Harry Potter Hogwarts Rejection Letters

whitewhiskey

Well-Known Member
You wANt h!m?

c0m3 @n) Ge7 Hi^^

 
Dear Hogwarts:

Monkey balls on a dragon sleeping with a rabbit that is jumping a tiger dancing with a rat filled snake strangling a goat that is being leered at by a horse riding pig next to the rooster laying the ox's egg on the lazy dog.

Make it happen or you will never see your precious Harry again.

Signed:
None of your damn business
Whitewhiskey, I like your rather subtle letter.

Deer Hogwarts,
I dun no how ya'll got yer birdie to finded us, but we needs Hary for the comin' sason. He makesed the gud shine.
Sinceredly,
Pickle
 

whitewhiskey

Well-Known Member
whitewhiskey said:
You know, it occurs to me that there could some otherworldly circumstances where the guardian doesn't know Hogwarts is in another world

To whom it may concern,

First, I must congratulate you on somehow getting your letter to such an impossible location and past the containment put in place by my sister.

But my chosen knight and heir needs none of your foalish parlor tricks, as he has studied intensively all the knowledge I have offered him thus far and still learns at an incredible rate. Indeed, he probably has more power in one limb than any of your teachers, and will truly show his worth to the world and those insipid twits who before abused him once I am freed and the lands know their true ruler.

Princess of the Eternal Night,
Nightmare Moon
Banishment log:

Year 992, Day 285

There has been an...interesting development this night. I felt the spells that contain me seem to quiver. With a lightning-like crack, I was no longer the only prisoner upon the moon.

It is a strange creature, with forelimbs like the claws of a dragon, only softer, maybe something like a monkey, but more developed. It wears odd and tattered clothes. It also seems bruised and malnourished, limbs seeming thin even for it's diminutive size.

I have no idea what this thing could be, perhaps some new race that has come to Equestria during my imprisonment, but this youngling has...potential. Even in it's weakened state, it was apparently able to teleport through my magical prison, even weakening my containment ever so slightly. Whatever this may be, it bears further study.

Year 992 Day 288

After three days of caring for the unconscious creature, it has finally awoken. It reacted to me with about as much fear as would be expected of a foal facing such supreme power. From questioning and following examination of his dreams and memories (He has confirmed himself to be male), I have learned close to nothing of how the world has changed in my time away. The youngling knows very little, if anything, outside of the house he was raised in. Although he spoke naught of it, I have found him to be both abused and neglected, haunting his dreams are images of what appear to be an especially heavy talking walrus and a creature that seems to be some sort of bipedal donkey who he refers to as Uncle and Aunt respectively. Both appear to have abused him both emotionally as well, to the point where he doesn't know his name, the only constant he is referred to as is Freak.

Examination of the youngling over the past few days has shown he has a strangely strong grip of magic intrinsic to his body.

It worries me that my sister's reign has degraded things to the point where one with such obvious power and potential is allowed to waste away under the unjust heel of obviously lessor beings, one of many things I will apparently have to correct upon my return.

I have decided to try and teach the youngling. It would be a waste not to and could prove to be an asset, as well as a way to fill time, if nothing else.

Year 992 Day 342

The youngling has shown an impressive improvement over the past months. Although he proved difficult at first, given that one of the few things his former caretakers taught him was that magic did not exist. Although a foalish and easily dis-proven idea, they had forced it into his head so much that he had inhibited his own power subconsciously.

After breaking this programming, he has quickly become the prodigy I foresaw. Already, he is able to use his magic to lift things a few times his mass with ease, and has quickly absorbed my teachings, both magical and mundane (It would not do to have an asset without a brain)

Year 994, Day 43

My chosen knight has advanced at an almost frightening rate over the past year, he has taken to his teachings with a fervor and dedication that reminds me much of myself in a younger age.

He has also begun to refer to me as...Mother...

I am unsure how to handle this new situation. Part of me feels righteous indignation, even as my student, for him to presume such closeness to me.

But, I will also admit to a certain...Happiness at this development. This would cement his loyalty and, as loathe as I may be to admit it, perhaps finally having somepony else as company after so long...

Year 994 Day 207

There has been a most surprising development with my student. Where I'd left to slumber my student, I found now a young alicorn colt of dark navy pelt and a mane as black as the darkest night which, along with his still piercing green eyes, was the only thing that remained even close to his original form.

The only explanation he gave was a wish. As he lay down to rest this past night, he wished upon the stars, with all his heart, and the stars answered his wish...

To be my son.

And this wish made him as he is now, the power of the stars above evident in his cutie mark, a shooting star with a lightning shaped tail. He is of elegant stature and gait that any mare with eyes would accept his suit once he has reached the age of courtship.

Now, truly, I must concede, he is an heir of suitable power, and now seemingly of blood, an alicorn.

I have a son, and I shall call him...

Star Bolt

Year 995 Day 26

Although he was required to relearn many things in his new form, Star Bolt's already quick absorption of my lessons has accelerated, only slowed by his need to adjust to his now greater power inherent to an alicorn. He has also had learned to fly with incredible ease, seeming natural in fight. In fact, he seems to have become more at home in his new form than his original.

However, he does at times become heavily fatigued and suffer from headaches, I believe he is pushing himself to overexertion. I have decided focus more on theory and mundane teachings to remedy this, for now.

Year 998 Day 260

My gradual wearing away at my sister's spellwork has had another boon. A letter appeared before Star Bolt sent with some odd form of teleportation, powerful enough that, like Star Bolt's arrival, wore down the imprisoning spells.

Assuming this letter truly is meant for Star Bolt, it appears his name was originally Harry Potter, surprising that a foal of such power had such humble beginnings as to be a son of a pottery maker.

I have answered the letter with a refusal, I see no need for my son to attend a school he cannot even reach at this moment to learn this he had probably learned years ago.

Star Bolt's headaches have had a resurgence as of late...

Year 999 Day 230

I have become worried. Star Bolt's headaches have become worse over the past few months, pushing me to the edge of my limited medical knowledge.

He has also begun to suffer night terrors, visions of death, the blood of innocents, his original kind...

I have tried to look into his dreams, but they are so jumbled and turbulent, the only constant I can see is disturbing, something like Star Bolt's original form, but with decidedly serpent like traits, and his eyes...they are the eyes of a madpony, one who kills without remorse or reason.

Year 999, Day 245

I have nearly been locked upon the moon for a thousand years, and now I need to escape more than ever.

I have extensively examined my son in every way I know, and I have found the source of his ailment. A scar upon his brow, something I had long ago dismissed as a mark of his foalish former caretakers. There is something within the scar, something evil that has gripped my son's soul, digging into him like a cancer, and it has been inexplicably been growing stronger in recent months. His magic has grown weaker by the day, as has his body, looking more and more like the sickly creature I found years ago.

I can stall it, contain it, but only temporarily. My power, as it is now, would only feed this darkness and deepen it's roots into my son.

I doubt even my sister could aid my son as he is now, so there is only one hope I can think of, so my hoof is forced. I shall beseech the stars for their aid, as my son did years ago, to break my weakened containment. Celestia will most likely see the signs, but I have no other option. I will not lose my son!

I will have the Elements, even if I must take them from my sister's cooling corpse...​

0808080

Celestia stepped towards her sister, now purified by the Elements of Harmony, only to be forced back, barely avoiding a strike from the horn of the younger alicorn.

Even in her currently weakened state, Luna, formerly Nightmare Moon, stood with an almost maddened look in her eyes.

"Give...Me...The Elements," Luna panted, her body shaking.

"Sister," Celestia said, hesitantly, "You are not well, your body has been left weakened when the dark forced left you, we should get you to-"

"NO!" Luna barked, her voice shaking the castle, "I need the Elements, Celestia, and I'll take them," She glared at the Element's current holders, "From your dead bodies if I mu-" Lune stopped, her eyes shooting wide as she felt something break, "No," she whispered, tears welling up in her eyes, before she took off in a dash, past the ponies and her sister, "NO!"

Celestia and her subjects followed suit, chasing after Luna through the ancient castle, watching the night princess ascend a tower Celestia recognized as Luna's from long ago.

When the seven mares finally caught up to the night princess, she was in a hastily refurbished room, openly weeping over young, sickly colt laying on a bed.

"Star Bolt! Please, say something," Luna sobbed, "Please..."

The sickly colt could barely open his eyes, their once sharp green cloudy and dull, his breaths shallow, "M-Mother?"

"Yes, my son," Luna answered, nuzzling her colt.

"M-mother," Star whimpered, "It hurts."

"I-it's alright, it will be alright, my son," Luna sobbed, forcing a smile, "My sister has brought help, you will be fine." Walking away from the bed, Luna glared at her sister, and spoke in a low voice, "I do not care what you plan for me, execute me, imprison me again, do what you will, but please," Luna could no longer keep her composure, her head dropping, "Please, save my son, the Elements are the only way to free him from the taint that threatens his very soul, they are his only chance."

Seeing her sister breaking down, Celestia turned and nodded to her student, "Twilight Sparkle, do what you can."

Unsure, Twilight and her friends gathered around the young pony as their necklaces began to glow, an orb of light, every color of the spectrum, enveloping the colt as he began to float.

080-Elsewhere, in another reality-080

Albus Dumbledore steeled himself for the coming battle, knowing it may be his last. Approaching the castle were the forces of darkness, lead by Voldemort, resurrected by the stolen Philosopher's Stone. Staring down his former student, Dumbledore drew his wand.

0808080

Luna watched as a dark miasma formed around her son, the Element bearers beginning to strain as it hissed like a snake, coalescing around the young colt.

Seeing the pained expression on her son's face, Luna steeled herself, dredging up what power she had left, she focused it into her horn and charged, ignoring her sister's cries as she leaped into the light, a roaring battle cry echoed as she drove her glowing horn into the shadow.

She didn't care if she died, she would protect her son.

0808080

Dumbledore could feel himself tiring as he dueled the monster that was once Tom Riddle. His chances were almost none with Voldemort backed up by the Philosopher's Stone, but he had to try. In the back of his mind, Albus did something he hadn't done since his mother died.

He prayed, he prayed to whatever power was listening for a miracle.

And something answered...

In the middle of the incantation for the Killing Curse, Vodemort dropped to his knees, screaming in such pain that all battle near him stopped. It felt as if something was burning him from the inside, he couldn't muster any sort of thought, let alone cast a spell. Like breaking glass, the dark wizards skin began to crack, light shining through as he tried to fight it off.

He was Lord Voldemort, the greatest wizard to ever live. He was immortal, he would not be defeated.

Voldemort felt a sudden stabbing in his body and something snapped. Every dark deed, every murder, every torture, from the innocents he'd slaughtered to the unicorn's blood he'd sustained himself on, his body and soul burned in the light.

A voice rang out, everywhere and nowhere, loud enough to shatter glass as storm clouds circled above.

"YOU SHALL NOT TAKE MY SON!"

With that, Voldemort erupted in a bright burst of light that cascaded in all directions, sweeping across the battlefield and beyond. Dementors, inferi and Vampires burned away into nothing in an instant, werewolves and death eaters fell to the ground, writhing in pain, unable to withstand the pure power of the light.

For many years after, Wizards the world over would wonder as to what had happened to turn the tide of the battle, the lands, remains and survivors would be analyzed to an insane degree, and they would barely scratch the surface of the light that had literally shattered the darkness. Only Albus Dumbledore had an inkling to the source, the mother whose sacrifice had, again, saved the world.

And even he would be wrong, in a way.

0808080

As the light cleared, Luna found herself, no longer in the long abandoned castle, but a beautiful field of flowers of every color and shade, even some she'd never seen on a flower.

"Your highness."

The voice startled Luna, who spun around to find her son, sleeping soundly, with his head in the lap of another, one of his original race, a female, she guess, with a long red mane.

"Who are you, and what are you doing with my son?"

The female smiled softly, "Just taking my last opportunity to thank you, your highness, for saving him, and being a mother when I could not."

Luna balked as she was engulfed in a bright light, finding herself back in the ancient castle, standing over the bed as her son's eyes opened.

Luna didn't care what came next, if she was to be a princess or a prisoner, this, by far, was her most important title.

"Mother..."
 
Dear Headmaster Dumbledore,

My son would be delighted to attend your school provided it meets the standards of his personal tutors, Zatanna Zatara and Jason Blood, in terms of curriculum. It must also meet my standards in terms of security. A man in my position has many enemies, not simply limited to the Muggle World. There will also be times when my son will be required elsewhere for personal business. Do not worry: His studies will not fall behind. I am many things, but a neglectful guardian is not one of them.

I look forward to meeting you in person where you will accept these terms.

Sincerely,

Bruce Wayne
USA
 

seitora

Well-Known Member
Harry as Robin?

Also, whitewhiskey: epic.
 

scriviner

Well-Known Member
Buggerit,

Hari iz note gunna atend hoGwertz. Thnk yu.

*in very different handwriting*

Buggerem. Millenium hand and shrimp.

No solo mio.

Ducks.

- Foul Ole Ron
 

Amaretto

Well-Known Member
So yea Daleks and the Doctor... damn it.

Contained within an envelope labeled do not open or deliver until September 1991. Several seals and wards litter the corners of the worn paper but it has finally arrived at its destination.

To Hogwarts,

I don’t know how you got that owl to us but she was a life saver! I mean really how did you get her to slip through both folded n-space and a recursive time loop? This little beauty broke us out of that paradox quite nicely. Anyway, I’m not sure when you’ll get this but ’91 isn’t a good year for me. I don’t really know how to put this but I already exist in that time line and cannot really be two places at once. Time is wibbley wobbly but I think this is one of those immovable black hole kind of things. Maybe we could meat up in say 1956 or ’47 would also be a good year for me as well. Anyway, we go that flux capacitor and driver’s side fender out of the Errol delineator. With any luck the Doctor will have us up and running in the morning. We’re both getting pretty bored with hanging out in 2015.

Best Regards

Harry Potter
 

whitewhiskey

Well-Known Member
A certain thread in the Cartoons section got me this idea. Probably write a set-up for it later
---------

Professor McGonagall,

I was actually surprised your letter found Harry after our move and my remarriage, though I suppose I shouldn't have been, magic and all.

I realize you and professor Dumbledore were probably looking forward to Harry attending Hogwarts, but he has decided to decline. I am sure that Hogwarts is a nice school, but I am also fairly certain there are good schools of magic here in the U.S. where Harry wouldn't have to be so far from his family, perhaps even one where he can return home for the weekend (I am also very certain my husband would love a chance to study magic in action).

You see, my step-daughters have become quite close friends with Harry and while a trip to Brittan would be a matter of little effort for them, I would also miss Harry terribly, as he would miss all of us.

My Apologies,

Petunia Utonium
 

whitewhiskey

Well-Known Member
whitewhiskey said:
To Whom It May Concern,

Harry has no need to go to some back-water school to learn magic, especially when we already deal with things beyond the comprehension of your weak minds on a weekly basis.

And I will not be deprived of the only intelligent conversation I have in this town. Bother us again, and I will be...displeased...

Amanda Maxwell
Endsville, USA

P.S. Enclosed are the heads of a few of your wizard friends who decided to visit Harry and I shortly after your letter arrived. Our 'Best Friend' didn't take well to their attack, or their choice in naming their little club. We kept the masks, wands, and their souls.
---------
"I swear, how do you stand 'dat girl?"

A pair sat on the steps outside of a modest house. One a young boy, and the other who had asked the question was, well, decidedly older and very much less...alive.

"She's my best friend, and my first friend," the boy answered simply. She was kinda his only friend, actually, besides Grim, being the only one Dudley didn't scare off.

"She's a menace, 'dat's what she is," the hooded skull huffed.

"Says my friend who just killed a dozen wizards and took their souls."

"And she tool 'deir masks an' you took 'dose wands," if he had eyes, Grim would be rolling them, "She's a bad influence on you, boy."

"Maybe," Harry said with a smile, "But if she wasn't my friend, then I wouldn't have you as my friend either."

"An' I'd be happier free of you brats."

"You know you love us," Harry said, smiling.

"Harry! Grim!" a voice called them into the house. The two entered to find a blonde girl in a pink dress, about Harry's age, sitting in a chair, calmly sipping tea.

Across from her on the couch sat Harry's Aunt, Uncle and Cousin, pale faces of fear looking like they had spoken with the devil, and in some opinions, they had. It was amazing how the girl could frighten adults without ever raising her voice, and amusing to Harry how his family found Mandy's presence to be more frightening than Grim himself.

"Yes, Mandy." Harry greeted as he entered.

"It seems your aunt was nice enough to hold onto your mom's old school trunk, it should have all of her books and notes for us to study."

"'Us'?"

"Grim!" Mandy barked, "Make me a witch."

Grim sighed, he really should have seen this coming, no way the little monster would let a chance for power go by. He could stand to sacrifice a couple of his new souls, but she was going to be insufferable after this.
 

seitora

Well-Known Member
Ruskbyte already has a pair of amazing stories with that exact crossover, one with some comedy, one freaking super-dark.
 

whitewhiskey

Well-Known Member
seitora said:
Ruskbyte already has a pair of amazing stories with that exact crossover, one with some comedy, one freaking super-dark.
I know, and he takes super long to update. Kinda wish there was more, though
 

seitora

Well-Known Member
whitewhiskey said:
seitora said:
Ruskbyte already has a pair of amazing stories with that exact crossover, one with some comedy, one freaking super-dark.
I know, and he takes super long to update. Kinda wish there was more, though

You could always...write something longer than snippets and short one-shots!



(but seriously, I see you writing lots and lots of shorts but never anything long, why is that?)
 

whitewhiskey

Well-Known Member
Mostly because I have trouble writing longer stuff, when I plan, I seriously plan, but I have serious trouble focusing long enough to type, especially being in my final year of university
 

sikle

Well-Known Member
Ruskbyte updates?

I mean, sure, I remember him updating that Harry Potter time travel story a while back, and he made a few interesting new things since...

Didn't some serious political upheaval go down in his locale recently? IIRC he's based in South Africa.
 

seitora

Well-Known Member
If you mean South Africa, South Africa's always been a bit of a hotspot for trouble, even post-apartheid.

The only thing that occurs to me as really serious recently was the breaking of the coal mine attacks with dozens of miners getting killed. And one hotshot radical who headed the national governing party's youth wing was also disbarred from the party, too.
 
Dear Hogwarts,

No. Just no. I will not have my son learn wand waving crap at your backwater school of inbreds and people you con into thinking your school of magic is the best. That's bullshit and as a former President of the United States...until that incident with a hooker...well anyway I know more than those wide eyed mundaneborn kids.

No I say. My son shall learn SCIENCE and kick the shit out anyone that battle him. Be it Linkara or anyone else! Even that crazy woman with all the make up and her own minions.

Bother me again and I'll level your school with Neutro. Hell I might as well do that anyway.

Sincerely

Doctor Insano!
 

seitora

Well-Known Member
I'm considering Naruto raised by Bill Nye thanks to that last post.

And now I'm imagining Bill Nye the Science Guy as being some sort of alternate universe where Bill Nye is literally God.

Although of course crack nearly killed Bill Nye.
 

whitewhiskey

Well-Known Member
Professor McGonagall,

Sorry, but no. Hex is doing just fine learning magic from me, and he's kinda become our own little mascot.

Plus, you have no idea how funny it is seeing those Titans getting knocked around by a pre-teen.

Seriously, it never gets old

So, Hex is staying.

Later,
Jinx
 

Amaretto

Well-Known Member
“Incoming transmission….” Dumbledore looked at the small device curiously as it came to life. The delivery owl shook its head and flew off.

A man whose face was obscured by shadows began to speak. “Greeting head master.”

“Hello, I must admit this is quite unexpected.” Dumbledore examined the unusual device with much curiosity.

The shadowed man gave no reaction to the headmaster’s reply. “It has come to the attention of the council that you are attempting to contact one of our operatives.”

A grey eyebrow arched slightly on Dumbledore’s face as he tried to figure out just what or who the man was talking about. “You seem to have me at a disadvantage sir.”

“I know,” the monotone voice replied. The headmaster could see the man open a manila folder. “Operative Warlock, also known as Harry Potter is the subject of our discussion.”

The headmaster nearly choked as the topic of their discussion was revealed. He did his best to school his expression and remain calm. “Ah, Mr. Potter, many people are quite eager for him to return to the magical world and begin his education.”

“The council has decided it is not in Mr. Potter’s nor the council’s best interests for him to attend your institution.” The silhouetted man stated with an arrogant tone. “He is a key asset to the Commander and Strike One. His skills and abilities have proved most useful in our ongoing conflict.”

Dumbledore’s eyes bulged slightly as the conversation took a most unexpected turn for him. “I assure…”

The head master was cut off before he could offer a rebuttal. “Mr. Potter will be receiving extensive tutoring in the magical arts.”

“Sir, I do not believe you understand the danger Mr. Potter is in.” Dumbledore attempted to regain a foot hold in the conversation.

“I understand the danger we are in all too well.” The man’s tone became angry as he leaned in. “That is all headmaster.”

Before Dumbledore could respond the connection was cut and the device began to grow warm in his hand. The tiny disk soon became too hot to touch before he had to drop it onto his desk. Paper began to cringe and then caught fire as the disk immolated itself.


Playing way too much XCom
 
To whom it may concern:

Mr. Harry Potter will not be going to your heretical, demon worshipping school to be corrupted from the righteous path he is currently on.

Signed,
Father Alexander Anderson
Paladin of Iscariot Organization, Guardian of Harry Potter
 

whitewhiskey

Well-Known Member
Professor McGonagall,

Harry will not be attending Hogwarts. In fact, he will be attending no school in your reality...Ever...

Let me tell you a story, five years ago, during their studies of the artifact they call The Veil, one of your Unspeakables had the bright idea to see what happens when the Killing Curse is sent into the veil. Nothing happened, and they continued their studies.

But something did happen in our reality, a single mother lost her only son, a child with a heart and soul more pure than any other being, a boy who would be destined for such great things, who would do such good in our world...

A life snuffed out due to one man's ignorance and carelessness, and our world lost one who was chosen for an incredible destiny.

I came to your reality to seek vengeance, and it was mine, that fool spent the rest of his days being chased through the Distortion World.

But what else did I happen to stumble upon? My portal opened, unseen, over a quaint little community, where a child, touched by destiny, lay beaten and un-helped, so I sought...Balance, in a way...

You took one of Our chosen, so I took yours...

Worry not, although he will have his trials, Harry has lead a far happier life as a Ketchum than he would have ever had as a Potter, under a Dursley's heel or your headmaster's manipulations, and even in the past year since his journey began, he has accomplished great deeds.

Perhaps, one day, I shall appear to him, and offer a chance to aid you in your coming dark times, ask him if he wishes to help those who abandoned him to sorrow and abuse.

You had best pray for his mercy.

Good Luck,

Arceus
 

ArchfiendRai

Well-Known Member
whitewhiskey said:
Professor McGonagall,

Harry will not be attending Hogwarts. In fact, he will be attending no school in your reality...Ever...

Let me tell you a story, five years ago, during their studies of the artifact they call The Veil, one of your Unspeakables had the bright idea to see what happens when the Killing Curse is sent into the veil. Nothing happened, and they continued their studies.

But something did happen in our reality, a single mother lost her only son, a child with a heart and soul more pure than any other being, a boy who would be destined for such great things, who would do such good in our world...

A life snuffed out due to one man's ignorance and carelessness, and our world lost one who was chosen for an incredible destiny.

I came to your reality to seek vengeance, and it was mine, that fool spent the rest of his days being chased through the Distortion World.

But what else did I happen to stumble upon? My portal opened, unseen, over a quaint little community, where a child, touched by destiny, lay beaten and un-helped, so I sought...Balance, in a way...

You took one of Our chosen, so I took yours...

Worry not, although he will have his trials, Harry has lead a far happier life as a Ketchum than he would have ever had as a Potter, under a Dursley's heel or your headmaster's manipulations, and even in the past year since his journey began, he has accomplished great deeds.

Perhaps, one day, I shall appear to him, and offer a chance to aid you in your coming dark times, ask him if he wishes to help those who abandoned him to sorrow and abuse.

You had best pray for his mercy.

Good Luck,

Arceus
I legit just had an almost-fanboy moment. This is embarrassing.

Someone, please. Do this.
 
Top