to read it, got a few chapters in, and had to stop.


For Ranma XCOM crossovers, I prefered '1 War - 3 Sisters' by A Brown aka Nighthawke, and the multi arc saga by Ar-Kaos.
Link please.
Check this post:

<a href='http://z14.invisionfree.com/The_Fanfiction_Forum/index.php?showtopic=19268&view=findpost&p=1142777' target='_blank' rel='nofollow'>http://z14.invisionfree.com/The_Fanfiction...dpost&p=1142777</a>
 

Drunken_Loli

Well-Known Member
#96
<a href='http://www.fanfiction.net/s/3388913/1/Ranma_and_The_Doctor' target='_blank' rel='nofollow'>Ranma and The Doctor</a> is it any good? I like Dr. Who, so I was surprised to find this fic today.
 
#97
changing a little the dinamic of the thread: at what level of Fail <a href='http://www.fanfiction.net/s/1041573/1/The_Return' target='_blank' rel='nofollow'>The Return</a> is? ecause i have heard/read that Sunshine is a fanwankey et al, but this story came up in a conversation, so anyone have braved this Temple's 'shit'?
 
#98
shioran toushin said:
changing a little the dinamic of the thread: at what level of Fail <a href='http://www.fanfiction.net/s/1041573/1/The_Return' target='_blank' rel='nofollow'>The Return</a> is? ecause i have heard/read that Sunshine is a fanwankey et al, but this story came up in a conversation, so anyone have braved this Temple's 'shit'?
I regard it as terrible.
 

Croaker

Well-Known Member
#99
shioran toushin said:
changing a little the dinamic of the thread: at what level of Fail <a href='http://www.fanfiction.net/s/1041573/1/The_Return' target='_blank' rel='nofollow'>The Return</a> is? ecause i have heard/read that Sunshine is a fanwankey et al, but this story came up in a conversation, so anyone have braved this Temple's 'shit'?
The Return has literally nothing to do with Ranma 1/2, and only features characters almost recognizable as the Sailor Moon cast. It's a terrible piece of fanfiction, and it doesn't work well as a piece of original fiction either.

That said if Ranma-chan succubus is your thing go for it.
 

Lawra

Well-Known Member
shioran toushin said:
changing a little the dinamic of the thread: at what level of Fail <a href='http://www.fanfiction.net/s/1041573/1/The_Return' target='_blank' rel='nofollow'>The Return</a> is? ecause i have heard/read that Sunshine is a fanwankey et al, but this story came up in a conversation, so anyone have braved this Temple's 'shit'?
It gets pretty bad and I still think what he did to Kuno is just brutal and the entire situation around Nabiki showed that the super scary human organization is managed by retards. He also purposely writes it so that as many characters become sappy succubae as possible. Which I think is the real detriment to the story because all the plotting and side stories are reasonably interesting.

I've ended up poking fun at it a fair amount in my story Cliched Fantasy.
 
Top