Why did the villagers treat Naruto badly just because he was the Kyuubi Jinchuuriki? Why weren't he and villagers told about his heritage? (Knyght)
RE: The Naruversity
Found this pretty solid answer of r/Naruto to the questions of:
Why did the villagers treat Naruto badly just because he was the Kyuubi Jinchuuriki? Why weren't he and villagers told about his heritage?
Found this pretty solid answer of r/Naruto to the questions of:
Why did the villagers treat Naruto badly just because he was the Kyuubi Jinchuuriki? Why weren't he and villagers told about his heritage?
You need to keep in mind that we are readers that are looking into this world that are informed of all the different rules and important pieces of the story. The people that make up this world do not share the same knowledge we do, just like we don't know most of what goes on in the real world and are easily influenced by rumors and hearsay.
To the people of the Narutoverse, the nine tailed beasts are the equivalents of demons. Note how in Part 1 both Kurama and Shukaku are frequently referred to by this name. This is the same for most of the uninformed in all the countries of the Narutoverse. Many people probably do not even believe them to be real. This is where all the rumors surrounding them came from.
Some of these rumors include the one about the Nine Tails appearing in times of conflict/hatred and how the citizens of Sunagakure came to believe that Shukaku itself was a living ghost of a corrupted priest sealed inside a tea kettle. This just goes to show you how the people of the villages are. And it's pretty realistic actually, when you stop and think about the rumors people spread about the people in power and such.
You cannot expect the people of the villages to be able to grasp these concepts immediately without it causing a shitstorm of events. These people probably hardly understand chakra as it is, let alone the concept of sealing mass beasts of chakra into children to make living weapons. You're giving the people of the villages far too much credit when in reality they are just like us and and too indulged in their own world to really care to understand how the world works. They're selfish like that.
The people of the village are really brought up to think that their village is indestructible and safe. They refer to the Hokage as their lord and believe that as long as the Hokage is around, nothing can defeat them. It's this nationalistic thinking that convinces people to participate in the wars that the villages wage and makes them want to die for it. The people of the villages are subject to the same propaganda that we are in the real world
Hence why you should be able to understand that when the Nine Tails' Rampage happened, and Naruto was said to be host of the Nine Tails, a massive shitstorm happened and rumors spread about like wildfire. These are people who just had their homes destroyed by this very "demon". Do you really expect them to calmly comprehend the situation or understand what a Jinchuriki is, let alone why they are necessary?
If people understood just how unstable Jinchurikis are, they would become even more fearful of the Jinchuriki then they already are. It's bad enough they hear that creatures they believe to be demons are sealed within these children, but if they know that these same demons can be unleashed at any time, destroying their home as they know it, they're gonna be pretty damn fearful. Just look at Killer Bee. He was said to have went on a rampage in the Cloud many times. It's no damn wonder why everyone in the village feared him.
Like I said, the people in these villages aren't the reader and don't possess the same knowledge we do. As the reader, we know pretty much everything. We know just what should be done in every situation because we possess all this knowledge. You have to take into account that these people of the villages don't.
And like I said, they worship the Hokage. So say they're told that Minato, their leader, sacrificed himself by sealing the Nine Tails into his newborn child. Even if it is emphasized again and again that the newborn is a hero and that Minato wanted it this way, the people of the village cannot help but think "the demon fox killed our leader, hurt our family, and destroyed our village". They will continue to equate Naruto with the demon fox no matter what. Nothing can change that.
Hell, it would have been damn worse for Naruto if the Third Hokage didn't outlaw speaking of the incident with the Nine Tails. Rumors would have been even worse and people would probably try to kill Naruto. That's why the Third Hokage did it. He knew that the people of the village wouldn't be able to calmly comprehend the situation and would blow things out of proportion. It's for the same reason that the United States once outlawed being anti-war. People can't be expected to think rationally.
There was also the ongoing threat of if people knew Naruto was Minato's son that his safety would be in danger. Remember how Minato single handedly killed 1000 Iwagakure ninja? Minato was probably made out to be some kind of Saddam Hussein or something. People would be constantly trying to kill Naruto. This was, again, thought of by the Third Hokage in an effort to protect Naruto in a time of public panic and distraught.
And then you have to understand that nobody is perfect. The Third Hokage handled the situation to the best of his ability given his circumstances. Think about it. A giant demon fox just attacked and almost completely annihilated the village. Do you think the people of the village would be calm and understanding? Absolutely not. The same thing happens in the real world when something big happens. The Third Hokage handled it pretty well given the hand he was dealt. He simply didn't handle Naruto himself correctly and didn't raise him correctly as he was too concerned with the village and protecting Naruto's identity as a jinchuriki and Minato's son. You cannot expect the guy to be omnipresent and the perfect all around person. He's going to fuck up, and the upbringing of Naruto was a biggie.
The reason why Naruto didn't "question any of this" is because he was brought up in this hostile environment with no parental love or guidance. When you grow up hated all your life you are going to think its natural, and as a child you don't have the intellect to think "Wait... this isn't right. Why am I being treated this way?" And at times, he probably did question it. He just didn't know what to do. Hence why he became a troublemaker to get attention.
TL;DR: You need to sometimes think about these things. The way Kishimoto portrayed it is actually very realistic and its a shame that not many people actually realize it.
To the people of the Narutoverse, the nine tailed beasts are the equivalents of demons. Note how in Part 1 both Kurama and Shukaku are frequently referred to by this name. This is the same for most of the uninformed in all the countries of the Narutoverse. Many people probably do not even believe them to be real. This is where all the rumors surrounding them came from.
Some of these rumors include the one about the Nine Tails appearing in times of conflict/hatred and how the citizens of Sunagakure came to believe that Shukaku itself was a living ghost of a corrupted priest sealed inside a tea kettle. This just goes to show you how the people of the villages are. And it's pretty realistic actually, when you stop and think about the rumors people spread about the people in power and such.
You cannot expect the people of the villages to be able to grasp these concepts immediately without it causing a shitstorm of events. These people probably hardly understand chakra as it is, let alone the concept of sealing mass beasts of chakra into children to make living weapons. You're giving the people of the villages far too much credit when in reality they are just like us and and too indulged in their own world to really care to understand how the world works. They're selfish like that.
The people of the village are really brought up to think that their village is indestructible and safe. They refer to the Hokage as their lord and believe that as long as the Hokage is around, nothing can defeat them. It's this nationalistic thinking that convinces people to participate in the wars that the villages wage and makes them want to die for it. The people of the villages are subject to the same propaganda that we are in the real world
Hence why you should be able to understand that when the Nine Tails' Rampage happened, and Naruto was said to be host of the Nine Tails, a massive shitstorm happened and rumors spread about like wildfire. These are people who just had their homes destroyed by this very "demon". Do you really expect them to calmly comprehend the situation or understand what a Jinchuriki is, let alone why they are necessary?
If people understood just how unstable Jinchurikis are, they would become even more fearful of the Jinchuriki then they already are. It's bad enough they hear that creatures they believe to be demons are sealed within these children, but if they know that these same demons can be unleashed at any time, destroying their home as they know it, they're gonna be pretty damn fearful. Just look at Killer Bee. He was said to have went on a rampage in the Cloud many times. It's no damn wonder why everyone in the village feared him.
Like I said, the people in these villages aren't the reader and don't possess the same knowledge we do. As the reader, we know pretty much everything. We know just what should be done in every situation because we possess all this knowledge. You have to take into account that these people of the villages don't.
And like I said, they worship the Hokage. So say they're told that Minato, their leader, sacrificed himself by sealing the Nine Tails into his newborn child. Even if it is emphasized again and again that the newborn is a hero and that Minato wanted it this way, the people of the village cannot help but think "the demon fox killed our leader, hurt our family, and destroyed our village". They will continue to equate Naruto with the demon fox no matter what. Nothing can change that.
Hell, it would have been damn worse for Naruto if the Third Hokage didn't outlaw speaking of the incident with the Nine Tails. Rumors would have been even worse and people would probably try to kill Naruto. That's why the Third Hokage did it. He knew that the people of the village wouldn't be able to calmly comprehend the situation and would blow things out of proportion. It's for the same reason that the United States once outlawed being anti-war. People can't be expected to think rationally.
There was also the ongoing threat of if people knew Naruto was Minato's son that his safety would be in danger. Remember how Minato single handedly killed 1000 Iwagakure ninja? Minato was probably made out to be some kind of Saddam Hussein or something. People would be constantly trying to kill Naruto. This was, again, thought of by the Third Hokage in an effort to protect Naruto in a time of public panic and distraught.
And then you have to understand that nobody is perfect. The Third Hokage handled the situation to the best of his ability given his circumstances. Think about it. A giant demon fox just attacked and almost completely annihilated the village. Do you think the people of the village would be calm and understanding? Absolutely not. The same thing happens in the real world when something big happens. The Third Hokage handled it pretty well given the hand he was dealt. He simply didn't handle Naruto himself correctly and didn't raise him correctly as he was too concerned with the village and protecting Naruto's identity as a jinchuriki and Minato's son. You cannot expect the guy to be omnipresent and the perfect all around person. He's going to fuck up, and the upbringing of Naruto was a biggie.
The reason why Naruto didn't "question any of this" is because he was brought up in this hostile environment with no parental love or guidance. When you grow up hated all your life you are going to think its natural, and as a child you don't have the intellect to think "Wait... this isn't right. Why am I being treated this way?" And at times, he probably did question it. He just didn't know what to do. Hence why he became a troublemaker to get attention.
TL;DR: You need to sometimes think about these things. The way Kishimoto portrayed it is actually very realistic and its a shame that not many people actually realize it.
Last edited:
- Approve 1
- Show all